The special session of the county commission convened at ten on Monday morning in the annex hearing room in Calloway, a paneled box with fluorescent lights, a flag, and sixty folding chairs, every one of them taken.
Silas sat in the third row between Wyatt and June, in the only tie he owned, which June had knotted with a savagery he had not seen since his eighth-grade graduation. Dovie sat on the aisle with her cane across her lap, in her man's wool coat, looking about the room as if it were a barn she was considering for a sale. Behind them Marian Voss had brought three binders. Toby had been left at school, over objections.
At the long dais sat five commissioners and a clerk with a tape recorder. In the middle, in the big chair, with his reading glasses pushed up on his forehead and a cough drop in his cheek, sat Burl Tackett, sixty, chairman. He had a heavy, tired, honest face. He banged the gavel once, lightly, as a man taps a melon.
"We're here on a single item," said Burl Tackett. "A resolution to erect a fence and lock a gate at the place known as the Rankin Lip, on account of, quote, a danger to public safety, unquote. I've read the filing. I've read the sheriff's report. I've read the letter from the state about Maple Terrace." He coughed. "I'd like to hear from everybody, and I'd like to be done by lunch."
It went as such things go. The county attorney read a long statement about liability. A man from the state Office of Risk read a longer one. A woman from the insurance carrier said, in the brisk tones of someone who had flown in for the day, that forty-one elderly persons had been found sleepwalking at a licensed facility on the night of the nineteenth, that the county could not afford a repeat, and that if a hole in the earth was the cause, a hole in the earth could be fenced.
"Is it the cause?" said the commissioner on Tackett's left, a young woman named Alma Pettigrew who ran a feed store. "I mean, does anybody actually know?"
There was a silence. Dale Pruitt rose from the front row. He had worn his uniform. He carried the green ledger in its pillowcase and set it on the witness table, and he did not sit.
"I'll say what I know, Madam Commissioner," said Dale. "I'm sixty-five. I've been sheriff of this county for thirty-one years, and for three of those I spent every weekend in the Rankin Gap looking for a boy named Wyatt Ketterman. I never found him. I came to learn where he'd gone. I keep a ledger." He rested a hand on it. "It's got the names in it of every person this county has lost to that hole since nineteen twenty-three. Eleven in the first hand. Sixteen in mine."
A murmur went across the room.
"I'm not going to tell you what's down there," said Dale. "I can't. I can tell you that in the last six weeks, with the help of some very odd and patient people, I've seen ninety-one folks go gray and come back. I've seen a boy walk out of that hole who was gone three years." He paused, and Silas, in the third row, felt Wyatt go still. "I'd call that a good record. I'd call it better than the highway department's."
A faint laugh. Burl Tackett did not smile.
"A fence won't stop it from leaning on a nursing home," said Dale, "if that's what it's doing. It doesn't care about fences. But I'll say plain, I'd sooner there be somebody at the gate every night with a lantern than a padlock. A padlock keeps out the ones who'd come to help."
Paulette Voss spoke next, to everyone's surprise, in a gray suit that fit her a little too well. She said she was an employee of the state and had no standing to speak. She said it twice. Then she said she had cost the county, by her own count, ninety-one hospital beds on the first of December, with a program she had launched, and that she had read every complaint and every file and tore up a lease. She said she had no wish to see a gate locked on anything she did not understand. She sat down very fast.
Then it was Dovie.
She did not rise at once. She sat looking at the chairman with her chin up. Then she stood, with the cane, in her great coat, small as a seed pod and as dry, and said in her gate-on-gravel voice that carried to the back of the hall without effort: "Burl Tackett. You were in my Sunday school class in nineteen sixty-six."
A real laugh went round the room. The chairman took the cough drop out of his mouth.
"You threw a hymnbook at Loyd Pettigrew," said Dovie.
"He was cheating at Bible drill."
"He was. And you're about to do the same thing." She tapped the cane. "I'll say my piece and be done. I've kept that hole for sixty-one years. Nobody asked me. Nobody wanted to. It's a poor, steep, ugly thing, and it's been the death of a girl I loved, and I've worn wax in my ears about it every frost for sixty-one years. I'd be glad to see it fenced. But a fence is a fence. You can put a gate on it, and a lock, and the next thing that comes is a boy who climbs it because he's seen a sign. I've seen the boy." She turned her head, once, toward Silas. "I'll take the gate. I'll be at it every night with a lantern. You put me down as the keeper. Seventy-eight, and I've never once been late."
She sat. Nobody spoke. Burl Tackett, at the dais, was looking at her with a look Silas could not read.
The vote, when it came, was three to two. It was a strange compromise. The fence would be built, six feet of split rail and wire, with a gate that would never be locked. A keeper would be named. The keeper would be present every night from dusk to dawn between the first frost and the thaw, with a lantern and a logbook and no authority whatever to turn anyone away. The fence would go up on the fifth of January.
"That's the best I can do," said Burl Tackett, into the microphone, in a voice rubbed raw. "Alma and Hank and I voted for it. The other two will want the reasons in writing." He coughed. "I move we adjourn."
It was in the hallway afterward, among the chairs, that he found Silas. He came out of a side door with his coat over his arm and his glasses in his hand, a big stooped man with a gray crew cut, and he stood a moment as though he did not know why he had come.
"Mr. Ketterman."
"Sir."
"My mother's at Maple Terrace." He said it quickly, to the carpet. "Eighty-nine. Hasn't known me since August. On the night of the nineteenth, I got a call at three. She was number seventeen at the front doors. They said she was standing there with her good coat on and her shoes on the right feet." He looked up. His eyes were red. "I'd have voted to fill that hole with concrete. I want you to know that. I wanted it done."
"Why didn't you?"
"Because I looked at your aunt." He gave a rueful snort. "Because I've been thinking since Friday that somebody has to be at the door. Not a lock. Somebody."
He put on his glasses. He put out his hand, and Silas shook it, and the big dry palm was damp.
Dale was waiting at the foot of the annex steps in the white cold light, with the ledger under his arm and his hat tipped back, looking at the sky. He did not look relieved. He looked like a man who has just won a point in a game he did not know the rules of.
"We got the gate," said Silas.
"We got till the fifth." Dale held out his phone. It showed a little yellow sun, a row of numbers, and a graph that rose like a ramp. "That's the forecast. Tuesday the thirtieth, forty-eight. Monday the twenty-ninth, fifty-two degrees." He put the phone away. "Silas, that's a thaw. If it goes, the Lip sleeps. And whoever's supposed to go down hasn't been found."

