Cole Whitaker caught me at the elevator bank on the fourth floor of the Justice Center, which is where prosecutors do their hunting. The elevators in that building arrive when they feel like it. You can say a great deal to a person while you both look at a lit-up number that isn’t changing.
“Third-degree,” he said, without hello. “Twenty to forty. Because I like you.”
“You don’t like me.”
“I like your record.” He clicked his pen twice, a habit I’d watched him use since moot court, where I beat him in the final and he has never quite forgiven the judges. Cole was thirty-seven, with the kind of face juries trust: pleasant, tired, forgettable. “First-degree is life without parole, Priya. I can get there. I’d rather not spend six weeks proving it.”
“My client doesn’t plead to things he didn’t do.”
“Everybody’s client says that.”
“Not everybody’s client means it.”
He looked at me for a second too long. “Twenty-three and oh,” he said. “I’ve always admired how clean that number is. I’d just never want anyone to add up the cases that never reached a jury.”
The elevator opened. Neither of us moved.
“Judge Pike came in on his own Saturday morning,” Cole said, quietly, to the elevator. “Seventy-one years old, walked into a district station and gave a statement because he couldn’t sleep. That’s who you’ll be cross-examining. I thought you’d want to hear it from someone who isn’t going to enjoy it.”
That was a decent thing to say, and I hated that it was.
I went back to the Defender’s Office, rode up to nine, and went straight to Renata’s door, where she was already waiting with the door shut, which meant she’d heard. In the Defender’s Office, news doesn’t travel by email. It travels by someone’s cousin who works in the clerk’s office.
“He trained you,” Renata said.
“He taught me to try a case. I worked under him for exactly one year, my first. That’s not training, that’s a coffee order.”
“Priya.”
“All right. He trained me.”
“Rule 1.7. Your loyalty to a witness could materially limit your representation of a client. You can proceed if you reasonably believe you can do both, and if the client gives informed consent in writing. You disclose everything. If he says no, you walk, and I give it to Dolan.” She turned the mug a quarter turn. “Don’t give it to Dolan.”
“Dolan has lost four.”
“Dolan has lost four and sleeps well. Go.”
The waiver was four pages. I’d written it that morning, in the plain English I use when I’m trying to keep a client from signing something he doesn’t understand. At the jail I slid it across the steel table and watched Levon Kasparian read every word of it, including the footer.
It took him eleven minutes. I know because I’d counted the tiles on the wall by minute six. When he finished, he put the pages in a stack and tapped the edge square against the table, which I was starting to understand was how he thought.
“Paragraph three,” he said. “Counsel has a personal and professional relationship with the Commonwealth’s principal witness that may cause counsel to hesitate in cross-examination. Do you hesitate?”
“No.”
“Would you tell me if you did?”
“For the record,” I said, “yes. I would.”
“And paragraph four. ‘Counsel will not disclose to the witness any confidence of the client, nor to the client any confidence of the witness.’ Why would the Judge confide in you?”
“He wouldn’t. It’s boilerplate.”
“It isn’t. It’s the only sentence in four pages you wrote carefully.” His voice stayed level. “Respectfully, some part of you thinks he might tell you something you’d be forced to carry.”
It was annoyingly accurate. I’d put it in at seven a.m. without understanding why.
“What is he to you?” Levon asked.
“The reason I know how to do this.” I hadn’t planned to say it. “He’s the best trial lawyer in this city, or he was. When I was twenty-five he told me the truth about my first cross, which was that it was terrible, and why. Then he made me do it again.”
“Then it’s a real conflict.”
“It’s a real conflict.”
He uncapped the pen. “I’d rather have a lawyer who is conflicted and good than one who is clean and mediocre.” He signed with the same small, upright signature he’d used on the booking forms, and slid the pages back. “Thank you for telling me the truth about it. Most people would have made it sound smaller.”
“Most people would have been fired.”
“I fire people on Sundays,” he said. “It’s a slow day.”
I laughed. It escaped before I could count it. In a jail interview room, with a man held on a first-degree murder charge, I laughed, and Levon Kasparian looked at the table as if I’d handed him something, and then looked up.
That was the first thing I did on that case that I should have written down.
Arden Pike lived in Mount Airy, in a stone twin with a slate roof and a porch where the paint was holding on out of loyalty. I’d driven past it perhaps once a year since he left for the bench and never gone in. That evening the light was already going, and a green station wagon older than some of my clients sat in the driveway with a dent in the rear bumper he’d never fixed. He said a dent was evidence of use.
A basset hound answered the door first. He was named Habeas, and he looked at me with the grave disapproval of an animal who’d seen a great many lawyers.
“Priya.” Arden stood behind him in the hall, tall and a little stooped, white mustache, a cardigan with leather elbows. His right hand was in his pocket. It was always in his pocket now. “I wondered which of you they’d send.”
“Nobody sent me.”
“Renata Sobel sent you. She’s been sending the lawyer who can’t lose to difficult men since before you could vote.” He stepped back. “You’ll want tea.”
I did not want tea. I sat in his kitchen while he made it with one hand, and neither of us mentioned the hand. Eleanor’s chair was still pushed in at the end of the table, nine years after the funeral. The tea was too strong. He’d always made it too strong.
“I can’t talk to you about it,” he said. “You know that. I’m a witness. You’re opposing counsel.”
“I’m not here to ask about the case.”
“Then you came for the tea.”
“I came because I wanted to see your face when I told you I took it.”
He lowered himself into a chair. His eyes were exactly as I remembered, pale and patient, a judge’s eyes. They did not leave mine.
“Give it back,” he said.
“What?”
“Tell Renata you’ve reconsidered. Let someone else try it. Dolan will do.” I must have made a face, because he almost smiled. “Dolan will do adequately. Let Dolan cross me.”
“Why?”
“Because I’d prefer it.”
“That’s not a reason.”
“It’s the only one I can give you.” He turned his cup on its saucer. “I taught you a good many things. I taught you never to ask a question you can’t survive the answer to. Do you remember?”
“It’s on a sticky note over my desk.”
“Then take your own advice, Priya. Please.”
At the door he held it for me, the way he always had, and I stood on the porch with Habeas leaning against my shin. Arden’s hand came out of his pocket to steady the frame, and I saw it shake, one fine tremor, and then it went back where it lived.
“Precisely,” he said, to nothing I’d said, and he closed the door so gently I never heard the latch.
I stood there until the porch light came on. It was a long time before I understood what I’d seen. Arden Pike wasn’t afraid of being cross-examined. He was afraid of who would do it.

