The first person to answer was Marsh, and he did it with a point of order.
"If I might," said Marsh, from the gravel, and the whole yard turned. Elmore Marsh was seventy, in a good overcoat, with the minute book under his arm as always. He had been the Co-op's secretary since before Dess could vote. "I move that the Bin weighs what it holds. The county's pooled Yield, as shown on the last audited tally. I would be glad of a second."
"Second," said Bernie.
"You can't second, Bernadette, you're taking bets."
"I can do both. I'm a woman of parts."
"Marsh," Dess said. "It's a witness chair. It isn't a meeting."
"It is, in my experience, always a meeting." He said it gently and he said it to the chair. Then, to the tag, in the formal voice he used for minutes: "The Bin weighs what it holds."
Nothing happened for a count of five. A freight car creaked down the line. Then the tag, pale in the dusk, lifted and turned.
*WRONG.*
The lantern flickered. Dess felt something go, a small pull in the middle of her chest like a thread drawn through cloth. She looked at the dog.
Biscuit had not moved. He sat as he had sat, chin up. But the outline of him against the boxcar wall was a little less. It was the kind of difference you notice with an animal you know, the way a coat hangs on a dog that has lost a day's water. His ribs showed where they had not.
"Teo."
Teo already had the balance out. He put the wire to the dog's flank, and the needle shivered and sank and came to rest, and he wrote on his pad and showed it to her without a word.
*40.*
"Forty," she said. "He was forty-one."
"Forty-one at Christmas. It could be the water."
"He hasn't taken water."
"Then it is not the water." Teo capped his pen. "A pound. About the weight of a very good loaf. I do not care for it."
"I move that we not do that again," said Voss, and wrote it down.
It would have ended there, if the county had been a more cautious place.
By the next morning they had a line. They stood in the trodden snow along the siding, in the thin gold sun, in good coats, with their hats in their hands, because a thing that has been asked of you in front of everybody does not sit quietly. Dess had not asked anybody anything. The chair had. In Orrin County that comes to the same thing.
She stood by the boxcar door with her arms folded and Priya at her elbow and watched them come.
The first one that morning was Hank Almquist, who said the Bin weighed "a hell of a lot," and the tag said *WRONG,* and the dog was thirty-nine. Hank took off his cap and stood a while with his mouth open, looking at the dog, and then went and sat on his own tailgate and put his head in his hands.
The second was a woman Dess did not know, from out by Sorrel, who had driven an hour. She said the Bin weighed what the elevator weighed on its footings, and she had a figure, a good one, from a structural survey. The tag said *WRONG.* Thirty-eight.
"Stop," said Dess. "Stop, please. Everybody. Every wrong one costs him a pound."
"We know, Doc," somebody called. "That's why we want to get it right."
"You don't know what right is."
"Do you?"
It was Gus. He had come up beside her without her seeing, with his hands in his coat pockets and his cap pulled low, and he had said it low, so only she could hear. There was no accusation in it. That was the worst of it. It was only a question, put by a man who had asked her very few in eleven years.
"No," she said.
"Well, then." He looked at the dog for a good while. "Nobody's going to make him do it by himself."
"That's the thing I'm afraid of."
"I know it." He took one hand out of his pocket and put it on her shoulder, briefly, a heavy weight like a feed sack, and took it away. "Don't quit on him, Doc."
"I'm not quitting."
"I know it."
Bernie, meanwhile, had commandeered the loading dock. She had a card table and a coffee can and her clipboard, and a hand-lettered sign that said ANSWERS: ONE PER PERSON, ONE PER DAY, NO COACHING, NO REFUNDS. Dess walked up to it with real purpose.
"Take it down."
"Hon."
"Bernie, I'm serious."
"So am I. If they're going to guess, they can guess in order. I got a list. Nobody gets two. Nobody guesses twice. We cap it at one a day and we write down every miss." Bernie's face under the clipboard was not the face of a woman taking bets. It was the face of a woman who had seen a thing she couldn't fix and had reached for the only tool she owned. "You said it yourself. You can't stop a county from having an opinion."
"I said that?"
"I said you said it. Same thing."
"It costs him a pound a time."
"He's got forty-one of 'em." Bernie's voice cracked on the last syllable. She cleared her throat and went into chant to cover it. "Hoo-boy, who'll give me forty, forty, forty, you can't buy a dog like this for forty, hon, you can't buy him for any—" She stopped. She put a hand over her mouth. "Oh, God. Oh, I didn't mean that. That's not what I meant."
"I know."
"Sit down," said Dess, and Bernie sat on the coffee can, and Dess stood beside her with a hand on her back, and they looked at the old dog in the chair.
He was thirty-seven by dusk.
Teo's last reading was done by lantern light, in a silence the whole siding had agreed to keep. He lifted his pen. He wrote the number. He did not show anybody. He put the pen away and stood with his hands on his knees, looking at the needle, in the posture of a man who has been asked to read a gauge and has found it reading something besides what the gauge was for.
"Dess."
"What?"
"The pounds. Come look at this."
"It's thirty-seven. I can count."
"Not the dog." He had his head cocked, as if listening for something under the boards. "I have been writing his weight down all day. And I have been writing something else. I did not mean to. I thought it was the habit." He turned the pad to her.
Under the dog's column, in his square engineer's hand, was a second column. It was headed, in pencil, *the other side.* It had four numbers in it, and every one of them was a pound.
"Teo. What is the other side?"
"I don't know yet," Teo said. "But the Beam in the scale house was one pound heavy at noon. And two at three. I did not weigh anything. Nobody has weighed anything on it since Tuesday."
She stared at him.
"It is," he said, "as if the pounds went somewhere."

