Cyrus Eberly read the line with a flashlight held flat against the table, almost touching the cloth, so that the beam skimmed across the page at a long shallow angle and every ridge of the paper threw a shadow. It is the way he reads tree rings, and I had learned the trick from him in July. He called it raking light. It was past midnight on Saturday, and I had not slept, and neither had anyone.
We did it with ceremony. Teague stood at the foot of the table and kept the minutes. Voight sat in his place with his hands in his lap, and Frame sat beside him, because he had asked whether he might stay, and nobody had had the heart to say that the porters were waiting upstairs. Mrs. Pilcher, who would not leave, had her black hand in her lap under her white glove again and her good hand on her cup. And Mabel, who had been carried up to the break room by Junie at ten and put to bed on three chairs under Marge’s coat, was not there, which I was glad of.
“It is a palimpsest,” said Cyrus, very quietly. He had not raised his voice since the door opened. “Like the old parchments. Something written, scraped off, and written over, again and again. Only it was not scraped. The page has done it itself. The fibers are not cut. They are pressed down, flat, the way a leaf flattens when a hand lies on it. It is not a mark. It is the memory of a mark.”
“Can you read it?”
“I can read the strokes. Not the words.” He moved the beam. “Give me a minute. And do not breathe on it.”
We did not breathe on it. He worked for forty minutes, lifting the light a degree at a time, and calling out what he saw in the low flat voice of a man reading a core, and Teague wrote it in the notebook in a column, as I might enter a list of accounts.
“The oldest is at the left. It is deep. It is a capital, and a round letter, and a long tail. E. Gosnell, I would say, but it is one stroke from being Eben. It is dated by nothing. The ink was iron gall, I think. The page was wet.” He moved. “There are three more under it, in the same hand. He tried it four times.”
“Gosnell,” said Teague. “In 1915. Entered in the log. He sealed the vault.”
“He tried to sign,” I said. “He sealed the vault and then he tried to be its Surety. The book would not have him.”
“Why not?” said Felix. “He was an Auditor.”
“He was hungry,” said Mrs. Pilcher, very low. “Eben Gosnell was the hungriest man who ever kept the Association’s books. It was how he got the land.”
“Next,” said Teague.
“Another, below. It is smaller. A lowercase, a long loop. I think it is a name with a hyphen.” Cyrus frowned. “Ostrander. No. I am sorry. I do not know it. It is nineteenth century. It has been struck over three times.”
“There were a great many Auditors,” said Voight, gently. “They came, one after another, I am told, in the first years. They came at night, with a pen. It was the custom in the county for the Auditor to come down on the night of his appointment and try the line. It was thought to be an honor. I believe it was thought to be luck.”
“And it never took.”
“It never took.”
“Next,” said Teague.
“There is a very strong one.” Cyrus’s voice changed. “Black pencil. Hard. A woman, from the slope of it. An E, a period. A P, quick, and a long i. E. Pilcher, I think.”
There was a silence. Mrs. Pilcher did not move.
“I was Auditor,” she said at last, “in 1981. I came down in the August, on the night of my appointment, with a pen. I did not know there was a Keeper. I opened the door, in the ordinary way, with a key, which Mr. Voight’s father had left in the desk. I came down the stair.” She turned her cup. “There was a table. I never told anyone. I signed in a good hand, in ink, in the place for Surety, and I went up, and I was sure I had done something wonderful.”
“And?”
“And the next morning my hand was black to the wrist, and I was writing in my sleep.” She looked at the glove in her lap. “I thought it was the Lender’s doing. I thought that the book had taken my signature and punished me for it. I have spent forty years afraid of what I signed.”
“You did not sign,” said Cyrus, gently. “It is here. It is faint. It did not take. It is a pencil ghost. The line rubbed you out.”
“Rubbed out.”
“Within the hour. I think.” He lifted the light. “The page does not hold a hungry hand. It has never held anyone’s. But it does keep a faint shape, I think, of whoever tried.” He swallowed. “It is a very kind page, Mrs. Pilcher. It does not punish. It only declines.”
She sat quite still, a small, upright woman in a cardigan, and I saw the tears come down her face and fall on the cloth, and she let them, which she had not done in my sight in three years.
“If I did not sign,” she said, “what did I do?”
“I think you wrote in your sleep,” said Voight, “because you were the Clerk, and nobody told you.”
I could not look at her. I looked instead at Teague, who was writing, with an unsteady pen, a line in the notebook, and I saw it was the next name, the one Cyrus had not yet read, and that Teague had read it before Cyrus spoke.
“Continue,” said Teague. “Please.”
“There is a long run of them,” said Cyrus. “Hundreds. It is a single hand. The same one, again and again. Over all the others. I thought at first it was a flaw in the paper. It is a letter G and a letter H. They are always the same size. Always in the same blue.” He paused. “It begins in 1932. It runs two hundred and fifteen times.”
“Two hundred and fifteen,” said Frame, in a whisper.
“One every month. Not the year. The month. The first of every month, for eleven years, 1932 to 1943. And then once a year, every first of December, until last winter.” Cyrus lowered the light, and I saw it, the pale long stroke of a capital G, the neat cold H, laid over and over on the line with the exactness of a man who has done a thing a hundred times and means to do it again. “He signed it. Every time. In his own hand.”
“Hale,” I said.
“He came down,” said Voight, in a faint voice. “I told you he did not descend. It was the day he came. He stood at the foot of the shaft, and he asked whether the book was hungry. That was March. I never saw him in the room.” He put his hand to his mouth. “I did not see him come. I thought he stood at the top.”
“He did not come to the room,” said Teague, softly. “He wrote from outside. It is a long reach, for a man who does not come in. He has been trying to sign a Surety line for ninety-five years, from a stair, and the page has said no to him two hundred and fifteen times.”
Nobody spoke. Frame’s face had gone the color of the cloth.
“He cannot be Surety,” I said slowly. “He cannot eat. He cannot sit. He is the Lender’s own Auditor, and he is not allowed in the room. All this time. The umbrella. The word. All of it.” My arm lay on the table, in the candlelight, and the old green lines were still. “He does not want me to open it. He does not want to stop me opening it. He wants me to sign.”
“Why?” said Felix.
“Because I can,” I said. “Because it will take me.”
There was a long silence, and in it, from above, from the shaft, from the stair, I heard a sound that I had never heard in all the months I had known him. It was the soft, patient tap of an umbrella tip on stone. Three taps. A pause. Then three again, on the first rung, as one knocks on a door one has never been invited through.
“It is noted,” whispered Odell Frame, who had gone entirely gray, “that someone is on the stair.”

