Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 18

Findings

Tamsin Orr spoke for six minutes, standing, with one hand resting on the back of the bench in front of her.

She didn’t read from notes. She said that she had been the relief watch at the east approach, that she had counted eleven people from the hut window and again from the span’s first plank, and that she had read the names to a clerk she’d never met. She said she had asked three times to hold the lane. She said the duty officer’s answer had been relayed to her in two words, and she repeated them: Lane closed.

“I had a rope,” she said. “The span’s rated for six, and the river was at the second mark, and I had a rope and a winch handle and two arms. I could have sent six across. It would have taken most of an hour, and the water was already over the lower approach. I don’t know if it would have worked. I’ve thought about it every day since. I’m not saying that to be pitied.”

Pryce didn’t interrupt.

“I came to ask for three things,” she said. “I’ve told the Collector what they are, so she isn’t hearing them first from this room. I’ll say them for the record.

“First, that the finding state what the seal said, both halves. Second, that a closure order on any crossing with a return seal read out a posted count of persons on the far side before the lane shuts.

“Third, that the east span’s original core be kept in place until someone who has never lied about it has heard it.”

“The third isn’t within this panel’s remit to grant outright,” Imes said.

“I know.” Tamsin looked at him without heat. “Ask for it anyway. That’s what I’m doing.”

She sat. The room didn’t react. People in the hearing room had learned, over two days, that the ones who said the most important things said them without raising their voices.

After the adjournment, Iva went out into the fog and stood on the circuit office steps. The quay was a quarter mile down the hill. A ferry horn sounded, two long notes and a short one.

That couldn’t be the noon ferry. It was only half past eleven.

She went down anyway.

*

The noon ferry came in ten minutes late, and the quay was nearly empty. A man with a barrow of onions stood at the end of the pier. Gulls walked along the rail. The boards were wet with condensation, and the fog was thick enough that the far breakwater existed only as a thicker patch of gray.

She had thought about what she would say for most of a night. All of it had left her by the time the ferry’s shape came out of the fog. It was a squat gray ferry with a patched funnel, and Hollis stood at the rail with his bag at his feet and his cane hooked over his arm, looking at the quay as if he’d been told it was a long way off.

She walked to the end of the pier. He came down the ramp.

“You got my telegram,” he said.

“I did.”

“I wasn’t sure whether to send it.”

“It wasn’t a question.”

“No.” His voice was dry. “I’d decided I’d be here before I decided whether you’d want me.”

“I wanted you. I also wanted to hit you.”

“Understood.” He shifted his weight off the knee. “Walk with me. I’ve been on that ferry four hours and the bench had a splinter.”

They went along the quay toward the inn. A cart horse watched them pass. The onion seller said something to his barrow.

“Tamsin told me,” Iva said.

“I thought she might.”

“She said you wrote to her two weeks ago and asked whether you should tell me.”

“Yes.”

“And she said no.”

“She said it was hers to tell, and she’d tell it to you herself, or not.” He stopped by a bollard. “I thought that was reasonable. I still think it was. I don’t think I handled it well.”

“Which part?”

“I told you she was someone I knew.” He looked at the water. “Not today’s business. As though it was a closed door. It was a closed door I’d had a hand in shutting.”

“You didn’t lie.”

“No. I picked a true sentence that kept you from asking.” He turned his head. “You’ve told me about that. How a true sentence can carry a lie. I haven’t forgotten.”

She stood very still, and then she said the thing she’d been carrying since the reading room. “It would have cost me nothing to know she’d be there. It cost something not to know. I walked in and saw her in the back row, and I had to find out what my face did without anyone warning it.”

“That’s fair,” he said.

“I’m not asking you to apologize.”

“I’d like to.” He said it plainly. “I’m sorry. I kept her story out of yours because she asked me to, and because it wasn’t mine. Both were good reasons, and I still shouldn’t have let you walk into it.”

“What would you have done differently?”

“I could have told you the shape without the story. She’ll be there. She has a right to be. She asked not to be introduced. I’d have asked whether you wanted me to stay away.” He paused. “That would have been enough.”

She felt something in her chest unclench. It wasn’t forgiveness, but it was information, which she trusted more.

“I’d like a rule,” she said.

“Go on.”

“If it’s somebody else’s story and they’ve asked you to hold it, tell me that much. That there’s something, and that it isn’t yours to give. I won’t ask. I’d like to know there’s a door.”

“I can do that.”

“And I’ll do the same.”

“About the license?”

“About anything. I’ve kept enough doors closed without telling anyone.”

He nodded. He held out a hand, not for a handshake, but palm up, an offer, and she took it, and they stood at the bollard in the fog with the cart horse looking on.

“I answered Carrad Shoal,” he said, after a minute.

“What did you say?”

“I said I’d examine the certifications of former apprentices, as a practical matter. Not the instruments. I told her my fee and that I would decline any examination I wasn’t satisfied was honest.” He lifted one shoulder. “I declined the joint part. I said you’d answer for yourself.”

“I haven’t yet.”

“I know. I thought you’d rather do it after today.”

“I would.” She exhaled. “After today.”

“Then let’s go to the room,” he said.

*

The panel gave its findings at three, in the green room, to a bench that held more people than the day before. Hollis sat in the second row beside Wynn Aldous, his cane laid across his knees. Tamsin was in the back. She didn’t look at either of them.

Pryce read for twenty-two minutes.

He began with the seal. Both halves, in full, in the examiner’s own clear voice. He said the panel found that the commission read as stated, that the seal’s whole instruction required the return to be available until the last passenger was off, and that the clipped form entered on the closure document was an incomplete rendering.

He said the incomplete rendering had been supplied to the duty officer by a caller from the lessee’s route office, whose identity the panel had not yet established, and that the panel was ordering the route office’s records produced.

He said the duty officer had acted on that call without verifying it, without consulting a collector, and without considering staged crossings under the span’s rating. The panel found that his decision had been made in under two minutes under real pressure and that the pressure did not excuse the failure to ask. It referred the matter of his pension to the circuit’s board of review without recommendation.

He addressed Wynn Aldous next, and the room noticed that he did it by name. The panel found that the clerk had done his duty on the afternoon of the closure by recording the objection and the count, that he had failed it afterward by keeping the carbon to himself, and that he had corrected the failure by bringing it forward unprompted. The panel did not commend him. It recorded that it had been given what it needed.

In the second row, Wynn looked at his knees. Hollis, beside him, turned his head and said something too low to carry. Wynn nodded without lifting his eyes.

He turned to Merrit. The panel found that her office’s practice of checking extracts against page lists, and not against logs, had contributed to the inquiry’s failure to obtain page forty-one. It ordered the practice replaced. It issued a formal reprimand, entered on her record, and directed that preservation of original cores in all circuit repairs be governed by a written standard within ninety days.

Merrit sat straight. She didn’t blink.

“As to Collector Iva Dane.”

The room changed. Iva heard it before she understood it: the sound of a number of people deciding to be still.

“The panel finds that the Collector’s testimony at the original inquiry was false in a material respect, that she knew it to be false, and that it was given to protect her license. Her subsequent statement, and her testimony before this panel, are found accurate and complete. The panel makes no finding of exoneration. The recovery of the fragments and the discovery of page forty-one bear on the duty officer’s conduct and the lessee’s. They do not alter the Collector’s.”

She kept her hands flat on the table.

“Her collection license remains suspended. The panel does not recommend revocation. She may apply for a limited assessor’s certificate, permitting examination of materials under another licensed operator’s authority, after four hundred hours of supervised work, logged and countersigned, and after the first two years of the restitution she has proposed are paid in full into escrow. The certificate carries no authority to execute a warrant or release a claim. The panel does not expect it to be granted lightly.”

Pryce paused and turned a page.

“As to restitution, the panel accepts the Collector’s proposal: fifteen percent of net earnings above rent and food, for eight years, payable to a fund established for the families named in the record and administered by Ms. Tamsin Orr or her designee.”

“The panel notes that the amount was increased by the Collector at Ms. Orr’s request, in the Collector’s own hand, and that the term was extended at her own proposal. The panel does not regard this as discharge of any obligation. It regards it as a beginning.”

Behind her, in the second row, Hollis hadn’t moved. She did not look around. Whatever he was hearing, it had his brother’s name inside it somewhere, and none of the sentences said so. She could tell from the quality of his stillness that he was listening for exactly that absence, and that no ruling the panel could issue would have been the right length.

“As to the east span at Low Hook. The panel finds sufficient connection between the Scrip House route desk’s call and the closure to order a stay of any alteration to the span’s original commission core pending examination by a named examiner under a proper chain. Examiner Brandt has countersigned.”

In the back row, a woman exhaled very softly.

“Finally, the panel refers the proposed closure-count rule to the circuit’s return-standard trial for consideration. The panel notes that the proposal arrived in this room in the words of a person who was there, and asks that its authors be heard.”

He closed the folder. “That is the panel’s finding.”

*

Iva was still sitting when the room emptied. Hollis stayed in the second row until the last bench had cleared. Then he came up the aisle with the cane and sat down on her left. It was the side where her hearing hand rested.

“It wasn’t what I expected,” he said.

“What did you expect?”

“Less money. More ruling.” His mouth moved. “I hadn’t expected the part about it being a beginning.”

“He’s good at sentences.”

“So are you, lately.”

She let the compliment pass. It had a sharp edge on it, and she thought it was meant to.

Tamsin came down the aisle while they were still sitting there. She had put on the gray coat and knotted her scarf inside out, which Iva noticed and, for no reason she could name, took as a kind of comfort.

“Hollis.”

“Tam.”

“You look like you’ve been on a ferry.”

“I have.”

“Eat something.” Tamsin turned to Iva. “The fund’s account is at the Mercantile on Lantern Street. Perrin has the number. The first deposit’s due at the end of next month, and I’ll send a statement every quarter. If you can’t pay one quarter, tell me before it’s late. Not after.”

“I will.”

“If you pay early, I’ll still send the statement.”

“That’s fine.”

“I’m not making conversation. I’m saying that I’m going to keep books on this, and the books will be accurate, and you can look at them whenever you like.” Tamsin’s mouth was a flat line. “Nobody kept books on this before.”

“No.”

Tamsin looked at Hollis for a moment. Something passed between them that Iva wasn’t invited to read, a lifetime of it, compressed into the time it took her to shift her weight.

“You keep that can,” Tamsin said to him. “Don’t give it to anyone. Don’t let anyone tell you it’s evidence.”

“I won’t.”

“It leaks.”

“I know it leaks.”

“Good.” She nodded once, to both of them, and went out. Her boots were loud on the boards, and then they weren’t.

Hollis let out a breath that sounded as if he’d been holding it since the ferry.

“She likes you,” he said.

“She does not.”

“She said fifteen percent. If she didn’t like you, she’d have said twenty.”

Iva laughed. It caught in her throat on the way out, and it took her a moment to realize it had become something else. Hollis said nothing. He put his hand over hers on the table, the way he had on the quay, and left it there until it stopped.

Perrin approached with a cream-colored envelope. He held it as if it were not entirely his business.

“This came for you while you were in session,” he said. “From Carrad Shoal. The keeper marked it urgent.”

Iva took it. Hollis stayed where he was and didn’t look at the envelope.

Inside was a single sheet in a hard upright hand. The yard’s creditor, a mutual association, had called its note. The Shoal had thirty days to produce certified evidence that its former apprentices were competently bound, or the yard would be taken for debt and the certifications voided. The keeper asked whether Iva could come within the week.

Clipped to the letter was a rubbing, taken from the housing of a retired training instrument, in soft black wax on thin paper. The commission mark was worn but legible. Under it ran a line of small cut letters that she had last seen on a tool chest in her own room.

A. Dane, Instructor of Record.

She read it three times. Beside her, Hollis tilted his head to see.

“That’s your mother’s,” he said.

“It’s her mark.” Iva’s mouth was dry. “I didn’t know she ever taught.”

She turned the rubbing over. On the back, in the keeper’s upright hand, someone had written a single line.

Ada Dane left word with my father that her daughter should be told this if she ever came. I have not read what else she left. It is sealed, and addressed to you.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!