They held the council in Dovie's kitchen, because Dovie said a thing like this ought to be argued over a table with a good cloth on it and not on a hill in the wind.
It was Tuesday morning, gray and raw. The stove was going. Marian had gone to fetch Opie from the state line and had come back with her in the hatchback at eight, the old counter woman sitting upright in the passenger seat with her black ledger on her knees and her tin box in her lap like a hatbox on the way to a funeral. Now she sat at the end of the table with her pencil behind her ear and her glasses catching the lamp. She had refused tea and accepted it.
Around the table sat Dovie, Wyatt, Cade, Marian with her map, Silas, and at the foot, in the chair nearest the door, Reuben Cales, with his hands in his lap and his bread-bagged socks drying on the fender behind him. He had been asked if he wanted to be there. He had said, reasonably, that he would rather be present for the argument about him than hear it from the porch.
"Four rules," said Dovie. "I'll say them plain, and Opal can tell me where I'm wrong."
She held up a finger, bony as a twig.
"One. Not held. A held person is at a stand, filling a blank. If they leave, the stair above them shifts. Dennis said as much."
"Two. Not called. Nobody can call from the bottom. If there's a rope on you, somebody at the top will sing you up the second you're in trouble, and the start of the thing is broken."
"Three. Free to go, and chooses it. Nobody sends. Nobody asks."
"And four." She lowered her hand. "A true thing. The last blank is said to whoever's waiting, and it has to be one only that person could say."
"Counting," said Opie.
She drew the ledger toward her. She opened it, flat, and ran her pencil down a column, though there was nothing there. She had not touched a page. She closed her eyes and sat a moment with her head tilted, as if to listen to a clock in the next room.
"Reuben Cales," she said, finally. "Twenty-nine. I've got nothing on you."
"Ma'am?"
"Not a mark. It isn't that you're uncounted, I've seen those. It's that there's nobody at the other end of the line. Not a rope, not a thread. Not a postcard." Her pencil hand trembled slightly. "I've been at that window fifty-five years and I've never counted a man with a page so clean. It's like looking into a pantry with the door off."
"I wouldn't say I'm clean," said Reuben.
"I would. I'm very sorry." She opened her eyes. "One, two, three. He's got all the first three. I can't count the fourth. A true thing isn't a number."
For a moment nobody in the room breathed.
"No," said Wyatt.
He had been sitting with his chair tipped back against the wall and his arms folded, watching Opie with a face that Silas knew, flat and polite, the face he put on at the edge of a thing he would do anyway. He let the chair down with a clap.
"No. I'm sorry. I'm going to say it plain, because I learned that from the best." He looked at Reuben, not unkindly. "Mr. Cales, I like you. I like your socks. I think you're one of the decent people I've met this year. And we are not going to send a stranger down a hole because he fits a checklist."
"It isn't a checklist if it's my choice," said Reuben.
"Is it your choice if nobody ever offered you another one?"
That landed. Silas, across the table, saw it land. Reuben did not flinch. He turned his head and looked at Wyatt for several seconds with an expression of absolute courtesy. "That's fair," he said. "That's a real point. I'll think about it."
"Don't think. Take a rope."
"A rope."
"The rule's in the bible." Wyatt turned to Dovie. "Non-kin can knot one. Each names a true thing they owe the other, both say it out loud. Any of us. All of us. Make a rope as thick as a hawser. He'd be called. He'd be ineligible. It would take the whole thing off his back."
"It'd take the job away," said Reuben.
"Yes."
"You mean to rope me out of it."
"Yes," said Wyatt. "Absolutely. As hard as I can."
Reuben considered this. He had a way of considering, with his head a little to one side, that made his answers sound as if they had been weighed on a postal scale. "Then no," he said. "Not yet. Ask me again when you mean it as an offer and not as a fence. I don't think you do yet. I think you mean it as a way of not being afraid."
Wyatt opened his mouth. Then he closed it. Cade, at the end of the table, made a small sound that might have been a cough, and Marian looked at her map with enormous attention.
"Wyatt," said Dovie, not unkindly. "He's got you."
"I know he's got me. I'm trying to be upset about it."
"And you." Dovie's eyes turned on Silas, sharp as a pin. "You've been very quiet. You've been to the Lip. You know what it's like."
He was ready for it. He had been ready since Monday night. "I think it's true," he said. "He fits. I think the stone knows what it's doing." He looked at the table. "I also think I was warm and welcome up there, and I'd have gone, Aunt Dovie. I'd have walked down in the dark and been glad of it. And I'd have been wrong. That's what I don't know how to say. The yes isn't the answer. It feels exactly like the answer."
"That's why I'm afraid of it," said Dovie.
Nobody said anything else. There was a long, dry silence in which the stove ticked. Opie shut the ledger. She laid her hand flat on its cover as though to keep it from rising.
"There's a fifth thing," she said, in her flat voice. "It's not a rule. I've no standing to say it. I'll say it once, and then I'll shut up, because I count and I don't choose." She looked at Reuben with her cold pale eyes. "A true thing is for somebody. You'd have to know who. You'd have to know what you owe them. And I don't believe, Mr. Cales, that you've ever in your life had anybody to owe."
Silas thought of the letter in the fourth box, of the tired voice at the bottom of the stair and the twelfth number nobody wrote. He kept his mouth closed. Dennis had asked it of him, in pencil, and it was not his to say.
Reuben was silent a good while. Then he put both his hands flat on the cloth, the way a man does when he means to rise. He did not rise. He sat for a moment longer and looked at each of them in turn, calmly, one at a time, as he might have looked at a trail map to fix its landmarks in his head.
"I hear you," he said. "All of you. I mean it. I'm not going to do it behind anyone's back, and I won't do it tonight." He smiled a little. "I'd like to be sure. And I'd like a deadline, so I don't go on being sure forever."
"What deadline?" said Marian, sharply.
"The longest night's on Sunday," said Reuben. "I read it on the calendar at the diner. That seems like a reasonable day for a man to make up his mind."
"Reuben."
"Sunday," he said, and the whole room heard that he meant it.

