Every year on Halloween, Hollis & Daughter throws the Pie Supper, and every year somebody threatens to leave the valley over a meringue.
It began in 1974, the Halloween after the treaty, when my grandmother realized the three packs could not be trusted to sit in a room without something to do with their hands. So she gave them pie.
Each pack bakes one. Each pack sets it on the counter. The children vote, with buttons from Ruth’s button jar, dropped into three coffee cans, because a vote by penny was ruled a bribe in 1991. The pie whose can gets the most buttons wins, and the pack that wins gets to say so until Christmas.
“Pie is not a bribe,” Ruth said, setting out forks. “It’s a ceasefire.”
“That’s rule six.”
“It’s the only one that works.” She was back on her feet, with a bandaged ankle and the air of a woman who had been ordered to rest and had filed an objection. “Hand me that cooler.”
By six the diner smelled like butter, cinnamon, and the faint, pleasing menace of seventy people who all wanted to win.
Maude Halvorsen had brought her late husband’s sugar-cream pie, and watched it like a hawk watching a field mouse. Emmett Haskell’s ranch hands set down a buttermilk chess pie so tall it had to be carried in with a spatula. Juno’s marionberry came with a lattice top so tidy that Aunt Verna looked at it, looked at Juno, and said, “It’s too neat. You’re hiding something.”
“Respectfully, it’s a pie.”
“Everything is something else, child. That’s what a pie is for.”
Aunt Verna’s unofficial entry, a vinegar pie, sat at the end of the counter with a card that said DON’T. Nobody dared.
Dane stood by the register with a paper plate. A slice of Juno’s marionberry sat on it.
He was looking at it the way a man looks at a letter he is not ready to open. I came up beside him with a pot of coffee.
“You don’t have to,” I said.
“I know.”
“Is it the pie?”
“It was my father’s.” He did not elaborate. He set the plate down on the counter, very gently, as if it might wake. “Not tonight. Maybe not ever.”
It was the only time all evening that I was aware of a thread, a small pull in my left arm, like someone tugging a stitch.
At eight o’clock, a woman in a gray suit stepped through the door. She did not carry a pie.
“Ms. Brandt,” said Gwendolyn Strand. “I understand it’s open to all.”
“Neutral ground,” I said. “Unarmed, please.”
“Only a briefcase.” She pumped sanitizer onto her palm from a small bottle in her bag, and the smell came across the counter like a slap: orange, cheap and bright. She was forty-five or so, immaculate, with a smile that arrived on schedule. “I won’t stay. I only wanted to say, on behalf of my client, that Mr. Kane is prepared to be generous. Relocation assistance for the Marlowe pack. A very fair figure for the diner. There is no reason this has to be unpleasant.”
“There’s every reason,” said Ruth, from the pass.
“Pie, Ms. Strand?” I said.
She studied it. “I’m afraid I don’t take food from the opposing party.”
“It’s not a bribe. It’s a ceasefire.”
“Then I’ll decline the ceasefire.” She snapped her briefcase shut and left through the door, and the entire room let out its breath at once. I gave the first kid in line a button. “Go vote,” I said.
The sugar-cream pie won. Maude pretended not to care, in the manner of a woman who has been waiting twelve years.
At nine, with the supper in full roar, the door opened one more time, and Mr. Quist came in.
He was in his good cardigan, buttoned wrong. His hair stood up on one side. He had a paper bag held in both arms, the way you carry a baby you aren’t sure you’re allowed to keep, and he did not go to stool six. He came straight to me, and set the bag on the counter, and I smelled earth.
“Winifred’s dahlias,” he said. “The tubers. Café au lait. You keep them somewhere dry over the winter, and put them in the ground in May.” His hands shook. “I wanted you to have them, Hollis-the-second. In case.”
“In case of what, Mr. Q?”
“In case I’m not here in May.”
Over his shoulder, Dane watched us. I gave him a small, tight look. It said: later. It said: not here.
I waited until the last pie plate had been washed and the last Haskell had gone home with a feather of meringue still in his hair. Then I put a slice of Quist’s favorite on the little table in my office, and poured two coffees, and shut the door.
“Sit,” I said. “Eat. Then tell me.”
He sat. He looked at the pie. He did not touch it.
“It’s a long time since anyone told me to eat,” he said.
“Mr. Q.”
“I know. I know you know.” He wept, then, with no sound at all, the way old men do, shoulders folded in. “I knew when you picked up my tin. I knew when you didn’t say anything these last few days. You get that from her, the quiet. You go very quiet, and everyone around you thinks it’s peace.”
“Tell me.”
He told me.
Winifred had died six years ago, and the hospital bills had come in over six figures, so he had taken out a reverse mortgage on the house on Larch Street, and he had not understood the paper he signed. In August, Kane Ridge Capital bought the note.
In September, Pruett Kane stopped him on the sidewalk outside the county annex, friendly as a church supper, and asked how the Table was keeping. And God forgive him, Mr. Quist said, he told him. He told him what Juno had said about clause nine.
Kane said it was a pity about the Table, how it held the valley back. He said he’d forgive the note, every penny of it, for one small favor.
“He said the treaty had a typo. He asked me to fix a typo.” His voice cracked. “Pruett didn’t ask me to hurt anyone. That’s what I told myself, for a month. A typo. One page. That Thursday, I typed it on your grandmother’s machine, on a ribbon his man brought, and put it in the folder with the key your grandmother gave me thirty-one years ago.”
“And on the ninth?”
“I telephoned him from my kitchen after the Words. He had asked me to.”
“And the real page seven?”
“Gone.” He did not look at me. “Strand took it.”
Pennies. It came off him like a spilled purse, bright and metallic. He was lying. About that, anyway.
I should have pushed. I’ve gone over that moment a hundred times. But he was seventy-four and he smelled of earth and grief, and behind the pennies there was real fear, plain and enormous.
I let it go. It was the second great mistake I made that month, and it was the kind of mistake that happens when you love someone.
“You’ll tell the Council,” I said. “On the seventh. All of it.”
“Holly.” He looked up, finally. “If I say it, he calls the note, and I lose the house, and Winifred’s garden. And the county annex, the copies, I changed those too. I was a clerk for forty years. They’ll call it forgery, and it is. I’ll die in a county cell.”
“You’ll have the whole Table behind you.”
“I’ll have an old man’s word against a vest.” He stood. “Thank you for the pie.”
He had not eaten it. I let him go. I stood in the cold light of the office with a paper bag of dahlias in my arms, and my own voice in my head said: you should have followed him. And the other voice, the tired one, said: he’ll come back, he always does, he comes at four.
Dane slept that night in booth four with his boots on. I hadn’t asked him to. He hadn’t offered. It was simply where he was.
At 6:02, a courier came through the door with a cream-colored envelope and laid it on the counter by my elbow.
It was an affidavit, notarized, three pages, signed at 3:14 that morning in a small tidy hand that did not tremble. Barnaby Quist, Scrivener of the Table for thirty-one years, swore under penalty of perjury that page seven of the Tamarack Table Treaty was genuine, original, and in my grandmother’s own words.

