They put Mrs. Dunning in my cell, because there was no other, and Mr. Boyce lit her stove with his own hands and would not meet her eye.
It was the longest afternoon of the week. Squire Pell said the matter of a drowned woman who was not drowned would want the county coroner, who would come on Monday, and that Mrs. Dunning could not be bailed on a Saturday because he had already put his boots by the stove. Mr. Pruett said, with perfect composure, that the examination of Mr. Caldwell’s fitness would go forward on Sunday, as agreed, since the clause concerned his own condition and the astonishing return of his wife did not improve it. Mr. Crane clapped Matthias on the shoulder again, and said “Capital, my boy, capital, a miracle,” and I saw that his hand did not quite close. Dr. Rainsford went away in his trap without saying anything to anyone at all.
I will say only that Fitch was brought down to the front hall at four, and looked at the thin woman in the grey wool for a long time, and then said, “You’re early. It’s only Saturday.” And that Lavinia knelt on the flags and counted his breaths against her cheek, eleven a minute, and that nobody who was there will ever again tell me that a child of six does not understand more than he says.
At seven Matthias came to the lockup in his greatcoat and asked me to come with him.
“She has asked for you,” he said. “By name. She said, the clever one, because I will need somebody to tell me what is true afterwards.”
“Where is Lavinia?”
“In the nursery, with a fire, and Birdie sitting on the floor to make certain she does not vanish.” His mouth did something I could not name. “I have not yet said one sensible word to her. I find there is none.”
Mrs. Dunning sat on the cot with her hands folded on the blanket, and her keys still at her waist. They had not thought to take them. She looked up and said, “Well now,” and I saw that she was a good deal smaller than she had been on Thursday.
“Agnes,” said Matthias. “Why?”
“Sit down, both of you. It is a long thing, and I am only going to say it once.”
She said it to the stove, in the voice she used for reading the lessons at church.
“Your father had four keys made for the tunnel, Matthias, when he cut the Great Vault. I will come to the tunnel. First there is Honora.” She wiped her hands on her apron, and found it was a blanket, and wiped them on that. “Dr. Rainsford told me that Honora walked in her sleep and should be locked in at night, for her safety. I locked her in, every night, in August of ’eighty-two, the twelfth, the thirteenth, the fourteenth. On the last night she cried, Matthias. She said, Agnes, for once, let me be a woman who can leave a room. I was tired, and I was sorry for her. I turned the key and I did not take it out. I left it hanging in the lock on the outside, turned back.” She looked at him. “I did not open the door. I only left it so that it could be opened.”
“Agnes.”
“In the morning it stood open, and her bed was cold, and I ran. Abner Teel pulled her out. He was seventeen. He has never been the same.” Her voice did not alter. “And the doctor said, there, you see, it was nerves, and he screwed the lid down himself before the vicar was in his stole. I have not said a word of it since. I have carried that key every day for two years and three months.”
“I never knew,” said Matthias, very low.
“You were out of your head, my lamb. You had been ill since the spring.”
I thought of the thread across the door, broken from the outside, and said nothing.
“And January,” said Mrs. Dunning. “Mrs. Lavinia came to me on the eighteenth, in the ice keeper’s rooms, where I was laying the stove. She said, Agnes, I am being killed and I do not know by whom, and if I die in my bed it will go on, and if I drown it will be a mercy to everyone. She had it all worked out. A shawl and a boot at the ice-cut, and the river to carry the rest. I thought, she will go mad if she stays in that house, and she will go to her grave if she goes to the doctor. So I took her down.” She drew breath. “I never told you, Matthias. I let you stand at the empty stone every Sunday and I let you think I did not know what it was to bury a thing that was not there.”
“The rosemary,” I said.
Her eyes came round to me. They were very light and tired. “Yes, miss. Every Sunday before the first bell. I leave it at her stone. It is the empty one, you see. I felt I had earned it. I could not bring myself to bring it to Honora’s.”
The stove ticked. Outside, somewhere on the platform, Mr. Boyce was winding his clock.
“There is one more,” said Mrs. Dunning, “and it is the worst, and I should rather you heard it from my mouth than from his.”
Matthias did not move.
“Eleven years, Mr. Crane has paid me ten dollars on the first of the month. ‘For the household accounts,’ he said. ‘For the children’s sake, Agnes. A man must know how his friend’s house goes.’ I took it. I thought it was an old servant’s wage for an old servant’s work.” She wiped her hands. “I told him who dined. I told him who was ailing. I told him when the lamp was lit in the cellar, and I told him in July you went down and talked to your jars, because I thought it would trouble him for you. I thought, he will send you a physician, and you will be well.” Her chin shook, once. “I never told him she lived. I never told him that. That much I swear, on all that I have.”
I had counted the dollars before she said them. I have no gift for liking a thing I am forced to add up.
Matthias stood. The cell was so small that when he did, his head nearly met the brick. He stood with his back to us, and his hands behind him, as he always does, and I saw the shoulder blades under the coat go hard.
“That will do,” he said.
She shut her eyes.
He did not leave. I waited. In my life I have heard that phrase end three conversations and begin none, and I held my breath for the fourth. He did not go. He turned round, and sat down on the cot beside her, which creaked, and took one of her hands in his right one, the one that could not feel, and held it, and looked at the wall, and I understood that he was telling her what he could not say. He had been a baby in those rooms under the Hall, and she had nursed him.
“I should be very angry with you,” he said, after a long time, to the wall. “And I find I am only tired.”
“It would be right if you were angry.”
“Yes. Presently.” He pressed her hand. “Agnes. You said the tunnel.”
She opened her eyes. From the ring at her waist she took a single key, a long dark one, not brass, with an old-fashioned bit, and put it in his palm.
“Josiah made four. The old Keeper had one. I have the second, and now you. The fourth was given to the manager of the ice company, in case of fire in the vaults. It has never been asked for back.” She did not need to name him. “At the far end of the Great Vault, behind the last racks, there is a door. The tunnel goes down through the bluff to the third ice house, where the carts load. Your father hauled ice up that way in the summers, when I was a girl.”
“Where it comes out,” said Matthias. “The third house, by the river.”
“Yes.”
I put my hand to my pocket, where I had a green button, and I said it aloud, because someone had to. “Teel said the hinges of the third ice house door were new-oiled on Monday. Nobody has had reason to open it since March.”
“I have not been to the third house in ten months,” said Mrs. Dunning. “I never oiled it. I swear it.”
“Then somebody has been through that door,” said Matthias, softly, “with Barnabas’s key.”

