On Monday night, at ten past eleven, I put my hand back in the print with a sentence written on it in ballpoint.
The rope was on. The three above ground stood in their places along the slack of it, Dee, Rafe, Zara, and behind them Calder, who had insisted on bringing a legal pad and a court-reporter’s pencil, and who had written at the top of the first page, in block capitals, TRANSCRIPT, AS BEST I CAN. Teddy had brought no thermos. For once he had brought only his hands, folded in front of his jacket, and I saw that he had decided, tonight, that this was not a time for sandwiches. Finch stood by the long table with the Nine. Josiah had put one hand on his shoulder, or on the space where it would have been.
“Hello,” I said. “It’s Pippa. May I?”
“Always,” said the Neighbor. It sounded warm, a little shy, and glad. “Did he get his sound back? The small one.”
My throat closed. “Yes. Thank you for asking.”
“We were sorry. We did not know.”
“I know. It’s my turn. I’m going to ask my second.” I held up my left hand to the lamp, and read it in a voice I tried to keep from cracking. “What do you do with what you keep?”
I had expected a pause. It answered at once, like a child who has been waiting to be asked what she did at school.
“We keep it,” said the Neighbor.
“That’s all?”
“That is all. It is the whole of what we do. It is not a small thing. Nothing that is kept is lost. Do you understand? Nothing in us ends.” It spoke with growing happiness. “We have a very great many. We have the cold and the fear in it. We have every beast that drowned. We have the man’s father’s bad night and the wife who could not get up the stair. We have a girl who was afraid of a dog in nineteen thirty-one. We have all of it, in order, and nothing is ever put down. It does not hurt. It does not spoil. It is only kept.”
“Where?”
“Would you like to see?”
Dee said, “Pencils—”
But I was already looking. I do not know how to say it. The slate under my palm opened, not as a door opens but as a held breath opens, into a place that was entirely dark, and entirely full, and entirely still. It was a long hall. It was not a hall. It was a pantry the size of a county, with shelves going up into a dark with no ceiling, and on every shelf, in rows, in exquisite order, a small bright thing in a jar. They were fears. I knew that at once, as one knows a sound is a bell. There were thousands of them. There were tens of thousands, a glimmering, patient, orderly, endless library of the unspent worst hour of everyone who had ever stood on this ground, labeled in no language I could read, dusted, cared for, and not one of them was doing a thing.
And there, on a low shelf near the front, I saw a small cold stone with a name on it. It said BISCUIT. Beside it, a larger and older one. Beside that, a dozen the size of my fist, with a handwriting I knew, a round, careful hand, a small boy’s.
“That is the roll of the Roll,” said the Neighbor, gently. “That is the place under all the places. We think of it as home.”
I came out of it on my knees. My ears were ringing. Rafe had a fistful of rope and a white face. Dee said, very quietly, “That’s one,” and Zara said, “Jesus, Pippa.”
“Do they, do the ones that are kept,” I said. My voice was a rag. “Do the people feel it?”
“Only the fear is kept, Tender. Not the people.”
“And the, the bound dead, the two hundred and thirty-one. In the Cordon.”
“Ah. That is an easier thing. Some of them said yes.” It sounded quite natural about it. “It is very hard, when one has died in fear, to say no. We asked. A great many were asked. They were so tired. We offered to take the fear, and they agreed, and then they were kept, in the way a thing is kept when it has nothing to fear. The lady with the sheets said no. She said it, I think, for a hundred and fifteen years. We were rather fond of her.”
“That’s my second,” I said. I could barely hear myself. “It’s done.”
“It is done,” said the Neighbor. “It was a very good one. It is our turn.”
Dee’s hand came down on my shoulder, hard. “Hon,” she said, “whatever it asks you, take your time.”
“I’m not going to answer for anyone,” I said. “I promise.”
“There is a thing we have been wishing to ask,” said the Neighbor. “It is about the man.” It spoke with extreme delicacy. “He is going. It is very plain. There is very little of him. We have watched a great many going. It is rarely so courteous. We are sorry for it.” A pause. “Aldous Finch is going. Would you like us to keep him?”
I should say that I did not hear the question as a question. I heard it as a hand held out in a cold room. I heard it as someone saying, you may have the thing you are afraid of, put back in your pocket, and nothing will be lost. I saw Finch’s glasses on their cord. I saw Ruth at the foot of the stair with her hand over her mouth. I saw Thursday after Finch, a long gray street with nobody on it, and a flight of forty-one stairs that nobody would ever come down.
“It must be true,” said the Neighbor. “Or you will have spent it.”
It was true. That was the thing. It was entirely true.
“Yes,” I said. “I’d like that. I’m so scared I’d like it very much.” I felt the tears running down my face, hot, ridiculous. “And no. I don’t, I couldn’t. He wants to go. He’s tired. He’d be so tired for, don’t. Please. Don’t.”
“Pencils down,” said Dee, in a roar. “Pencils down, pencils down—”
“Of course,” said the Neighbor. “We have only one more thing to say. It was the loveliest answer we have ever heard.” The slate lifted under my palm, in a long slow swell, and something went out of me, so large that I heard Zara cry out. “Thank you. We will be very kind.”
They pulled me off the stone. I do not remember it. I remember the rope on my ribs, and Rafe’s face, and Calder saying “Oh dear,” in a tone I had never heard from him, the tone of a man watching a contract go out the window. I remember Zara holding the glass up in the lamplight, and saying nothing, because it read twenty-nine.
I remember going up the stair. I went up alone, because I told them I wished to, and because I did not want to see their faces. I walked the corridor of the sub-basement past the pretzel machine to the foot of the main stair. The long fluorescent tube over the bulletin board flickered on and off. And at the foot of the steps, with one hand on the banister, stood Aldous Finch.
He had walked up ahead of us. He had been standing there, I think, for some time. I looked at him. I looked, and I felt it, and I did not understand for a moment what I was seeing.
“Pippa,” he said. He sounded puzzled. He turned his hand over and looked at it. “I should be very much obliged if you would tell me whether I am imagining this. I feel, I think, quite remarkably steady.”
I could not see the wall through his chest.

