Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 1

Twenty-Three and Oh

Twenty-three jury trials, twenty-three not-guilty verdicts, and not one of those clients had ever heard me ask whether he did it. I called that a professional courtesy. Levon Kasparian was the first person to call it professional cowardice, and he said it politely, which made it worse.

That was later. On the Monday morning it started, I was standing in Renata Sobel’s doorway on the ninth floor of the Defender’s Office, holding a coffee brewed during some previous administration, and Renata was holding a folder as if it smelled.

“Kasparian,” she said. Renata ran the Homicide Unit and spoke in telegrams. “Murder. Yours.”

“The Kasparians. Banquet hall, parking garages, the other thing nobody has ever proved.”

“The son. Levon. Arrested Saturday, arraigned Sunday, held without bail. The District Attorney froze his accounts Saturday night, so as of breakfast he’s indigent, and therefore ours. He fired the family lawyer yesterday. Ellery Sachs, who has represented that clan since I had hair.”

“Who else turned it down?”

“Everyone.” She turned her chipped tea mug a quarter turn on the blotter. “Press. Family. A case the Commonwealth thinks is a layup. Palm print on the victim’s front door, a plate reader that puts his car in Roxborough that night, and an eyewitness.”

“A good one?”

“Read it.”

I took the folder. It had the weight a murder file always has, which is not the paper but what the paper is allowed to do to a person.

“You’re the only one on this floor who doesn’t lose,” Renata said. “Twenty-three and oh. Try for twenty-four.”

“I don’t try for anything. I show up.”

“That’s what they all say,” she said, “right before they lose.”

Bernie Szymanski was waiting at my desk with a soft pretzel in a paper bag and a tote bag full of other people’s secrets. Bernie had twenty-two years in the police department before she came over to the defense side, and she still sat the way cops sit, with her back to a wall and her eyes on the door.

“Here’s the thing, kid,” she said, tearing the pretzel in half and offering me the bigger one. “I already went down to the Roxborough district this morning. Victim’s Leonard Fisk. Forty-nine. Estimates heating and cooling jobs for a contractor in Manayunk. No wife, no record, no enemies anyone can find.”

“That’s not a victim. That’s a ghost.”

“That’s what I said.” She pointed the pretzel at the folder. “Also, your mother called the desk line. She says your cell is going to voicemail.”

“My cell is on silent because I’m a professional.”

“She says Mrs. Venkataraghavan’s son has become a dentist. She’s only mentioning it.”

I counted that as one. I keep a tally of things I decline to feel before noon.

The jail on State Road smells like industrial lemon and wet coats. The attorney room had a steel table bolted to the floor, three chairs, and a window of wired glass that looked onto a wall. The man who stood up when I came in was taller than his booking photo and a great deal less tired than I’d expected.

“Ms. Raman. Thank you for coming on a Monday.” He had a low, level voice, with no theater in it. “The chair on the left doesn’t wobble. I tried them.”

“Mr. Kasparian.” I took the chair on the left. It didn’t wobble. “Before we start I’m going to tell you what I tell everyone. I don’t need to know what happened. I need to know what the Commonwealth can prove. Don’t tell me anything you wouldn’t want read back in a courtroom, and we’ll get along.”

He sat. He had a library paperback on the table, a tax manual, bristling with torn-paper bookmarks, and beside it a pen he’d been issued, which he laid parallel to the edge of the table with a fingertip.

“Respectfully,” he said, “I’d rather you asked.”

“Asked what?”

“Whether I did it.” He said it the way another man might ask whether I’d like water. “I’m told you’ve tried twenty-three juries. How many of those clients did it, Ms. Raman?”

“I don’t ask.”

“That isn’t what I asked.”

I opened my legal pad instead of answering. Three columns, the way I always draw them: KNOWN, PROVABLE, HOPED. All three were empty. It was the cleanest page I’d ever hated.

“I’m going to be sitting at a defense table for a year, maybe less,” Levon said. “I’d like to be defended by someone who knows what she’s defending. I realize that’s an unusual request.”

“It’s a ridiculous request. Most people who ask it want me to say I believe them.”

“I don’t want you to believe me. I want you to know.” He waited. “Please.”

For the record, it was the please that did it.

“Did you kill Leonard Fisk?”

“No.”

I watched his hands, because I always watch the hands. They lay on the table, open. They did not move.

“Where were you Friday night?”

“I told the detectives I was at home.” The pen on the table was suddenly not quite parallel with the edge, and he fixed it with one finger, a tenth of an inch, like a man correcting a picture frame. “Alone. My phone was there. Anyone who wants to check will find that it never left the house.”

His no was the first answer a client had given me in seven years that I believed all the way down. The alibi was another matter; I’d seen the pen move.

I should explain why that was a problem. Believing a client is a liability. It makes you reckless in cross-examination and soft in a plea negotiation and stupid at three in the morning, when the only person awake is you and what you think you know. I had built a career on never knowing, and on this man’s word I was already knowing. I put it down to the lemon smell and the long weekend.

“Mr. Kasparian, why me?”

“Mr. Sachs works for whoever pays the bills,” he said. “My family pays the bills. I wanted a lawyer whose paycheck had nothing to do with my last name.” The corner of his mouth moved. “Also your office has a reputation. A lawyer who doesn’t lose is either extraordinary or very careful about which fights she takes.”

“Those aren’t exclusive.”

“No,” he said, “but I’m curious which one you are.”

I hadn’t expected to be cross-examined in my own client meeting. I put on my professional expression, which I’d bought for the occasion seven years earlier and kept in good condition. “The Commonwealth has a witness. I haven’t read the file. That’s what I’d like to do next, with your permission, in this room, so you can tell me where it’s wrong.”

“The detectives wouldn’t give me the name.” He folded his hands. “Would you read it to me?”

I opened the folder. The affidavit of probable cause was five pages in the flat prose police use when they want a document to feel inevitable. Victim, address, time of discovery. The palm print, outer face of the front door. The plate reader on Ridge Avenue at 10:41 p.m. And then, on page two, a paragraph that began with the word WITNESS in capital letters.

Witness stated that at approximately 11:40 p.m. on October 10 he observed the defendant, whom he positively identified, descend the front steps of 4417 Ferncliff Street carrying a dark object in his left hand.

I read down to the name.

The eyewitness was the Honorable Arden Pike, retired. I read it twice, the way you read a typo, hoping the second pass would correct it.

It didn’t.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!