Toby Wray came in person.
He arrived at the Gap on Thursday at four in the afternoon, in a dented hatchback with its back seat full of cable, and he got out slowly, with a canvas bag over one shoulder and a pair of enormous headphones around his neck. He was a thin pale man in his thirties, with a beard that had not been shaped by anyone, and he stood at the end of the bridge looking at the booth as a man looks at a dentist's office.
Silas went out to meet him. He had read the letter aloud to everyone on Tuesday, and Wednesday had gone by in a long grim hush, and nobody had said the word. Nobody had asked.
"I'm not saying yes," said Toby, before Silas could speak.
"I know."
"I want that on the record. I said no on the speaker and I meant it. I'm a contractor. I rig microphones. I'm deaf in one ear." He tapped the left side of his head. "I don't have anything to give it. I haven't got a true thing. I haven't got a blank. I've got a ten-channel mixer and a bad back."
"Nobody's asking you to sing."
"No. That's what's wrong." Toby shifted the bag. "Edie Royce said an ear. I listened to that letter twice on the phone. She said somebody with every reason to say no. And I thought, I've done it for three months, every night, listening, and I didn't want anything. I wasn't being brave. I just couldn't stop." He looked at the bridge rail, and the creek running brown beneath it. "I'm only going to listen. That's all. If it's a trap, tell me now."
"I don't think it's a trap."
"That's not the same as no."
"No," said Silas. "It isn't."
They went in together.
It was already full. Opie sat on her stool with the ledger shut. Dovie had the crate. Hollis Royce stood by the shelf, and Wyatt and Marian and Walter against the walls, and Teddy in the corner with her slicker over her arm, and Hattie Bowen, who had driven in that morning from the bald with a thermos and a tin of biscuits and a look of grim purpose. The cot had been taken away. The place where it had stood was bare plank, with the shape of its legs pressed into the boards.
The kindling stool was by the door, where nobody had moved it. Toby looked at it a moment.
"I'll sit on the floor," he said.
"That is the correct answer," said Dovie.
He sat, with his back against the counter, and put the headphones on, and plugged them into the small gray box he took from the bag. He turned a dial. Then, after a moment's thought, he took them off again, and laid them in his lap.
"I don't think I want those," he said. "I think I want to hear it the way you do."
Nine o'clock came and went. Nobody spoke. Outside the stars came out in the long window, thin and clear over the ridge, and the road lay under frost, and the bridge a gray bar over the water. The frost lay late that year, and thick. It had not yielded since the last day of February. Silas sat on the floor with his shoulder against Wyatt's, and his hands between his knees, and for the first time in days he did not feel like a man who was waiting. He felt like one who has set a thing down, and does not yet know whether it will stay.
At nine-oh-nine, Toby breathed out.
It was four seconds, long and slow. Then he breathed in. Then out again. He did it without apparent intent, with his eyes shut, in the manner of a man settling down to sleep in a strange house.
The floor warmed.
It came up from the left, as it always had. One. Low, round, careful. Two, Mill Lip. Then the rest, one after another, each set down like a stone on a wall. Silas had heard it twelve times and it still made the hair stand on his arms. Six, the one from Orphan Ridge, with its soft closing sound. Seven. Eight. Nine.
And the space.
It opened, warm and wide and the width of a thumb. Silas saw Opie's pencil lift. He saw her look at the page, and at the blank line. He saw her put the pencil down.
She did not write. She did not say a word. She sat with her hands folded over the closed book, and let the space be.
Toby breathed out. Four seconds. In. Four seconds. His shoulders had dropped. He had his chin on his chest and his hands open on his knees, and he looked, Silas thought, like a man in a church pew who has stopped waiting for the sermon and begun, for the first time, to hear the building.
A minute passed. Two. The space did not close. It did not press. It sat in the bottom of the booth like a bowl of dark water, and Silas understood that nobody was going to do anything, and that this was it, and that it was the hardest thing he had ever sat through.
Then, from under the planks, a hum began.
It was not the count. It was not the ten voices. It was a single thin thread of sound, very low, and Silas knew it before he knew he knew it, five notes climbing, a flat third, a drop. Wyatt's tune. And after it, the second line. The clumsy, tender, uncertain second line, the lullaby, a man's own comfort sung to a river.
But it was not Wyatt's tune, and it was not Lon's voice. It was neither. It was something that had listened to both, and kept them, and was singing them back in the only way it knew, with a kind of grave and painstaking exactness, like a child reciting a prayer for a parent in the next room.
Take your time.
Opie made a very small sound. Her hand had come up to her mouth. Dovie sat bolt upright on the crate with her lips parted and her eyes wide.
"That's his," Opie whispered. "That is Lon's. That's how he did the turn."
It sang it through to the end, once, and it stopped. And in the silence that followed, from the same place under the floor, in a clear, small, childlike voice, so ordinary that for a second Silas did not understand what it had said, the thing said:
"Ten."
Nobody moved.
"It counted," said Hollis, hoarsely. "It counted itself."
"It did not count itself," said Opie. Her voice was very low and very careful. "Lon said it couldn't. It was counting something else. It counted him. It sang his tune, and then it said the number. It has put Lon in the tenth place." Her hand dropped. "It's counted my brother."
"Twelve," said Dovie, barely audible. "Held, home."
"Ten," said Opie. "And twelve. It doesn't matter. It's kept him." She bent her head. "It's kept him, and it said so."
Toby had not moved. He sat with his head against the counter and his eyes closed, and tears were running steadily down his beard. He did not seem to notice them. His chest rose and fell, four seconds, four seconds, and he said, very quietly, to the floor:
"I hear you."
It was all he said. It was not a verse and it was not a promise. A warm note swelled in the floor, and Silas felt it in his teeth, a long, slow, grateful sound, a sound like an exhale. The nine doors rang once, softly, all together, the chord he had not heard in days. Wyatt grabbed his arm.
And then, a long way below, something else began to speak.
It did not come through the booth floor. It came up under it, from beneath the stone, from beneath the ten steps and the landing and the warm dark room, from a place that had never once been sounded in any count. It was very deep, and it was very slow. It was a man's voice, dry and unhurried, with no breath in it, the voice of someone who has been saying a thing for a long, long time to nobody.
It said one word.
"Eleven."
The floor went still. Every light in the booth seemed to burn a little lower.
"There's no eleven," said Dovie, and her voice cracked down the middle. "There's no eleven. There are ten. Opal. There are ten. There is nobody."
The voice came again from the dark, patient, unhurried, a little closer, as if a man had risen from a chair and taken one step toward the stair.
"Eleven," it said. "Count me."

