I woke on the foredeck, wrapped in a sail, with forty pounds of orange cat asleep on my ribs.
The storm had gone as suddenly as it came. The sky over Carrow Quay was scrubbed pale blue, and the harbor was gone. Every drop of it had gone out to sea with the First Blow, and the whole fleet sat aground on shining mud, tilted at angles, like cows that had lain down in a field. Gulls walked between the hulls, looking offended.
Sunlight lay across the planks. I held up my hand and the planks stayed bare, no gray shape of fingers on the wood. I looked like a figure cut out of paper and set down on the deck, and I did not like it.
“It’ll get less strange,” said Dagny, handing me a mug. “That’s a lie, but it’s a kind one. Drink.”
The tea was hot and tasted of tar. “Where’s the captain?”
“Below.” She heard herself. “In his cabin. Below, in the sense of down the stairs.”
“I’d like to ask him what ‘I am’ meant.”
“Then I’d eat first,” Dagny said, and left me with that.
He came on deck at midmorning in a dry coat, which was somehow worse, because the dry coat was already going dark at the hem. I got to him before he reached the mast.
“Custom,” Idris said, before I opened my mouth. His voice was perfectly pleasant. “When the sea asks who’s the debt, the captain answers for his ship. It means I’m responsible.”
“That’s not what it sounded like.”
“It’s what it was.” He knocked two knuckles on the rail, and then he looked at me, and I couldn’t tell if the knock was meant for the future or for the lie.
A shout went up on the pier before I could say so. Six Quay wardens in gray oilskins had come down the planks at a brisk walk, with a young man at their head who looked as if he had never been so sorry to do anything in his life.
“Maris Keel?” His ears were red. “Warden Haskell Dunne. By order of the harbor-master, you’re arrested for working the water without a warrant. It’s only, it’s very much witchwork, miss. And you’ve no shadow. That’s sort of evidence, in itself.”
“I know,” I said. “I was there.”
Idris stepped past me to the head of the gangway, and a mild, courteous man turned into someone I wouldn’t have argued with. “Warden Dunne. Anyone on the roll of my ship stands under the Prince’s peace. Your harbor-master wrote that law herself.”
“Miss Keel isn’t on your roll, Admiral.”
“She is as of this minute.” He held out a ledger and a quill. Tuck, who had apparently been waiting for this his entire life, produced a clean page. “One copper a day, and the right to sit on the foredeck and be rude about the weather.”
I signed. The salt came again, thin and sharp. Warden Dunne turned the color of boiled ham and said the harbor-master would hear about this, and Idris said he was sure she would, and the wardens went away down the pier in single file.
“A copper a day,” I said. “That’s insulting.”
“It’s legal.” The corner of his mouth moved. “Read the fine print, Miss Keel. The sea does.”
Then the water spoke.
A long, low note rolled in from the dry harbor, one string plucked in a very large room, and Tuck dropped his pencil. Down at the foot of the Tidemark Steps, where the mud started, something black was rising out of the muck, step by step, wet and polished as licorice.
“The Stair,” breathed Tuck. “Admiral, it’s the Stair, in daylight!”
“The Prince has been patient,” Idris said. “He’d like to meet the woman who held his sea flat.” He turned to me. “It’s not an invitation. I’d offer you a chance to decline, but I don’t have one to give.”
At the head of the Steps he said it quickly, as if he’d said it eight times. “Hold the rail. Don’t look behind you. Whatever you hear on the way down, don’t answer it unless it says your name.”
“What if it says my name?”
“Then be extremely polite.”
I counted the steps. At forty I stopped, because the air had thickened to something you had to push through, like velvet, and my ears were full of a sound like a seashell held up to a larger shell. The harbor floor closed overhead. Still the Stair went down, black and cold, with the damp walls on either side glowing a faint green.
Then it opened.
The Underhall is the size of a shipyard and shaped like the inside of a hull. Ribs curve up on both sides into a ceiling that is the underside of the harbor, where keels drift by overhead, slow and black as clouds. The pillars are the masts of ships that didn’t make it home. Candles burn in bubbles that never rise. Along the walls, in silver letters that move like minnows, are names.
“Names Held,” murmured Idris. “Don’t read them. They like it.”
At long tables sat the drowned. They played cards. They poured wine that stayed in the cup. Their hair drifted though there was no water, and as we passed, every head turned, slowly, with the patience of the very old, and watched me with eyes that were not hostile, only interested. I’d never felt so thoroughly priced.
At the far end, in an overturned lifeboat dressed with kelp-silk, sat a young man.
He looked twenty-six. It was the kind of face that is meant to be looked at, long and pale and fine-boned, and his hair was black and drifted like ink in water. He wore a circlet of barnacled bronze nails. His eyes were the same gray as Idris’s, and I understood, with a cold little drop, that it was the gray of the drowned.
“Maris Keel,” said Calloran. “We have expected you for twelve years.”
“I’d have worn something nicer,” I said.
“I would not have noticed.” He studied me. “A shadow. The sea asks small things first. Do not take it personally.”
“I’m taking it extremely personally. Prince, I need to know who set this debt.”
“I did not set it. I collect it. The one who asked set it.”
“The book says that’s me. Odette says it’s a clerk’s word.”
“It is a word.” He said it softly, with a kind of weary courtesy, and it was not a no. “What it means is written. It is not mine to say. A debtor must learn her own debt, or it does not count. It is the only mercy the sea has.”
“That’s a terrible mercy.”
“Yes,” said the Prince. He had not used a single contraction. I was beginning to think he had never had the chance.
He turned those gray eyes on Idris. “You answered for the debt, Admiral.”
“I answered for my ship.”
“As written,” the Prince said, in the voice of a man handing back exact change. Something went between them that I couldn’t read, something with teeth and a long history.
“I may sell you what else I know of this debt,” he said to me. “The price is one song.”
“That’s the only song I have.”
“Yes.”
I thought of the ring of flat water, and how little I had left that I could afford to spend. “Not today.”
“Then the sea will take it in the second storm regardless,” said Calloran. “It nearly always does. I only wished you to choose how it was spent.” He paused. “I gave my own name to the sea a long time ago. I remember that it was a good one.”
I didn’t know why that made my throat close. I said thank you, because Grizel raised me.
As we turned to go, the Prince spoke again, low, but in that hall everything carried. “You did not tell her.”
“No,” said Idris.
“Then she will learn it the hard way. And soon.” Calloran tilted his head toward the ceiling, listening to something I couldn’t hear. “The tide is turning, Admiral. You will want to hurry.”
We ran. The Stair was slick as a seal, and halfway up I heard it behind us, a long roar like the whole harbor drawing breath. Idris caught my hand. His fingers were so cold they burned. We came out onto the top step with the water thundering at our heels and the Stair going under behind us without a sound.
“You didn’t tell me what?”
Idris looked at the harbor, not at me.
“It has to be learned,” he said.
“By whom?”
“By you.” He let go of my hand, and I realized that he had been holding it very hard. “And I would give anything for it to be someone else.”

