Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 81

The Doctor's Hour

Dr. Lemuel Tate kept his surgery on the ground floor of a yellow house on Sandpiper Street, between a dentist and a locksmith, and on the day after Christmas he kept it open for no one.

Dee rang at nine. She had told nobody where she was going, not Mattias, who was in Cleveland with Ines arranging the transfer of the trunk's other effects, and not Hugh, who had put on his hat to drive her and been told that he was not needed. She had driven herself, in her father's hearse, slowly, around the block three times. She had her mother's diary in her handbag, and nothing else.

The door was opened by the doctor in person, in a cardigan and slippers, and with his beret on, as if he had been waiting in it. His round face was haggard. He had not shaved. "I thought it might be you before the third," he said. "I did not think it would be so soon. Come in, Miss Halloran. Mind the cat."

The waiting room was a museum of the nineteen-seventies. A fish tank, a rack of pamphlets about shingles, a framed photograph of a young man in uniform shaking hands with someone whose face had been cut off. In the surgery, beyond, were a desk, a scale, an anatomical chart, and an electric kettle. He made tea. He did it slowly, with attention, and she watched his hands, which were small and square and entirely steady.

"I will not ask you to sit," he said. "I think you would rather stand."

"I would rather hear."

"Then I will tell you what I did. I will tell you all of it, and I will tell you that I do not know where she went." He set the cup before her and did not touch his own. "On Friday the twenty-third of April, 2004, at about two in the afternoon, I was called to Mercy General by your father. I was not on duty. I was not a hospital physician. I was a harbor doctor, the kind that sets a stevedore's wrist, but I had known Margaret since 1993, and she had asked for me."

"She was alive."

"She was alive. She was in a bed in room 412, on a medical ward, under a chart that said pneumonia. I had seen her in the corridor of my own surgery a week earlier. She had said to me, in a voice I have not forgotten, Lem, I need you to be a coward for me, and not ask." The old man's lips trembled and were still. "I asked. Of course I asked. I am a doctor. She told me what she believed. I said it was impossible. She said, Then examine me. I did."

"And?"

"And I found nothing. A pulse at forty. A little cyanosis at the nailbeds. A cough." His eyes met hers, very bright. "The symptoms of a woman who has been given a slow dose of something for a long time. And of a woman who is frightened. I could not say which. I am still not able to say. But I could say what she wanted. And I could say that Walter, who was standing at the foot of the bed in a clean collar, was crying like a man at his own funeral."

"So you signed."

"I signed. I put down cardiac arrest, which is what one writes. I gave the form to the night clerk at four o'clock. She was wheeled to the morgue at four-fifteen under a sheet, by an orderly, who was Walter's cousin. She was driven out at five, in a hearse, by Walter, to a house I was not told." He wiped his mouth with his thumb. "She left a note on the pillow. It was for me. It said, Do not look for me. I did not."

"For twenty-two years."

"For twenty-two years I have been a very bad doctor and a very good friend." He spread his small hands. "I stood in the corridor with you, Miss Halloran. I had my hand on your head. I said I was sorry for your loss. I have been sorry for it every day since. It was a lie, and the worst I have told, and the only one I would tell again."

Dee did not speak. She stood with her hands in her coat pockets, and she was aware that her face was not doing anything at all, which was how she knew she was close to something. She had seen families do it. They would stand quite still in the chapel with their hands folded and their eyes dry, and then, in the car, would put their heads on the dashboard.

"There is a card," said Tate.

"A card?"

"Once a year. In April, on the twenty-third, for five years. 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009. A plain postcard with a gray heron. No return address, no signature. On the back, in her hand, one word. Well." He crossed to the desk and drew open a drawer. "I have kept them. I did not know whether to burn them. In 2010 they stopped. I have not had one since."

He put five postcards on the blotter. Each was identical, a bird standing on one leg in a blue marsh, postmarked from a different town. Dee read the postmarks in order. Erie, Pennsylvania. Buffalo. Dunkirk. Ashtabula. Port Clinton. Each one on the shore of the same lake, each one a little farther west.

"She was going round it," said Dee.

"Looking for something. Or fleeing it." Tate lowered himself into his chair, and the chair gave an old man's complaint. "I told Walter once. In 2007. He did not say a word. He said, Lem, do not tell me where she is. And I said I did not know. And he said, That is why I trust you."

"Doctor." She put the diary on the desk, between the cards and the cup. "There is a name in here. A. It signs every letter. It sent my mother a tea service in 1999. It is the man who wrote the Instrument's last letters, the ones that go out each month. It is also, I think, the man who called me on the lake line, and used Plain Answer."

"I do not know a man called A."

"The Counting House has a correspondent. Mr. Cornelius Ashgrove."

For the first time the old man's face changed. It did not break. It closed, like a door in a draft.

"Cornelius is eighty-one years old," said Dr. Tate carefully, "and has been the Quiet Board's secretary since 1991. He is the gentlest man I know. He has never raised his voice. He posts a letter on the first of every month to a woman he has never met, and he has done it for twenty-two years, and I have never seen him do a cruel thing." He paused. "Which is exactly the description Margaret wrote of the Principal."

"Then you see why I ask."

"I see. I am only telling you that I cannot answer." He rose, with an effort, and took a long envelope from the inside pocket of his cardigan. It was cream, sealed with a small red harp, and addressed in a precise, upright hand to Miss D. M. Halloran, by hand. "Cornelius gave me this on Wednesday night. He asked that I deliver it to you on the third. I think he wished to be sure it was not opened by the wrong person. But I think, Miss Halloran, that you had better have it now."

"What is it?"

"It is the letter that was not in the drawer," said Dr. Tate. "Someone had taken it out. Someone put it back. Cornelius found it on the floor of the Principal's chair on Wednesday, with the seal intact, and the date on the front changed." He laid it in her hands. "It was addressed to be posted on the thirty-first of December. The date written on it now is the twenty-eighth. Which is Monday. Which is the day the federal grand jury sits."

"They are moving the dates."

"Someone is," said the doctor, "who knows what the letter says. Open it."

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!