Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 17

Chain of Custody

MR. WYNN: State the date and time you first touched the item.

A. Sunday, five-oh-six p.m. Evangeline Prejean's kitchen.

MR. WYNN: And when did you last touch it?

A. Five-nineteen. With my fingertips.

Calder Wynn has not slept, and he has dressed for it. His cardigan is the same one, buttoned wrong. He receives me at nine on Monday morning in a conference room on the fourth floor of the State building in Port Sable, a room with a long table and a window onto a parking structure, and he does not offer a chair until Pru clears her throat.

"Thank you," I say.

"Do not thank me. Sit down and listen." His voice is perfectly even. "You read the book."

"I read the last page. And the first thirty."

"You handled it."

"With my fingertips, by the edges. I did not touch the glued sheet. I counted the pages with a pencil." I keep my hands on the table. "I wrote down the times. I called you within nine minutes."

"I am aware. That is why I am speaking to you in a room instead of a hallway." He sits across from me, and for the first time I see how much he is holding down. "I can't have a witness who reads the evidence before I do, Ms. Fenner. Anything you tell me about its contents, a defense lawyer will call contaminated. The best thing in it is that you can read your own forgery and say why it's false, and the worst thing is that you read it before I could stop you."

"I know."

"Do you?"

"I know what a chain of custody is." I say it quietly. "I've watched people argue for a day about a single missing signature on a property tag. I wasn't treating it like a letter, Mr. Wynn. I was trying to be the first witness to say what it was."

He studies me. Behind him, on the wall, a clock ticks at nine-oh-eight.

"Mr. Teague is not in custody and is not in my office," he says. "He said he would come at nine. It is now nine-oh-eight. The state police found his Buick in the harbor lot with the engine running, and nothing in it but a hat."

"He wouldn't leave his hat."

"No." Wynn presses two fingers to his eyes. "Everybody is very certain about what he wouldn't leave. I am only certain that he left."

Pru says, "Is the lot under camera?"

"It was. The camera on Quay Street was disabled by a work order that someone filed on Friday." He lets that sit. "I will not tell you who filed it."

I do not tell him I can guess. I have filed a work order on a floodlight, and I know the sound that kind of paper makes.

At ten o'clock a woman arrives with a briefcase, a tall, precise woman in her sixties named Dr. Ilse Brandt, who examines questioned documents for the state crime lab. She wears white cotton gloves and a magnifying visor pushed up like a welder's. She looks at the black book through a glass, once, from three inches away, and then at me.

"Your handwriting," she says.

"The last page appears to be."

"It is a skilled imitation. It is also a traced one, in part. See the pen lift here, and here." She puts a gloved finger over the paper without touching it. "A person writing freely does not lift in the middle of a letter g. He lifts after, at the loop. Whoever made this was following a model."

"Can you prove it?"

"I can say it is consistent with tracing and not with free writing. Whether a court will agree is a different question." She takes off the visor. "I will need exemplars. A great many. From today, and from years ago, if you have them. You should know that I have been doing this thirty-one years and no one has ever asked me to prove the handwriting was forged by a man who also wrote the words."

"The words are his," I say. "'Family does what family does.'"

"Yes. So I read."

She sets up at the end of the table. For two hours I write for her. She gives me a lined pad and tells me to copy a paragraph in ordinary speed, then slowly, then with my left hand, then standing. I write the week's date and the name of the ferry. I write "I know," forty times, because she asks for sentences I use. Then she asks me to write "I think I should say what happened," and I stop.

"I won't," I say.

"Please."

"It's his sentence. I'd be forging it."

She looks at me over her glasses. "You would be producing a sample, under supervision, for the purpose of comparison."

"I understand that." My pen hovers. "I still don't want to."

She lowers her gaze to the page. After a moment she nods and writes something in a small book of her own. I realize, later, that it was probably the best exemplar of the morning.

It is almost noon when Wynn's assistant, a young woman with a blunt bob and a very polite voice, puts her head into the room.

"Mr. Wynn. A courier from the District Attorney's office. He says it can't wait."

The envelope is long and stiff, with a county seal across the flap. Wynn slits it with a letter opener and reads the first page. His face does not change, but I have spent a week learning what that means.

"Mr. Roark has resigned from the District Attorney's office, effective this morning," he says. "And has filed a sworn affidavit in the Marchand matter and the matter of Raymond Fenner."

"Saying what?" says Pru.

"Saying that on October sixteenth, five years ago, at two in the afternoon, Ada Fenner came to his office in the county counsel's building in a state of agitation and confessed to him that she had killed Walter Prejean." Wynn turns the page. "He states that he advised her to leave the state and said nothing because he believed her to be unwell, and that he has been, quote, tortured by the memory ever since."

Pru makes a tiny sound.

I look at my hands.

They are not shaking. They are very still. For the first time in a long while, I am almost grateful for a lie, because it is so enormous that I can see its edges.

"Mr. Wynn," I say, "what is the date again?"

"October sixteenth."

"At two o'clock."

"Yes."

"I was on the 6:05 a.m. Greyhound out of the Port Sable depot on October fifteenth. I got off at Mobile at 9:50. I took a room at a motel on Dauphin Street, which I paid for in cash and where I stayed for eleven days, because I did not have a clue what else to do." I hear myself speaking in sentences, in order, the way I would take dictation. "I have the ticket stub. It is in a coin purse in the red folder, in the credit union box in Birch Landing, with the motel receipt, because I could not throw away a piece of paper. The ticket is stamped."

Wynn has stopped moving.

"He did not know that," Pru says slowly. "He built a story on the one day he thought nobody could check."

"He was not in the room either," I say. "He knows a date. He doesn't know a bus schedule. A man who knows bus schedules would have put it on the nineteenth."

"You can prove you were in Mobile on the sixteenth."

"I can prove I was nowhere near his office."

Wynn picks up the affidavit and reads from the bottom.

"There is one more thing." His voice has dropped. "Mr. Roark's affidavit is notarized. The notary is a woman named Imogene Cade."

"Cade," I say. The word falls out of me before I know why.

"Do you know the name?"

"No." My pulse has started to climb. "Cade. No."

Dr. Brandt looks up from her notes.

"You said it twice," she says gently.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!