The log chute took forty minutes in the dark, and by the top Silas had stopped counting the ties and started counting his breaths, one to a step, the way Rena did. Gene went first with a headlamp and her rope bag, saying nothing. Wyatt came behind him, humming. Nobody had asked him to stay at the head of the chute this time. He had simply gotten up, put on his borrowed suit coat, and followed.
"I'll go down to the third," Wyatt had said, in the yard. "I owe Trav a visit. I'm not going lower."
The lantern burned in its railroad globe on its stump, a thumb of honey gold, and the frost ring around it had spread to the size of a barn floor. Silas stood a moment with his hand on the cold iron rail. Below the lantern, the stair began: warm gray steps, going down into the pine dark between walls of old sawdust.
They went down in a line. At the third stand, on the planks, sat Trav Olin in his county jacket with his knees up and his sandy mustache in order, exactly as he had sat for twenty-nine days. He raised a hand.
"Hey, boss. Hey, Gene." He peered. "Is that Wyatt Ketterman? Oh, wow. It is. You look about eleven pounds better."
"Eight," said Wyatt, and sat down on the step beside him without being asked.
"Did her dad come?" said Trav. "I heard something. Hannah said, she said there was a lot of noise in the kitchen."
"He came," said Gene. She had stopped, rigid as a post, with her face in shadow. "He sat in the chair."
"Good." Trav smiled at his own knees, a vast mild contented smile. "That's real good. Go on down, I've got company."
Silas went on alone. Below the third stand his legs began to turn to lead, as they had the first time, and he took the steps one at a time, with a hand on the sawdust wall. His throat was very tired. He had spent it all on the radio. He kept his mouth shut, and listened, and in the stillness he could hear a small dry pencil moving on a page.
Fifth stand. A warm blue glow, no brighter than a night light. There was a seat there now, a flat, worn place in the stone about the size of a kitchen chair, and a figure sitting in it, upright, with its hands on its knees.
It had Wyatt's face. It had had Wyatt's face for weeks. Lately it had begun, by tiny degrees, to look like itself, and Silas could not have said what that meant, only that the eyes in the face were older than before, and the jaw less like a jaw and more like a decision. It wore a plain gray shirt. On its knee lay a pad of paper, and in its hand was a stub of yellow pencil, bitten at the end.
"Good evening," said Dennis. "You've brought the pencil."
"I brought two."
"I would like it noted that I only wanted one. But thank you." It laid the stub aside and looked at him. "I'm sorry about your legs. I did say to take the chute slowly."
"You didn't say anything."
"I intended to."
On the sixth stand, a little way below, a girl in a wool coat with her collar up raised two fingers off her knee, without turning, like somebody at the back of a classroom. Hannah Pruitt. Silas raised his own. Then he sat down on the step above the seat, because he could not have stood much longer, and said, "You wrote me a note."
"I did."
"In Dale's book."
"Hannah held the pencil. She has the better hand. I only had to say the letters." Dennis's mouth, with its borrowed shape, made a small dry smile. "I have been practicing. The lists on your mother's icebox. The ones about eggs. I have a lot of feeling about eggs, now."
"You said the tenth is not hers alone. You meant Ruth."
"I meant a number of things." Dennis folded its hands. "I would like to tell you them in order. I would like to be asked correctly. I find I have not got used to being asked at all."
"What's the first?"
"The tenth stave is in pieces." The voice was level and dry and a little hurried, the voice of a patient clerk with something to deliver. "I hear all nine doors now. It is not pleasant. It is like sitting in a house with nine radios and no dial. But I hear the humming at every one, and I can tell you what it is: it is living people, not the stair. People who have carried one phrase their whole lives, because someone sang it over them, without ever being told it was a verse. At Rankin, Ruth. I knew that. At Sutter's Knob, a woman who makes cider."
"Fee."
"Line two. I heard her on Monday, and I answered, which I should not have done." Dennis looked slightly guilty. "I was lonely. It is a very good lullaby. At Bell Hollow I hear a woman who sings while she cooks. I do not know her name. She hums over a kettle. It is very bright, a camp song, line three, I think, and she has no idea."
"And four."
"At the Other One by the state line." Dennis's face changed. It was not a large change. There was a tightening about the eyes, and its hands closed on each other. "I would not go there. I would like that noted, in your notebook, in pencil. Write it."
"Write what?"
"All of it. I would be grateful. A pen is a lie that cannot be taken back, and I may have the order wrong." Silas took out the notebook and turned it over. On the inside cover were his tally strokes, eleven hundred miles of them, and he turned past them, and on a clean page wrote what he was told. Line one, Rankin, Ruth. Line two, Sutter's Knob, Fee. Line three, Bell Hollow, a woman who cooks. Line four, the Other One.
"That is correct," said Dennis. "The Other One is not like the rest. It does not hum. It counts."
"Counts what?"
"Everything. The doors, the stands, the people. It counts them in a very low voice, all night, and I do not like the sound of it. I think it is keeping a ledger." Dennis shivered, a thing Silas had not seen it do before. "It is not a cruel sound. That is what is frightening about it."
Silas wrote it down. His hand was cold. When he looked up, the face in the blue light was watching him with a peculiar steady attention, as if he were a sentence that had not yet come out right.
"The second thing," said Dennis. "You will carry this alone. You always do. You walked eleven hundred miles to avoid being carried, and you will take a verse in four pieces, and you will try to hold all four. I wrote the line because I know you. The tenth is not hers alone. It is not yours alone, either. It is not mine. It is the first thing in my life that I have been permitted to be a part of, and I would like it noted that I do not mean to let you hog it."
Silas laughed. It was a cracked, painful, entirely helpless laugh. He put the back of his hand against his mouth.
"All right," he said. "Noted."
"The third," said Dennis, and now the dry voice dropped. "There is something wrong at the doors. Not the hum. Another sound on top of it. Somebody is playing recordings."
"What?"
"Over the stones. In the daylight. Voices that are not here, singing very old lines, over and over, into the stair. I do not know who they are. They are dead keepers, I think, from a long time ago, and they are being made to say the same sentence a thousand times." The thing in the gray shirt looked up. "They are wrong, Silas. It is like hearing a person you love be made to laugh."
Far above, from the top of the chute, a headlamp flashed twice. Gene's voice came down the pine tunnel, taut with news: "Silas? Silas, it's Marian, she's on my phone. She says Colby just sent her a photograph."
"Of what?"
"Of two men bolting a speaker to a post at the stone at Cutler Ridge," said Gene. "With a sign on it. VOICES OF THE LIPS. Four hundred people downloaded it today."

