Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 12

Proffer

MR. WYNN: Ms. Fenner, you understand nothing I say in this room is a promise.

A. I understand.

MR. WYNN: Then tell me what the record cannot.

Saturday morning, a different cinder-block box. The table is the same height, and so is the light. Only the people have changed.

Calder Wynn is a tall, stooped man in his middle fifties, with the careful posture of someone who has spent decades leaning over documents. He wears a gray cardigan under his suit coat, which would be a strange choice for a prosecutor if he were not obviously cold. He is a special prosecutor from the Attorney General's office, assigned at dawn. His voice is mild. He sets a thin recorder on the table and asks my permission before he switches it on.

Beside me sits Priscilla Delacroix, the public defender, who came in on her own Saturday and whom I have known for ninety minutes. She is twenty-nine, quick, with hair pulled back in a pencil. She has already told me three things: do not volunteer, do not guess, and do not apologize.

"She is here for a proffer," says Pru. "Everything she says today is for use in the investigation only. If it comes to trial, you can't use her words against her unless she testifies differently."

"Understood," says Wynn. "I've read the rules. I wrote some of them."

"Then we're all friends," says Pru, and does not smile.

"Ms. Fenner." He folds his hands. "I have the transcript from Friday morning, as taken by Mr. Tate. It is a good transcript. It misspells 'Prejean' once, and I want to say I noticed."

"He wrote P-R-E-J-E-A-N. That is correct."

"Ah." Wynn tilts his head. "So it is. I stand corrected." He makes a small mark on his pad. I understand that he did it to see how I would take it. I am a little ashamed of how much I like him for it.

"I will ask you to tell me everything, in order," he says. "Start with the day you left Port Sable."

I tell it. It takes two hours and ten minutes. I do not guess. I do not apologize, though Pru has to put her pen on my sleeve once. I give him October fourteenth, from the three o'clock dictation to the forty minutes in the records room. I give him the bus to Mobile, the steno school, the day I found out that Nell Aldous was dead and nobody in the registry had updated her file. I tell him what I did with her certification and why I did not return it.

When I get to the recorder on the ferry, he stops me.

"You took the court's audio backup out of the building on Wednesday night."

"Yes."

"Why?"

"Because I had no other way to make him say it."

"You could have gone to Judge Lyle."

"I could have." I look at my hands. They are not counting. They are flat on the table, the way Jude holds his. "I thought if I went to her, I would have to tell her who I was, and I thought she would remove me before I had anything to give her. I thought I only had one chance to be believed."

"Were you right?"

"I don't know." It is the truest sentence I have said in five years. "I'm not sure I would do it differently, and that does not make me honest."

Wynn writes this down. He does not look at Pru.

"There is the matter of Mr. Marchand," he says. "You kissed him. In open court you said that you chose it."

"Yes."

"Before Tuesday, had you spoken to him outside of court?"

"Monday evening. The 6:10 ferry. He asked me to come."

"What did he say?"

"That he knew I was not Nell Aldous. That his tow driver had brought the sedan to his yard on October fifteenth, and he had stacked boats around it and said nothing for five years." I wait. "That he was sorry."

"That is a confession of obstruction," Wynn says mildly.

I feel Pru go very still beside me.

"It is," I say. "He said it to a witness, not to an officer. He asked me for nothing."

"He asked you to meet him."

"He asked. I came."

"Hm." Wynn looks at me for a long moment. Whatever he writes next is short. "Thank you. We will return to that."

"Mr. Wynn," says Pru, in the tone of a woman reaching for a fire extinguisher, "my client's statement about a third party is not a waiver."

"No. It is a statement." He is not unkind about it. "I'll leave it where it is. May we turn to the black book?"

I tell him what Teague told me, word for word. When I say that the last page is a confession in my own handwriting, dated the fifteenth, I find I am whispering. I make myself say it at a normal volume. Wynn does not lean in. He lets me finish.

"Ms. Fenner, you told me you signed blank pages."

"Payroll, tax forms. Ray said it was easier than having me sign every time."

"How many?"

"I don't know. Years. Dozens of sheets. Once a month he'd put down a stack, I'd sign the bottom of each and he'd say Adie, you're a saint." My mouth is dry. "But it is not a signature on a page. Teague said it's in my handwriting."

"Handwriting is easier to forge than most people believe. It is harder to forge well enough to survive an expert." He taps the pad with the cap of his pen. "That is the only reason I can leave you at peace for a moment. Everything about this case so far depends on two things. One is whether your uncle is the sort of man who prepares for a day like this. The other is whether anyone can prove it."

"He is."

"Forgive me. You say that as someone who has spent five years afraid of him. That does not make it evidence."

"No." I say it before Pru can stop me. "But I lived in the house. He cleaned his shoes on Sundays. He put every receipt in a folder. Ray told me once that the difference between a man who gets caught and a man who doesn't is a drawer."

Wynn is quiet.

"Fine," he says at last. "I believe in drawers myself."

He shuts the recorder off. The room is suddenly very small and very still, and I realize that I have been talking for so long that I have not thought about the jail once.

"The safe was empty," he says. "Mr. Teague has not been found. His coat is on a chair in a motel room, and no one has seen him since he walked out of a protected interview room at 2:10 this morning. The desk clerk says he asked for a glass of water and then did not come back for it."

"He walked out of custody?"

"He was not in custody. He had volunteered." Wynn closes his pad. "I could not hold him. I could have asked."

Pru says, carefully, "What do you want from my client, Mr. Wynn?"

"At the moment? Her best memory of every place your uncle kept a drawer." He rises, and so, awkwardly, do I. He holds out one thin, cold hand. "And her word that if Mr. Teague comes to her, she will call me before she calls anybody else."

I take it.

"I'd like to give it," I say. "I don't know yet if I can."

"That is the most honest answer I have had all week," says Calder Wynn, and goes to find the officer with the keys.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!