The lid of the pheasant tin had rusted to the rim, and Hattie Bowen got it off with a bottle opener and a dry curse.
Inside lay a single envelope, long and cream-colored, gone the shade of weak tea. It had been folded in thirds and sealed with wax, a dab of ordinary candle wax, pressed with a thumb. There was no stamp. On the front, in a round upright schoolteacher's hand, someone had written four words.
To whoever answers ten.
"My granny never opened it," said Hattie. "She said it wasn't hers to open. I've held it up to the light, I'll confess. It's thick. It's written on both sides."
She laid it in Wyatt's hand. He looked at it as if it were hot, and passed it to Silas. "You read," he said. "I can't. My hands."
So Silas broke the wax. It came away in two clean halves. The paper inside was lined, torn from a ledger, and the ink had faded to a brown so pale he had to tilt it to the lamp that Hattie lit on the cable spool. The hut ticked and creaked in the wind. Outside, the bald was going blue, and the steel legs of the tower sang a long thin note.
He read it aloud, because there was no one else.
"To whoever answers ten. I do not know your name. I do not know if you will come. I am writing this on the eleventh of April, nineteen seventy-one, at a table in the Rankin Gap churchyard, with the stub of a pencil, because my husband says I must not climb the Gap again, and because I do not trust the post.
"My name is Edith Royce. I am thirty-eight. My husband is Thaddeus. You will have heard of him, or you will have heard of what he did, which is to go down the Hollow and sit in a room and not come up. I want you to know that he is not dead. I want you to know he is not lost. He is doing a thing he said he would do, and I let him, and I would let him again.
"I will tell you what he told me, in the five minutes I had with him at the lip, on the sixth of November, before he went back down."
Silas stopped. He swallowed, and went on.
"He said, Edie, it counts nine, and then it stops, and I do not think it knows what to do next. It has learned its numbers from the people who called it. Each door, one number. I said, then who counts you? He said, nobody. I am not a number, Edie. I am only the one who is there.
"I said, then it ought to know. He said, it can't be told. It is a child, and it will not be told by an old man that it has a tenth person in it. It has to be shown. Somebody has to count it who is not afraid of it, who does not owe it, who does not mean to take anything from it, and who does not mean to leave it. Somebody has to be the tenth by choice. If it is a duty, it will know. It always knows. It knows a lie in a clean shirt a mile off.
"I said, how will they know it is them? And he said, that is the thing, Edie. They won't. They will not want to. It will be somebody who has every reason to say no."
Hattie had sat down on her stump. She had her hands pressed together between her knees.
"I have thought about it for five months. I do not know what he means. I want to tell you what I have done. I have written the number ten in my Bible, on the flyleaf, next to my husband's name and mine. I have written a space beside it. I do not know why. It seemed the right thing to do. I would like it noted that I have not set a place for you. My husband told me not to. He said, you will make it a chair, and it is not a chair. It is an ear.
"That is the word he used. An ear. Not a mouth. Do not sing at it, Edie, he said. Do not call. Do not ask. It has been called by every living thing that ever stood at that lip. Be the first who only listens."
Wyatt had put his hand over his eyes.
"There is one more thing. I am not sure I ought to put it in a letter. But I have not slept, and I want it written down, in case the next person to read this is the only one who ever will.
"My husband said something at the end that I did not understand. I was holding the lantern. He was on the step, with one foot in the dark. He said, Edie, I have been in that room nineteen Novembers, and I think I know it now. It is not the oldest thing down there.
"I asked him what he meant. He said, there is a place below the room. Below the ten steps. It is not a stand. It is not a landing. It is a floor, and there is somebody on it. He said, I have never seen him. I have only ever heard him, in the dark, very far down, saying the numbers, very slowly, as if he is teaching them.
"He said, I think the thing learned to count from him. I think it counts nine because he taught it nine. And I think it is not afraid of him. I think it is afraid of being counted by him.
"He said, there is a second counter, Edie, below the first. And I do not know whose side he is on."
Silas lowered the page. His hand was not quite steady.
There was a long, flat silence in the hut. Hattie Bowen, on her stump, stared at the stove. Marian stood with her notebook shut against her chest and her mouth a little open. It was Wyatt who spoke, at last, in a cracked, very quiet voice.
"There's a letter on the back," he said. "You've not read it."
Silas turned the page. On the reverse, below a ruled line, in the same round hand but slanted now, written more hastily, as if added at the last moment with the gate already swinging, were three short lines.
"If it is you, my dear, and you have come, I would ask one thing. When it is over, and you have done whatever you have done, go and tell him I kept the stove lit. He will know what I mean. I kept it lit till the day I died."
Underneath, in a different hand, a hand that shook, someone had added a single line in pencil, years later.
"Edith Royce, d. March 3, 1999. The stove is still lit."
Hattie Bowen gave a small, sharp, startled sound, and put both hands over her face.
"Dear God," she said, through her fingers. "I remember that. Mama took me. I was twelve years old. We climbed the Gap in a snowstorm, and an old woman asked my granny to write that, and my granny said she would, and I thought it was the saddest thing I had ever seen. I didn't know." She drew a ragged breath. "I never knew what it was for."
"It's for him," said Wyatt. "It's for Thaddeus."
"It's for whoever answers ten," said Marian slowly. "That's what she wrote. And it's the first time anyone has told us what the tenth is supposed to do." She looked at Silas, and the lamp lit one side of her face. "Not a chair. An ear."
"A listener," said Silas.
"Somebody with every reason to say no."
"Toby," said Wyatt, and began to laugh, helplessly, with his face in his hands. "Oh, God, Toby."
Silas did not laugh. He was reading the last paragraph again, the one about the second counter, and a cold feeling had started in the pit of his stomach and begun to spread. He thought of the long, slow, four-second breath. He thought of the sound under the ten steps, the one nobody had ever heard in the doors' count. He thought of a thing that counted nine because somebody taught it nine.
It was Thursday in three days. He had a very clear, very bad idea of what would happen at ten past nine.

