The tack room smelled of neatsfoot oil, old leather and forty years of a man not saying things.
Gus Ferreira stood in the doorway with his hands in his coat and looked at the peg. It was a plain nail, driven into a post at about the height of his shoulder, beside a hoof pick and a coil of baling twine. A loop of twine hung from it. The loop was whole. It was tied in the hard square knot a dairyman learns at ten and never forgets, and it held nothing.
"Tied it in eighty-six," he said. "Walt brought it over. He said, put it somewhere I can't lose it. I put it where I'd see it every morning." He lifted the empty loop with one thick finger. "I never took it off. It's not cut. It's not been untied."
"It went through the knot."
"Looks like."
"Gus. It went through a knot."
"I can see that, Doc."
She had driven out at seven with the clinic heater on high and her warm hands loose on the wheel, and the old tag in her coat pocket, and it had not occurred to her until she was on his gravel that she did not know how to start. He had been standing in the yard already, as if he had heard the truck coming across the section. He had walked her straight to the tack room without a word. Now he took his cap off and turned it round in both hands.
"Tell me about the hour," said Dess.
"Walt tell you?"
"Walt wrote it down. He didn't say what happened in it."
"Well." He said it the old way, flat, as the whole sentence, and then he laughed, one short breath, and shook his head at himself. "Quill said that to me last week. Said it exactly like I do. I about fell off the porch."
"Gus."
"I'm getting there." He sat down on an upended feed bucket. There was another one beside it, and he did not look at it, and after a moment she sat. "November of eighty-five. I was twenty-four. Dad had the farm, I had a pickup and a bad attitude. Walt called me at four in the afternoon and said, I need somebody to carry a chair. That's all. I carried a chair."
"Annelise's twin."
"I didn't know it was anybody's. It was a chair. We took it out to the barn on your family's place, the old dairy end, the bottom, where the cement had a patch in it the size of a grave." He turned the cap. "I set it down. He sat. There was a collie at his feet, a young one, red and white, with a crooked ear. They had just got him. Walt said he'd been given him that fall."
"Given."
"Walt said that. *Given.* I didn't ask who."
"What did you do?"
"What a neighbor does. I stayed." He looked at the floor. "I'd have gone home, Doc, but he looked so small. Walt. That was a big man. He was six three and he looked about like a boy at a bus station. I got a bucket and sat by the door. I sat sixteen hours. Marlene thought I'd run off with somebody."
She tried to see it. A young man with Gus's face and none of his silence, on a bucket in a barn at night.
"Nobody came. No one asked a thing. About midnight a light went on in the chair, down low, a tag, I figure, I couldn't see it right. Walt didn't read it out. He sat there with his hands on his knees and every so often he'd say something to the dog. And the dog sat on his feet."
"And at sixteen hours?"
"About noon. The next day. It went quiet. You could hear it go. And Walt said, *well, that's that.* And he said, *I got it wrong, Gus.* Then he stood up. He was stiff. I helped him." Gus stopped. His jaw worked once. "And the dog didn't get up."
"He stayed."
"He sat on the cement. Right where the chair had been. I mean the dog was on the floor, and Walt was on his feet, and the chair was still there, and the dog was looking at the lid. Not at me, not at Walt. At the lid. And Walt says to me, quiet, he says, *Gus, don't call him.* So we didn't call him."
"For an hour."
"A little more. I had my watch." He put the cap on the bucket beside him, and put his hand on the cap. "I think about that hour more than I think about my own wedding."
"What happened in it?"
Gus did not answer for a long moment. Outside, a Holstein bawled across the yard, one long sound of complaint, and the dog that guarded the dairy barked at nothing and subsided. A slab of light came through the dusty window and lay on the floor between his boots.
"It *hummed,*" he said.
She waited.
"Doc, a dog doesn't hum. A dog whines, a dog howls. I've got ears. A dog can't do what I heard. He sat there with his mouth shut, with his head up, and the sound came out of him through his nose. Low. Three notes. Down, down, and a rest, and then down again." He hummed it, a rough baritone with the break in the middle where a man hasn't used his voice for singing in thirty years. Three falling notes, a gap, and then the last one, lower.
"Again," said Dess, quietly.
He did it again. She listened with her head bowed and her hands loose between her knees.
"Walt knew it," said Gus. "I could tell. He took his hat off. He stood there with it over his chest like it was a funeral, and he never said what it was. When the dog finished he got up. Just like that. Shook himself and walked to the door and looked back. And Walt said, *All right, then.* And we all went and had breakfast."
"And the chair?"
"Stood there till the Wren man's people took it. They came in a truck. I helped load." His mouth did a wry thing. "That's where I got the tag. Next morning. He gave it to me on the porch. Said it came off the pup's collar when he shook, and could I keep it somewhere, because it was a thing that would be wanted."
"Wanted."
"That was the word." Gus shrugged. "I figured he meant by the pup."
"I think he meant now."
"I think he did, too." He picked up the cap at last and set it on his knee. "Walt made me promise something, that morning. Not to tell. I promised. Forty years I haven't said it to a soul, not Marlene. He said, *You tell my niece, if she's ever got that chair and that dog. Not before.* He said, *Not till the dog sits again.* And he said, *She'll know what it is.*"
"Know what?"
"The song, Doc. The three notes." Gus looked up, and for the first time since she had known him there was nothing flat in his face at all. "He said you'd know what song it was."
She did not answer. She was no longer in the tack room. She was in a dark cellar under a barn, on her knees in the cold, with an old woman's thin high voice coming up out of a bucket. She was in a kitchen with a pencil. She was holding a letter in which a woman had written *the treble line, kept, not echoed.* She had a ribbon in her pocket. She knew the hymn the way she knew the first dog bite of her career, in the muscles of the hand.
Three notes, falling, a rest, and a fourth.
"Gus," she said. "That's the last line. That isn't the dog's. That's the treble."
"Whose treble?"
"Maren's," said Dess. "He was humming Maren's part."

