Nobody slept that night, and at six on Sunday morning the Lodge bell rang, and Tally Clerk Prill came across the square with a briefcase and a face like a closed drawer.
I had last seen her at Wagon Wheel Lot, in Dee's court, reading out a Bureau claim on a girl who was not hers to claim. She had not changed. She was a small, round, neat woman in a charcoal skirt suit, with her hair in a bun so tight it seemed to pull her eyebrows up, and she walked the way some people sign their names, without hesitation and with a flourish at the end. Behind her, in a gray coat, with her brass lantern in one hand and her thermos in the other, came the Auditor.
We had not talked about the eighth knock. We had climbed out of the Datum in a rush, all seven of us, and Hester had stood at the top of the stair with a coil of yellow tape and said, "I shall close it. I shall not open it again until I know what is behind it," and she had laid the tape across the broken dish and drawn it tight, and I had watched her hands, and they were not the hands of a woman who believed in the tape. Nobody had said what we all had in our heads. A door that counts your party. A receipt. And an eighth.
Now we stood in the square in the cold gray light, the whole town of Plumb on the pavements behind us, and the great plumb at rest over the broken stone.
"Ms. Teague," said Prill. "Mistress Lund. Madam Auditor, thank you for attending. I have a notice." She opened the case with two small clicks. "On behalf of Mr. Pellam, who regrets that he cannot be here."
"He regrets it," said Danny, under his breath, "in a way that doesn't say anything."
"Mr. Pellam notes that on Saturday morning, between five and seven a.m., all commission plates on the first Division were removed or fell. He notes that the Level Lodge, by its Master Surveyor, is party to a contract dated eleven years ago, the Clean Route Agreement, under which the Lodge undertook to display a certain figure on forty markers. He notes that the Lodge is now in breach." She turned a page. "Under Clause Fourteen, upon breach, the Lodge's arrears, which Pellam Freight paid in full eleven years ago, become a loan, repayable in thirty days. The sum is one hundred and eighty-one thousand dollars, with interest. Failing repayment, the Lodge's principal asset, the plumb and its crane, passes to Pellam Freight." She looked up. "That is the whole of the notice. Mr. Pellam asks me to say that every word of it is true."
It was very quiet. Behind us I heard a Surveyor draw a long, shaky breath.
"One hundred and eighty-one thousand," said Hester Lund. She did not sound frightened. She sounded like a woman reading a bill for the last time. "I do not have it."
"No," said Prill. "I did not suppose you did."
"The commission was void," said Dess, in a thin, high, furious voice, and the Tally Clerk's eyebrows, which had nowhere to go, went there. "It was void. Section Nine. The head commission was voided by the voice of the commissioner, and everything granted under it fell. The agreement fell with it."
"The *commission* fell, Miss Quarles. The *agreement* is a separate instrument. Mr. Pellam's counsel has examined it. He finds that it survives as a contract for services." She pursed her mouth. "I do not say it is a good outcome. I say it is the law."
"Madam Auditor," I said. "Is that so?"
Marguerite Pruitt-Lane took a long time to answer. She uncapped the thermos, and poured, and looked into the cup. I realized she was giving us the time.
"It is a defensible reading," she said, at last. "I do not say it is the only one. The Office of Audits has jurisdiction, as of this hour, over the commissions of the first Division. I am obliged to examine every claim on the Lodge's account." She sipped. "I am also obliged to examine every claim against it. And every claim *by* it. And I should like to remark that in the course of an audit, Ms. Teague, a claim and a counterclaim are netted. It is called set-off. It is the dullest provision in the Code. I have had occasion to love it."
"What claims?" said Prill.
"I am coming to that. Mr. Strand?"
I turned my head.
I had not noticed them come. All the way across the square, in the gray light, past the Wardens and the white coats and the astonished faces of the town, they were walking in a line, thirty-one men and women in Pellam jackets, with their caps in their hands. Dolores Kline led them, with her braid over her shoulder. Eddie Strand was beside her, carrying a cardboard box. They stopped at the edge of the broken dish, and Eddie set the box on the stone.
"Claims against Pellam Freight," said the Auditor, quite gently. "Filed with the Office this morning, in due form, by thirty-one drivers on the Clean Route, each of whom was shown a false figure on a post under a commission paid for by Mr. Pellam. Each seeks the value of his lost hours." She set the cup down. "I have, I think, the figures."
"Thirty-one claims," said Prill, sharply. "Of what magnitude?"
"Mrs. Kline lost a year of rest and a rating. Mr. Strand lost a hospital and a wife's care. There are, I believe, eleven years of such losses outstanding on a road the Office has not yet counted." She picked up a clipboard, and read down it, without hurry. "Totaled at the standard rate for lost hours, for these thirty-one claims alone, with interest, the sum is two hundred and ninety-four thousand dollars."
I heard a small strangled noise. It was Dess.
"That is a great deal more," said the Auditor, "than one hundred and eighty-one thousand."
"Those are claims by individuals. The Lodge is not a party."
"The Lodge is party to nothing, Ms. Prill. Pellam Freight is party to the claims, and Pellam Freight is the creditor of the Lodge. It is a very simple matter. A creditor who owes more than he is owed is not a creditor." She smiled, a small, dry, exact smile, like a person finding a coin in a coat. "I have set them off. The Lodge's debt is extinguished, and Pellam Freight remains my debtor to the sum of one hundred and thirteen thousand dollars, for which I shall issue a notice. I trust Mr. Pellam will find it in order. I have found him to be a very orderly man."
For a long moment nobody moved. The bell was still ringing, somewhere, very faint, and I saw Hester Lund take the yellow tape measure from around her neck, slowly, and look at it, and hold it out in both hands to nobody.
Then the square went up. I cannot describe it, except that three hundred Surveyors in white coats made a sound like a flock of birds, and Warden Tate sat down on the curb, and Dolores Kline put both arms around Eddie Strand and burst into tears, and somebody threw a hat, which came down on the plumb and slid off.
"The Lodge is solvent," said Prill, in a voice like a drawer slamming. She shut the case. "I will convey the ruling to Mr. Pellam. He will not be pleased."
"He will say that he is not displeased," said Pruitt-Lane. "And it will be true. Mr. Pellam is a man who is not displeased by anything he has already planned for."
The Tally Clerk stopped. She had turned half away, with the case in her hand, and when she looked back her face had changed, just slightly, as though a window had been opened in the closed drawer. She was not looking at the Auditor. She was looking at me.
"Ms. Teague. Mr. Pellam asked me to give you a message. I am not to say it to anyone else. I do not know what it means, and I have been asked to say that this is so." She drew a breath. "He said: *Please ask her to read the second page of her own log.*"
"The second page," I said.
"He said she would not have looked." Prill hitched the case under her arm. "He said that he cannot lie, and that you would find it in her own handwriting, and that he is, on this one subject, very sorry."

