I did not tell Matthias about the note until breakfast, and then I told him in front of the Sheriff, because I have learned that a thing said in front of a Sheriff is a thing nobody can say you hid.
“Somebody wishes me in Crane’s office,” I said. “I cannot say who. The hand is a dead woman’s, or says it is.”
Sheriff Colby read the paper twice, held it to the light, and put it in his pocketbook. “I was going there in any case, Miss Whitlock. A man who is ordered to my office with the books of a company and does not come is a man who is somewhere. I shall be glad of somebody who notices things.” He glanced at Matthias. “And somebody who is not you, Mr. Caldwell, if you will forgive me. The ice company is a delicate place for the owner to be searched in.”
“Take her,” said Matthias, and looked at me, and for a moment neither of us could think of a thing to say in front of the Sheriff. “Take Teel. And Eleanor, you will eat nothing.”
“I have the Three-Hand Rule,” I said, “and a pocketful of bread.”
The Caldwell Ice and Cold Storage Company keeps its office in a long brick building on the quay at Tarrow Landing, with a loading door on the river side and a bell over the street door that rang twice when we went in, which made me look round for Mrs. Dunning. It was only a clerk. He was a very old man in sleeve garters, with ink to the wrist, called Mr. Tibbs, and he stood up from his high desk like a heron that has been startled in a reed bed.
“Mr. Crane,” said the Sheriff.
“Is not in, Sheriff. He has not been in since Saturday noon. I sent a boy to his rooms yesterday afternoon and the landlady said he had gone out at ten on Saturday night, in his greatcoat, and not come back.” He wrung his hands. “I have kept the books straight these thirty years. I should like it understood.”
“It is understood, Mr. Tibbs. Whose is the inner office?”
“Mr. Crane’s. It is locked.”
Deputy Lyman, a large young man with the shy grace of a plough-horse, put his shoulder to it. It was not locked so much as shut. The room within was small and square, with a rolltop desk, a stuffed pike in a glass case, and a cast-iron stove in the corner that was still warm.
“It has not been lit these two days, Sheriff,” said Mr. Tibbs, behind us, in a thin voice. “I light it myself, at seven. It was cold on Monday.”
“It is not cold now,” said the Sheriff.
I took the tongs from the hearth, and the Sheriff opened the door of the stove, and the heat came out in a breath. Inside lay a heap of black leaves, curling, each one a page. Somebody had fed the stove a ledger at a time and let each one burn halfway, and then, as a man does who has been interrupted, or whose courage gave out, had left them. The edges of the pages were still glowing red.
“Pull them,” said the Sheriff. “Carefully.”
I knelt on Mr. Crane’s hearth rug and pulled them with the tongs one at a time, and laid them on the Sheriff’s handkerchief, and blew on each as one blows on a child’s porridge. Most of them were ash by the time I had them out. Three were not.
The first was a column of dates and sums, in a hand I had last seen on a bottle and in a green docket book. It was upright. Each stroke was built, as if it had been put up with scaffolding. Every month for four years, in the same stiff pen: E. Rainsford, M.D., attendance on the master, $40. And in the margin of each, smaller, in the same hand, the initials appd. O.P.
“Pruett,” said the Sheriff.
“Mr. Wren’s hand,” I said. “Mr. Pruett’s initials.”
“The doctor was paid by the company, then, and the lawyer approved it.” He turned the scrap over with one finger. “I had thought it was Mr. Crane’s money.”
“It was,” said Mr. Tibbs, behind us. “That is to say it was entered as his. Mr. Wren came every month to inspect the accounts for the trustees. I thought him a very careful young man.”
The second thing I pulled out was a burned corner of a letter with a Troy grocer’s name on it, which I put in my pocket without thinking why. And the third, which had been at the very back of the heap, and was singed along three sides, was the last page of a printed deed.
It was very handsomely printed. It said that the party of the first part, being the owner or his lawfully appointed trustees, did hereby grant, bargain and sell to the Hudson Valley Terminal Company, of the city of Albany, the bluff known as Blackwater Bluff, with the Hall and gardens thereon, the whole of the river frontage, and the three ice houses on the shore, for the sum of sixty-two thousand dollars. A line at the foot, left blank for the signature, said it was to be executed at noon on Friday, the twenty-first of November.
I read it twice. I felt as though I were reading a letter addressed to me by a stranger who knew a great deal about my house.
“Friday,” said the Sheriff.
“Friday the twenty-first. The same day Mr. Pruett has asked Squire Pell to hold Lavinia.”
“A coincidence.”
“Sheriff,” I said, “I have lived twenty days in that house, and I have not seen a coincidence yet. I have seen a great many people who were good at being quiet.”
He gave me a mild look, over the deed, like a deacon who has caught the organist in a joke. “Go on.”
“The deed says the owner or his trustees. Mr. Caldwell will not sign. So the Hall can be sold only if Mr. Caldwell is unfit, and the trustees act. That was what Sunday was for. Dr. Hollis stopped it, but nobody withdrew the deed. It is still dated for Friday. And the one thing in Josiah’s will that stands between the trustees and the bluff is a wife.” I heard my own voice go dry. “If Mr. Caldwell died tomorrow, Lavinia would be mistress of the Hall. Unless she were in prison.”
“Miss Whitlock,” said Sheriff Colby, “I think you had better stop telling me things I shall have to write down.”
There was one more thing, and I nearly missed it. In the margin of the deed, along the scorched edge, somebody had written a line in black pencil, in a large, loose, impatient hand that I knew from six dinners, with the tail of every letter flung out as if it were about to say Capital.
I will not sign. B.C.
And beside it, a small round ring where somebody had put down a glass of brandy.
I looked round the room. On the washstand behind the door there was a towel, folded over the rail, and when I put my face near it I smelled something sweet and sharp at the same time, like a clove-studded orange left too long in a drawer. Bay rum.
Honora wrote that her lantern-man smelled of peppermint and under it, bay rum. I had had it in my diary for five days without a name. I had a name now, in a dead woman’s handwriting, in a note I did not trust. I wrote the three wrong things in that room on my cuff in pencil, as I always do. The stove lit by somebody when the clerk was out. The deed saved when everything else was burned. A man who writes I will not sign in the margin of a paper, and then burns it, and then leaves it.
“Sheriff,” I said. “Whoever lit that stove is a person who wanted us to find these three pages and no others.”
“Or a man who ran out of nerve,” said Colby.
“Or a man who ran out of time.”
The street bell rang twice. It was the stationmaster, Mr. Boyce, out of breath, with his cap in his hand and his boots, new as ever, covered in river mud to the ankle. I had never seen him run. I had not known it was something he could do.
“Sheriff. Mr. Teel said to find you here. It is Mr. Crane’s gig.” He gulped. “It has been standing at the ferry road since morning, with the horse blown and the harness hanging. I have counted it six times. I did not like to say nothing.”
“And Mr. Crane?”
“That is the matter, Sheriff,” said Mr. Boyce. “There is the gig, and the horse, and the greatcoat on the seat. And there is not a trace of Mr. Crane.”

