It was Teel who found him, and Teel found him by his boots.
We stood on the ferry road in a thin wind with the Sheriff and Mr. Boyce and the blown horse, and nobody could think what to do with a gig that had lost its owner. Teel went down on his heels beside the near wheel and looked at the frozen mud for a long moment, as another man might look at a letter.
“Heavy,” he said. “Flat in the sole. A nail gone from the left heel.” He lifted his head. “It is the man in the tunnel, Sheriff. It was never anybody but Mr. Crane, and that is why I could not say it. He walks as he talks.”
“That was sawdust. This is mud, sir, and mud keeps a man’s mind.”
The prints went away from the gig along the shore, and they were not the prints of a man walking. They wandered. In two places they stopped altogether, where somebody had gone down on hands and knees. They ended, a quarter of a mile along, at the loading door of the company’s old quay ice house, a squat black shed the village used for its own cutting in January, with the hasp unfastened and the door open the width of a hand.
I do not like that width. I never will.
He was lying on his face in the sawdust, in his shirtsleeves, with his arms flung ahead of him as though he had meant to crawl farther. A large man, waistcoat undone, watch chain trailing in the dust. For a moment nobody moved.
“Is he—” said Mr. Boyce.
“No,” I said, because I had my fingers on the thick red neck. “He is cold and he is slow and he is not dead. He has been sick a great many times. Teel, his coat. Deputy, the cart. Sheriff, would you send a boy for Dr. Hollis, and not for Dr. Rainsford.”
“I should not have dreamed of it,” said Sheriff Colby.
We took him up to the Hall in the Landing’s hay cart under three blankets, a ton of Crane in a very small space, and Dr. Hollis met us in the yard with his sleeves rolled. He had the man in the old blue guest room in ten minutes, and the iron and magnesia in him in twenty. We sat up all that night, the doctor and I, on either side of the bed, with a basin and a lamp and a great deal of milk. Crane was sick until two. After that he was only grey. At five o’clock on Wednesday morning he opened one eye and said, in a hoarse small voice nobody who had ever heard Mr. Crane would have recognised, “Capital.”
“Do not talk,” said Dr. Hollis.
“My boy,” said Mr. Crane. “Is he—”
“Mr. Caldwell is alive, and well, and has been fed bread by a woman with a conscience. You are the one in the bed.” Dr. Hollis wiped his spectacles. “You have been given arsenic in a very large dose, and you were saved by your own stomach and the temperature of an ice house. How did you take it?”
It was the tin. Of course it was the tin. I had known it before Crane said the word. A flat round tin of cocoa, with a Troy label in blue and gold, had come to Crane’s rooms on Saturday by hand, left with his landlady, with a card that read With the compliments of the Trustees.
“A kindness,” he whispered. “After Sunday. I thought they meant to make it up.”
“And you drank it.”
“Not that one. I do not hold with cocoa. I left it on my desk.” He closed his eye. “A note came, to go to the quay at ten. Bring the key. Wren was going to give me the whole of it, the whole business with the stores, in private. His hand. I knew his hand.”
“Did you see him?”
“There was a lantern in the door.” The big cracked voice slowed. “It was held low. Under the chin, so I could not see a face. I thought it was a joke. I said Wren, don’t be a fool, and a whisper said, Come in, Mr. Crane, it is cold, there is a kettle. And there was. On a little stove. He gave me a cup of cocoa, my boy, to warm me, and I drank it, because I was not afraid, and it was only when I had it down that I smelt—”
“What?”
“Peppermint.” His eye opened. It was a good blue eye, pouched and bloodshot, and I was sorry for it. “I thought, Edmund. I said Edmund, and the lantern went out.”
I felt the room turn very slightly, as a floor does under a ship.
“And the stove,” I said. “In your office.”
“I do not light my own stove. I have never lit it in my life.”
“And the lantern that was held under the chin. Mr. Crane. Did you ever carry one, to the pond, to a woman who walked in her sleep?”
For a moment I thought he had not understood. Then the colour, such as there was, went out of his face, and he put one great hand over his mouth. I saw that it was shaking, and I saw why, and I was ashamed I had needed to ask.
“I do not go near water, Miss Whitlock. I went through the ice on the Kinderhook at nine years old, and my father pulled me out by the hair, and I have not walked within a rod of a pond since. Ask any man at the Landing. I will cross the river by the bridge, and I will not look down.” He swallowed. “I never carried a lantern to that pond. If I had been there, I should have shouted for the whole county.”
“Then why does everybody say you did?”
“Who is everybody?” said Mr. Crane.
I did not answer.
“I will tell you what I know,” said Mr. Crane, “because I am not a clever man, and I should like to be a living one. The loaf. Every Michaelmas I carry the blue loaf to the Hall for the master’s lady. I do not make it. I do not order it. It comes in a box, from Mr. Pruett’s office, with a card, in Josiah’s own custom, and I deliver it. For eleven years.” He gave a ghastly smile. “I thought it was a kind thing, giving. It was the only way I knew how. And the key, the fourth, to the tunnel. I lent it in July to young Wren, for a stock count. He gave it back in August. I never looked if it was the same one.”
“And Mrs. Honora,” said Dr. Hollis.
“She asked me one day in the garden, in the summer she died.” The voice dropped. “She asked, very sweetly, who it was that put the sugar into her bowl. I said, Mr. Caldwell does it himself, madam, on a Saturday. And she looked at me, my boy, with the kind of look I have seen on a horse, and said, Then it was not a dream.” He turned his face to the wall. “I have not slept a night right since.”
Dr. Hollis told him to rest. I went out.
I did not go to my room. I went to the schoolroom, which was empty, and the sun was only just coming through the windows at the end, and I took out of my diary the thin blue sheet I had had pushed under my door on Monday night. From my other pocket I took the other, the old one, the one Lavinia had given me in the cellar, folded and soft with reading. I spread them side by side on Rosalind’s desk.
They matched. The round, uphill slope, the small curl on the capital H, the tail of every y going out like a cat’s. Anybody would have said so.
Except that I am a forger, and I know that what is hardest to copy is not the shape. It is the habit under the shape. And there, at the end of every word in the letter that was written in 1882, the pen went straight through to its last stroke, as a woman’s pen does who is writing against time. And at the end of every word on the paper that had come under my door, the pen was lifted a hair, a very small hesitation, before the final stroke.
I knew that lift. I had spent four months of evenings learning it, in another woman’s hand, and had thought it was Mrs. Lyle’s. It was not Honora’s hand. The second wife had not written to me.
I sat with the two papers under the window until the sun had reached the desk, and I knew exactly whose pen had.

