Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 8

The Rest of the Tape

The window stayed down for ten seconds. I counted them, because counting is what I do when something is happening that I can’t stop.

Then the man in the cap straightened, tapped the roof of the wagon twice with his open hand, the way you pat a horse, and walked away toward Cedar Street, hitch and all, until the edge of the frame took him. The window slid back up. The taillight did not flicker. Nothing in the station wagon moved at all.

At 11:34:14 Levon Kasparian crossed the street.

We watched him do exactly what he’d told me he’d done. Up the three steps. Palm flat on the door. A shove, a lean, a long stillness with his shoulder in the gap. That was the part Cole had shown in a hearing room, thirty-eight seconds including the empty street before he crossed, and then came the part he hadn’t.

Levon stepped back. He stood there another few seconds with both hands hanging at his sides, empty, open, like a man who’d been handed something and refused to take it. He went down the steps. He crossed the street. He did not look behind him.

“Never touched the inside,” Bernie murmured. “Not one foot.”

“No.”

“And nobody came out the front door before he went up.”

“Nobody.”

We ran it to the end because I wouldn’t let Bernie stop. At 11:36 Levon’s car sat dark. At 11:49 its headlights came on and it drove away. At 11:57:20, in the cold gray-green silence of the street, the driver’s door of the station wagon opened.

Arden Pike got out. He stood on the pavement for a moment, a tall figure with a hand against the roof, steadying himself. Then he walked, at the pace of a man who has made up his mind and doesn’t like it, along the sidewalk toward 4417. Up the three steps. Through the front door, the one that had stood open since 11:30, which he pushed wider with his left hand.

Two minutes. At 11:59 he came back out. He stopped on the stoop, and put his hand over his mouth, and stood like that.

Then he walked back to his car, and sat in it for five minutes, and drove away.

“Did you know the occupant?” Bernie said, very quietly, repeating my own question from the preliminary hearing. “Did you at any time approach or enter 4417?”

I said nothing. I had a legal pad in front of me with three columns and not a thing to write in any of them that I could stand to look at.

Levon sat under the jail’s one humming fluorescent tube. I’d told him everything we’d seen, and he sat very still.

“Describe him,” he said.

“Broad. Mid-fifties. A flat gray wool cap. A hitch in the left knee, as though the leg’s a half-second late.”

He closed his eyes. It was like watching someone read an address he already knew.

“Vart,” he said.

“Vartan Boghosian.”

“He drives my uncle. He taught me to ride a bicycle on the lot behind the Ararat Room, when I was six. He held the back of the seat for an hour and said, ‘I’ve got you,’ and let go, and I rode into a dumpster.” His voice was entirely flat. “I’d like to say it can’t be him.”

“Mr. Kasparian,” I began.

“You will not say my uncle’s name in that courtroom.”

“If I can show who that man is...”

“You can show the man in the passage. You can show the jury he exists, that he went in and came out, and that no one from the Commonwealth ever asked who he was. You can say you don’t know his name.”

“I know his name.”

“You know who you think he is,” Levon said. “Reasonable doubt is something you build from what you can prove, Ms. Raman. You taught me that on the first day. I would very much like to be a man who didn’t give the state his family on a guess.”

“And if the guess is right?”

He looked at me then, directly, the way he’d looked at the waiver. “Then I’d like to be the one who finds that out. Not a jury.”

I could have argued. A better lawyer, a cleaner one, would have gone through the Rules of Professional Conduct with him paragraph by paragraph. What I did was write VART in the HOPED column and turn the pad around so that he could see it, and then cross it out, so that he could see that too.

On the Friday before trial, at four, I filed my reciprocal disclosure with the Commonwealth, with a cover letter: one certified export of the camera footage at 4420 Ferncliff Street, all of it, from 10:31 p.m. until 12:15 a.m., in a sealed envelope. The letter was three sentences long.

Cole watched it in his office with me sitting across from him, because I’d decided, on the elevator down, that if I was going to blow up the Commonwealth’s case I wanted to be in the room when the shrapnel landed.

He didn’t speak for the first forty minutes. I listened to the radiator in his office instead, and to the faint hiss of a hundred pens being put down in the corridor at the end of the day. When the man in the cap leaned down to the wagon, Cole’s pen stopped clicking. When Pike went in, it clicked once and then went quiet, and I realized he’d lost count.

“Brackett had the ten minutes,” he said at last.

“He had the ten minutes. He showed the court thirty-eight seconds.”

“He told me the rest was cumulative.” Cole took his glasses off and pressed his fingers to his eyes. “I want to be very clear about something, Priya. I did not know. If I’d known there was a second man, a car, a retired judge who’d lied about being parked, you’d have had it in discovery.”

“I believe you.”

“You’re the only one in this building who would.” He put the glasses back on. “I’ll disclose Brackett’s edit to Judge Abbadessa in writing on Monday. The Commonwealth doesn’t hide things from juries.”

“That’s what I thought.”

“I’m not dismissing the case.”

“I wouldn’t expect you to.”

“I’d like you to think about why I’m not.” He looked at the frozen frame on his screen, the man in the cap at the window. “I’ll see you Monday.”

The jury took all of Monday to seat. We got twelve people and four alternates who swore they could be fair to a man named Kasparian, including a pharmacist, a dental hygienist, a woman who knitted through everything, and a retired mailman who looked at Levon with the open interest of someone who’d seen the name on a great many envelopes. Judge Abbadessa set her red tomato timer on the corner of the bench and let it tick.

Tuesday morning Cole stood to open for the Commonwealth.

He did it without notes, in his plain, tired, forgettable voice, which was the most effective voice a prosecutor can have. He told the jury about Leonard Fisk, a quiet man who liked his house tidy. He told them that on October tenth, at 11:23 p.m., someone had gone into that house through the side passage and killed him with a single blow.

“The Commonwealth will show you a camera across the street,” Cole said. “You’ll see two men on that block. One of them went in through the side. The other sat in a parked car for forty-two minutes, two doors from the house, and then walked up the front steps and put his hand on the door.”

I felt Levon go still beside me.

“Ask yourselves why a man would sit for forty-two minutes outside a house,” Cole said, “if he had no idea the other man was inside. Ask yourselves what he was waiting for. The evidence will show that the defendant did not act alone.”

The pen in Levon’s hand moved a tenth of an inch toward the edge of the table, and I watched him let it.

I had spent three weeks building a defense out of a camera. In nine sentences, Cole Whitaker had taken the camera and made it his. The video that was going to save Levon had just been recruited by the other side.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!