Silas got as far as the first stone before Cade caught his collar.
“No.” The runner hauled him back a full pace with both pink hands. “You’re the caller. You go down there, there’s nobody up here. That’s the whole rule, Ketterman. You said it yourself.”
“She’s seventy-eight.”
“And you’re the one who knows the staves.” Cade’s face, in the lantern light, had gone almost as white as the frost. “Sing. I’ve got the light.”
He lit Dovie’s porch lantern from the cairn and held it up in both hands, higher than he needed to, like a boy carrying a candle in a procession. The flame leaned in the cold air flowing up out of the Hollow, and Cade leaned with it.
Silas planted his boots on the frost beside the first stone. His legs were thin as paper. The Settling had scooped him out, and the well under his ribs was so wide he could feel the night air go through it.
He thought of rope. Blood gave him one to Wyatt. It gave him none to Dovie.
“Aunt Dovie,” he called. “I lied to you at the Lip. He asked me, and I said no. I owe you the truth.”
A scrape came back up the steps. “And I knew you lied, hon. I let it stand. I owed you better.”
“I know,” he said. Something caught between them, slight as a knot pulled tight. It was not the whole truth he owed. It was enough to lay a rope.
Long, low, even.
“Water goes under the hill and is gone,” he sang.
The Calling ran backward, the last stave first. His voice came out of the hollow place in him rough and small, and he laid it along the ground and down the steps, not at the dark but beside it, the way Rena had taught him. The Sink’s lend rose in his eyes like water in a well.
The Hollow opened. The mist lay on the stair like a gray skin, and he could see through it. The path went down in a long, steep spiral into the laurel, and he could count the stands by the pale slabs set into the steps. One. Two. Three. And on the third, a small figure in a man’s wool shirt, sitting with her hands in her lap.
“Water comes out in the day. I will sit by you down in the dark.”
From the third stand, thin and scraping and a half beat late, a ruined voice sang it back.
Cade made a sound in his throat. Neither of them had known whether she could take up the line.
“And sing till you find your way.”
She filled the blank. It was a small, cracked, ugly thing, and it carried up the stair as clear as a bell. “I was afraid of you, Ruthie. Of my own sister.”
The rope went taut. Silas felt it in his teeth.
They went on. The Mail Route stave turned his ears to Odell’s gift, and he heard Dovie’s breath at the third stand, and her boots shift on stone, and then he heard her rise to the second.
The Ladder stave swelled his chest. He sang a line long and slow into the Hollow and the breath held, and held, and did not run out. Each time, Dovie sang it back, and each time she filled the blank. I stayed away. I let her go. I was seventeen, and I’m still seventeen, and I’m sorry.
Cade did not let the lantern waver once. His arms shook. His breath smoked. Somewhere in the second stave the old cairn lantern went out in a gust, and he lit it again with a match, cupped in the shell of his free hand, without lowering the other.
“Easy,” Cade breathed, to the flame. “Easy, easy.”
The first stave was Laurel Run, with its lamp and its root and its stone. At the end of it Dovie answered from the first stand, only a few steps below the Lip. He could see her now, white braid and bent back, climbing the stair on hands and knees. Her gate of a voice was almost steady.
“I’m coming up,” she said, to the dark below her, not to him. “Ruthie. I’m coming up.”
Five hours had gone. The stars stood thick over the saddle. Frost lay on the bracken like salt, and Silas’s voice was a thread, but it held.
“The closing verse,” whispered Cade.
“I know.”
He drew the page from inside his shirt, and he didn’t need to read it. He had it by heart. He had had it by heart since the mailbox.
“I did not go for lack of you,” he sang, and the flame leaned toward the Hollow. “I went for one who cried.”
Dovie had gone for one who cried. It fit her as well as it fit his brother. Maybe that was why Wyatt had written it so, as a verse a stranger could borrow.
“So hold the light and sing it true.”
Cade’s arms were trembling. The lantern shook, and steadied.
“And tell me what you hid.”
The last line stood in front of him like a wall.
The frost did not creak. Down the throat of the Hollow, Dovie had stopped climbing and was waiting on the last stair with her face turned up.
He knew what the hole wanted. He had known since the Mail Route, since the letter, since a porch step three years ago in the dark. It wanted the thing he had hidden hardest, in a place so deep he had built three years of walking over the top of it.
And Cade Lyle was standing beside him in the cold, holding a lantern in two white-knuckled hands, listening. Cade, who had stood here two nights. Cade, who would look at him, after, and know.
He couldn’t. Not in front of him. Not yet.
“I hid that I lied to you at the Lip,” Silas sang. His voice shook. “Aunt Dovie. He did ask me. I said no. And I told you he never asked.”
It was true. He had said it once tonight and heard her answer. But he had left the same thing out, and he knew it.
The Hollow took it, turned it over once, and handed it back.
It was not a blow. It was the feeling of a door closing very quietly on a room he had lived in all his life. Far below, the rope went slack in his hands. He heard Dovie cry out, small and sharp. He heard her boots scrape and slide down the stone, one long falling scrape, and stop on the third stand.
Then the lends went out of him one by one. Night-sight. Far-hearing. The breath. The legs. And when the last went, something that had been his went with them.
He opened his mouth to sing the next line.
Nothing came. Not a note. Not a whisper. Not even the rasp of air.
“Silas?” said Cade.
He tried again. His throat worked. His ribs moved. His lips shaped the words, the whole of Wyatt’s verse, and the cold black air took the shapes and kept them, and no sound came out into the night.
“Say something.”
He couldn’t. Cade’s face turned toward him in the lamplight and slowly came apart. It was the face of a boy who had stood at that hole two nights and been ignored, and had just been shown the one voice that might have worked, spent.
There was no Hollow to see now. There was only the mist, and the cold, and the first stone with Dovie’s coat folded on it. Silas could not hear her. He could not hear anything but the small tick of the lantern’s iron.
He went down on his knees at the edge of the frost and looked at the black throat of the stairs. For three years every direction had been a way out. Here there was none. He had no voice, no lends, no rope, and nowhere at all to walk to.
Cade did the only thing left that either of them knew how to do. He lifted the lantern higher.

