Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 20

Different Answers

It took three days to hear the eleven frames, and by the end of the second Iva could have recited the dust patterns from memory.

She worked in the long shed from seven until the light failed. Bram sat on his stool by the door and wrote down what she said in his large, uncertain hand. Tarrow came and went, bringing tea, taking sheets away to copy, turning up at odd hours with a question she had clearly been holding for some time.

Each frame went through the same ritual. The brass plate came off. Tarrow showed the open core to the witness. Iva bared her left hand, warmed it, and laid it on the copper.

By the end of the second afternoon she had a column of eleven lines, and she had read it so often that the figures had gone slightly strange.

Frames one, two, three, five, six, eight, nine and ten spoke in Ada’s voice, with small variations in the order of the words. Let them go, in each of them, was the last thing said. Frame six had carried the sentence with a flourish, as if the maker had pressed his thumb into the disk for emphasis.

Frame nine had been so worn that Iva heard only the first two clauses and said so; she wrote down the missing part as unheard and would not guess it.

Frames four, seven and eleven were different.

They were younger. The disks had been cut by another maker, and the copper had a slightly redder tint. The voice in each belonged to the man she’d heard in frame four, a dry baritone with the patience of someone dictating to a slow clerk.

Hold them to the method until the yard releases them in writing. No apprentice is to alter the method on his own judgment.

She’d heard it three times, once in each, and each time she had said it aloud and watched Tarrow’s face.

“That’s my father,” Tarrow said, the third time. It wasn’t a question.

“I don’t know whose voice it is. I can tell you it’s the same man in all three.”

“It’s him.” The keeper stood very straight. “He dictated in a particular way. He said, I’ll have that on paper.” She took her glasses off and pressed the bridge of her nose. “When did he commission them?”

“Nobody can tell from the voice. The disks have a maker’s date scratched on the inside edge.” Iva turned frame eleven’s core to the window and read the tiny figures. “Eighteen years ago. The same year he retired the set.”

“So he retired them and recommissioned three in the same year.”

“Yes.”

“Why would a man do that?”

Iva had been asking herself the same question since the fourth frame. She had two answers and trusted neither. “I can’t tell you why. I can tell you what, and when. I can’t tell you what he was thinking.”

“I can,” Tarrow said. “He’d taken out a note against the yard that spring.”

Bram stirred on his stool. He hadn’t spoken in an hour.

“Joan,” he said gently.

“I’m not accusing him, Bram. I’m saying what the ledger says.” She put her glasses back on. “He borrowed against the yard’s future fees. A decade of certificate income. Then he took Ada’s frames out of service, because he said no one needed to be taught the old way anymore. And he made three that said hold.”

“Which certificates do the three cover?” Iva asked.

Tarrow knew without checking. She had clearly done the arithmetic many times. “Fifteen of thirty-four. The rest were certified under the frames that say let them go.”

“Then fifteen are bound under a purpose that says hold. Nineteen aren’t.”

“Under a purpose.” Tarrow’s voice was dry. “Which one the law prefers, I couldn’t tell you. A purpose recommissioned in a final year is still a purpose.”

“It’s the purpose of the frame as it stands now. That’s what I can say.”

“And Dilys?”

“Frame six. Let them go.”

“Orrin Voss?”

“Frame two. Same.”

“Matthias Kell.”

Iva looked down at her sheet. She had been dreading this line since she’d heard the dry baritone speak.

“Frame four,” she said.

*

Hollis came on the packet at noon the next day. Iva saw it from the end of the boardwalk, where she had gone to put her head in the wind for ten minutes. It was the same gray, patched ferry, or its cousin, and he stood in the bow with his bag at his feet and his hand on the rail, a long thin man in a coat too light for the weather.

She walked down to meet him at the landing. He saw her coming and lifted his cane in greeting.

“Collector.”

“Mr. Fen.”

“You look better than you did.”

“I’ve been eating fish stew for three days. It’s the only reason.”

He came down the gangway carefully, one hand on the rail, the knee taking its time. At the bottom he stopped, set the cane, and looked at the Shoal: the stilted houses, the lamps, the weed-green pilings. “It’s the first island I’ve been on that I didn’t trust to stay put.”

“It doesn’t move.”

“I know. That’s what bothers me.” He almost smiled. “Pell taught me to look at the underside.”

They walked back along the boardwalk. She told him, in order and in plain terms, what the frames had said. The three that said hold. The fifteen certificates under them. The name of the dry voice. He listened without interrupting, his face turned to the water, and when she had finished he was quiet for most of a minute.

“You’ll have to say it,” he said.

“I know.”

“All of it. Even Matthias Kell.”

“Even Matthias Kell.”

“I haven’t met him.”

“I haven’t either. I’ve seen his certificate number.” She looked at the planks. “Dilys told me he’s the best float builder on the coast. I believe her. And I’m going to tell the keeper that his certificate is bound under a frame that says hold.”

“A frame that your own hearing says holds him.”

“Yes.”

“And you’ll have no way to say it’s wrong.”

“No. It’s what the thing was made to do.” Her mouth tightened. “I’m very tired of what things were made to do.”

He walked a few steps without speaking.

“I’ll be looking at something different,” he said. “I won’t be hearing any frames. I’ll be watching what each of them can actually do with a float in a trim basin. Whether they’re safe. Whether they can say stop when it’s time to say stop.”

“That may give a different answer from mine.”

“It will.”

“Dilys will be released by my hearing and endorsed by your trial, probably.”

“Probably.”

“And Matthias will be bound by my hearing and endorsed by your trial.”

“If he’s as good as she says.”

“Then he’s bound and he’s good.”

“That’s allowed.” Hollis stopped at the end of the boardwalk. “It’s not comfortable. But it isn’t a contradiction. You tell what the instrument meant. I tell what the man can do. Neither of us tells whether the law should bind him.”

“That sounds like a very reasonable division of labor.”

“It sounds like one. We’ll see what Tarrow thinks of it.”

*

Before the meeting she took him to the shed.

It was the first time she had stood in it with someone who didn’t need the frames explained. Hollis walked the row slowly, leaning on the cane, and stopped at each cradle without touching it. He bent to read the dials. He crouched, with a grunt, to look at the underside of a float, and Iva watched him look at it the way she had once seen him look at a cracked basalt shelf: patiently, as if waiting for it to say something it hadn’t yet decided to.

“Who trimmed these?” he asked.

“Apprentices. Every working day, for years.”

“Then somebody should tell the lever on frame eight that it’s tired.” He ran a thumb over the brass handle, polished into a shallow dish by palms. “They all have this wear. Except these.”

He had stopped at frame four. Then seven, and eleven. The levers were worn, but differently, a flat on one side, as if the hands that had held them had always pushed in one direction.

“Hold them to the method,” Iva said.

“Maybe.” He didn’t look up. “Or maybe somebody added a stop. There’s a witness mark here on the pivot. Something was fitted after the frame was made.” He pointed with the tip of the cane, careful not to touch. “I won’t know until I’ve had it open.”

“That’s your work, not mine.”

“Yes.” He straightened. His eyes went down the row of eleven frames, the dust in the light. “Your mother taught here.”

“Apparently.”

“Do you want to talk about it?”

“No.” Then, because it was a lie of the kind she no longer wanted to tell, “Not yet. I have a letter I haven’t opened.”

“All right.”

“I’m afraid of it.”

“That’s a reason.” He said it without weight. “I’m not asking you to open it for me. Just so you know that if you do, I’m in the house.”

“Separate rooms.”

“Separate rooms. The chandler’s got a cot above the rope loft. It smells like tar.” His mouth moved. “I’ll be fine. I’m used to that smell.”

She laughed. It was a small, real sound in the cold shed, and it startled both of them.

*

Tarrow thought it was acceptable, with reservations.

She put them at the meetinghouse that evening, in a long bare room with benches and a stove and a map of the Shoal’s pilings nailed to the wall. She had asked three people to come, and they sat on the front bench in a row like parents at a school recital: Dilys Perrow with her arms folded, Orrin Voss with his cap in his hands, and a lean, brown-faced man of forty-three with scarred fingers and a heavy gaze.

“Matthias Kell,” Tarrow said, introducing him without ceremony. “Frame four.”

He stood and offered a hand. His grip was careful, a man who had learned to be gentle with other people’s work.

“Collector Dane.”

“Iva.”

“Iva.” He sat. “Dilys says you’re the one who hears them.”

“I hear what each frame was made to do. That’s all.”

“And what did mine do?”

She had rehearsed how to say it. She had decided to say it without softening.

“It says to hold the apprentice to the method until the yard releases them in writing. It says no apprentice may alter the method on his own judgment.”

The room didn’t move. Matthias looked at the stove. His scarred hands were folded loosely, as though they’d decided to behave.

“That’s what Hesper said,” he said, after a while. “To my face. The day I got the token. He said, You hold to the method, boy, until I say different.”

“I’m sorry.”

“Don’t be sorry. It’s what the frame says.” He lifted his head. “It doesn’t say the method’s good.”

“No.”

“It doesn’t say whether I’m any use.”

“No. I don’t know that.”

“I know that.” His voice stayed even. “I’ve built eleven floats that don’t behave the way Hesper’s method says they should. They behave better. I’m not saying that to brag.”

Hollis, at the end of the bench, hadn’t spoken. Now he did.

“I’ll want to see them,” he said. “In a basin, under load. If you’re willing.”

“I’ll have to be.” Matthias glanced at him. “You’re the bridge man.”

“I’m a bridgewright with a bad knee. I don’t certify anyone. I write down what I see.” Hollis shifted the cane. “If your floats are good, I’ll say so. If they aren’t, I’ll say that too. You may not enjoy either.”

“I’ve been told that before.”

“By whom?”

“By my wife.” Matthias almost smiled. “She was right both times.”

The room relaxed by a fraction. Dilys let out a breath. Orrin Voss shifted on the bench.

“I’d like the three of you to hear this together,” Tarrow said. “So nobody gets one version in a corridor. Iva is going to write what she heard. Mr. Fen is going to write what he sees. They’ll file separate reports, with their own fees and their own names. I don’t want them blended. If they disagree, I’ll have two answers, and I’ll know what each is worth.”

“Will the creditor accept two?” Dilys asked.

“I don’t know.”

“Because he’s already here.”

Tarrow’s hands went still. “What?”

Dilys jerked her head toward the door. “He came in on the same packet as your bridge man. Shorter than I expected. He’s at the ferry office. He asked the clerk for the best room in town and was told there wasn’t one.”

“Who?”

“A man from Harbor Mutual. Lucan Pask. He says he’s an examiner of securities.” Dilys’s mouth twisted. “He’s brought his own pen. He’s been showing it to people.”

As if summoned, the meetinghouse door opened.

The man who stepped in was fifty, soft-faced, and tidy, in a gray suit with a silver watch chain. He carried a leather portfolio and wore a faintly apologetic expression, like a waiter about to announce a long wait for a table. He looked at the benches, the stove, and the faces turned toward him, and smiled as though everyone had been expecting him.

“Keeper Tarrow,” he said. “I do apologize for arriving early. I hoped to find you at the yard, but your husband said you’d be here. Lucan Pask, Harbor Mutual.”

“Mr. Pask.” Tarrow didn’t move. “The note isn’t due for thirty days.”

“Twenty-six, by my count.” He set down the portfolio. “I’m not here to press. I’m here to simplify. I understand you’ve engaged two examiners. Two separate reports, I’m told. Separate fees.” He glanced at Iva, then Hollis, with polite interest. “I’m afraid my principals can accept only one.”

“One what?”

“One finding. A single joint statement on whether the certifications are sound.” He opened his hands. “Two reports invite two interpretations. My principals prefer clarity. If the examiners could reconcile their views within forty-eight hours, and sign together, I think we’d all be spared considerable distress.”

Nobody spoke. The stove ticked. Iva looked at Hollis and found him already looking at her, his face wholly without expression.

“You’d like us to sign together,” Hollis said slowly.

“If you would.” Pask smiled. “It would show the dispute is being resolved constructively.”

Iva heard the sentence land in the room, a small sound like a dropped coin. Across the benches, Hollis’s mouth moved. It wasn’t a smile.

“I’ve heard that phrase,” he said.

“Have you?” Pask’s smile didn’t change. “How gratifying. Then you’ll appreciate that it’s meant kindly.”

“I appreciate that it’s meant,” Hollis said.

“Mr. Pask,” Tarrow said, “my examiners are engaged by me, under my authority, with my fees. Whatever they conclude, they conclude on their own names.”

“Of course. And my principals hold the note.” He lifted the portfolio again. “Forty-eight hours, Keeper. I’ll be at the ferry office. The room, I’m told, has a window.”

He nodded to the benches and went out. The door closed softly behind him, the way a very polite man closes a door he intends to open again.

Dilys let out a short, ugly laugh. Orrin Voss worried his cap. Matthias Kell sat without moving, looking at the place where Pask had stood.

Iva realized she was looking at it too. She had noticed something as he turned, a flash of metal at his waistcoat where the watch chain crossed. A small charm hung from it, no bigger than a thumbnail. In the stove light it had seemed to be a coil of rope with a hook at the end.

She had seen that device before. She had seen it on a cream-colored letterhead in the circuit’s reading room, and on the iron housing of a winch that had once been trying to drain an island out from under its people.

She didn’t say anything. Hollis, at the end of the bench, was looking at the door, and she knew from the set of his shoulders that he had seen it too.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!