Detective Brackett lasted forty minutes on Wednesday. I asked him how much of the footage he’d requested and he said ten minutes. I asked how much he’d shown at the preliminary hearing and he said thirty-eight seconds. Judge Abbadessa listened to the rest with her glasses pushed up into her hair and the tomato ticking, and when he finished she gave the jury an instruction about the Commonwealth’s duty that I would have framed.
It was a good day. I knew better than to enjoy it.
On Thursday the Commonwealth called the Honorable Arden Pike, and the room stood.
Cole had prepared him well, or Arden had prepared himself, which was worse. He took the oath with his left hand raised and the right one hidden in his lap, and Cole steered him through it like a boat he respected.
The preliminary testimony had been wrong in two respects, Arden told the jury, and he regretted it. He had not been walking. He had been parked at the corner since 11:12 because, as he put it, “I am seventy-one years old, I have a tremor, and I’d had a long dinner. I sat to gather myself.”
The jury looked at his hand, which he did not hide for once. It trembled on the rail.
He’d seen Levon on the steps. He’d seen him come down them.
A man had stopped at his window to ask the way to Main Street, and he’d told him. At 11:57, alarmed that the door had been left open, he’d gone to the house, looked in, and seen Mr. Fisk. “I should have called the police,” he said. “I was frightened and I was ashamed, and I went home. I came to the district in the morning. I am sorry for the lie I told in Municipal Court.”
Then Cole asked it. “Judge, did you know the victim, Leonard Fisk?”
“No.”
“Never met him?”
“No, sir.”
There it was. He said it to the jury without so much as a blink, on the record, in front of God and an alternate juror knitting a scarf.
At the lunch recess I took Levon into the attorney room behind the courtroom. “I’m going to use Kimmel,” I said. “It’s the only way to prove he’s lying. You asked me to tell you first.”
Levon stood with his back to the window. “Aram’s name will be said in front of those twelve people.”
“Yes.”
“Is there another way?”
“If there is, I don’t have it.”
“Then I think you’re about to do what I asked you to try not to do.” He looked at his own hands, and then at me. “You told me first. That’s all I can hold you to.”
He didn’t say go ahead. I took his silence for permission and would like to say I was sure.
I stood at the lectern at 1:40. I started on safe ground, because that is what Arden taught me.
“Judge, you told Municipal Court Judge Tillery that you were walking.”
“I did. That was wrong.”
“You told him you never sat in your car.”
“Wrong.”
“You told him you never entered 4417 Ferncliff Street.”
“Wrong also, and I regret it.”
“Which of the answers you gave on October seventeenth were true?”
“Objection,” said Cole, quietly.
“Sustained. Rephrase, Ms. Raman.”
A cross is a staircase, and I was nearly at the landing. “Judge, you told this jury this morning that you did not know the occupant of that house.”
“I did not.”
“Did you ever meet Leonard Fisk?”
“No.”
I lifted two documents off the lectern. A name-change petition. A docket sheet. “Your Honor, I’m handing the witness certified copies marked Defense One and Two. Judge, please read the caption on the second one.”
He read it. He read it a long time. I watched his lips form the words. Commonwealth versus Dale Edward Kimmel.
“Who was lead counsel in that case?”
“I was.”
“For whom?”
“For Mr. Kimmel.” His voice was low and exact. “A man who was acquitted.”
“And Defense One, Judge. A petition to change the name Dale Kimmel to Leonard Fisk. Granted eight years ago.” I took a breath. “Leonard Fisk was your client, wasn’t he? The occupant of 4417 Ferncliff Street was Dale Kimmel.”
For three seconds the courtroom had no sound in it at all.
“I did not know that Mr. Fisk was Mr. Kimmel,” Arden said, “until I stood in his hallway. I knew only Dale Kimmel. When I saw his face on that floor, I knew him.”
He turned, for the first time, and looked directly at the jury. “The fire that Mr. Kimmel was acquitted of setting killed a young man named Aram Kasparian. I’ve carried that boy for eleven years. I won that case, and I believed my client was guilty, and I’ve never forgiven myself. Why did I tell this jury I didn’t know the occupant? Because I was ashamed. Because I didn’t want my sin in this room.”
The pharmacist put a hand to her mouth. The woman who knitted had stopped.
“I’d like to say something to Ms. Raman,” Arden said.
“Judge,” said Abbadessa, “answer the questions.”
“I trained this young woman. She’s the finest lawyer I ever taught. She’s doing exactly what she should.” He looked at me and his eyes were wet. “I’m sorry it costs her. I’m sorry it costs everyone.”
I had no further questions. I’d just handed the jury the best motive in the history of murder, and the only man who’d emerged from the exchange looking like a saint was the witness.
Cole’s redirect took four minutes. “Judge, how did you recognize Mr. Kasparian on October tenth?”
“I sat fifteen feet from him for six weeks during the Kimmel trial. He sat in the second row every day, in a black suit. I’d know him anywhere.”
“No further questions.”
Renata found me in the hallway during the afternoon break. “The First Assistant just called me,” she said. “He wants to know why my best lawyer accused a retired judge of perjury in front of a jury.” She turned her mug a quarter turn. “I told him you’d found it on a camera. He said a camera won’t save your desk if this goes bad. I’m sorry, Priya.”
At 4:30 Cole caught me by the elevator. “Voluntary manslaughter,” he said. “Five to ten. It expires at nine tomorrow. You know what that jury heard.”
“I know.”
“I’d rather not take this to a verdict.” He clicked his pen twice. “I mean that.”
That night at the jail I laid it out the way I lay out every offer, the numbers clean as a bill.
“Take it,” I said. “Five to ten. Five years at the minimum, before any credit for time served. You’d be thirty-nine. If you go to the jury, they may convict on first-degree. That’s life, Levon. No parole.”
“No.”
“They heard Aram’s name. They heard motive, a false alibi and an eyewitness. I don’t try cases I can lose.”
“Ms. Raman.” He didn’t raise his voice. “How many clients have you pleaded?”
The question went into me like a needle.
“Eleven,” I said. “In seven years.”
“And the twenty-three you tried?”
“The ones I could win.”
“And the one you can’t forget?”
I didn’t answer.
“You have one. Everyone who counts has one. It was in your face the first day, when I asked.” He waited. “Tell me.”
“Terrence Mabry. Armed robbery with injury. Three years ago. He was twenty-six. I thought we’d lose, so I got him twelve to twenty-four. Afterwards I found out there was a witness I never chased.” My throat had closed. “He’s at a state prison upstate. I’ve never gone to see him.”
He didn’t pity me, which was a kindness. “I thought you believed me.”
“For the record, I do.”
“Then act like it.”
“I’m trying to keep you alive,” I said.
“I know.” He let a moment pass. “There’s something I haven’t told you, because I thought I could win without it. My father kept a book. Tuesdays. Names, amounts, dates, in his handwriting. Pike’s page is number eleven. It starts the month Kimmel walked.” He looked at me steadily. “I stopped paying in June. If I put that book before a jury, it ends Arden Pike. It also ends three judges, two detectives, a deputy district attorney and half a city council.”
“Levon.”
“I would rather lose than be the first Kasparian to use it.”
I sat there a long time. I thought about a sticky note on my desk. “Never ask a question you can’t survive.”
I had one witness left and a closing I didn’t know how to write.

