The first three attempts went into Lyda Tolliver's cookstove, because she said a bad song was kindling and a good one was a surprise.
Silas had been writing since six that morning. He sat at the oilcloth table in her kitchen with a pencil and the backs of three feed-store receipts, the deaf man's envelope propped against the sugar bowl where he could see it, and a plate of cold biscuits he had not touched. The rain had set in overnight and ran down the window in long gray lines. On the sill, in the pale square of light that fell through the glass, Dennis lay quiet, as a person lies who is trying very hard not to listen to someone else's homework.
Toby Wray sat across from him on an upturned bucket with the fiddle across his knees. He had not gone to school. Pearline Ayers, on the telephone, had told Principal Okafor that the boy was engaged in a work of the church, and Principal Okafor had not asked which one.
"Again," said Toby.
"I can't."
"Just the first one. The first line. You've got it, you just keep, you keep making it pretty."
Silas looked at the crumpled receipt in his hand. It said:
Oh, I will set a light on the hill And pray for them that roam
"It's pretty," said Toby. "It's not true."
"It's about a light on a hill."
"Mrs. Tolliver doesn't pray. She told me. She just hums." The boy turned the fiddle in his lap. "Think about the oil can. Think about, you know, Buddy and Ray. Nobody up there says it's a prayer. They say it's a kindness."
It was a hard thing to hear, and it was right. Silas tore the receipt in half, and gave it to Lyda, who was sitting by the stove with her feet on a hassock and her shawl round her, and she dropped it into the firebox with a small, satisfied nod.
It was not the writing that was difficult. He had written the fifth stave in a night. It was that he had known what the fifth was about, because it was about him. This one was about thirty-one households, and a boy in a gray coat, and a woman who had waited sixty-three years, and a man named Jesse who had sat down on a cold stair for another man's life. It was not his to tell. He kept reaching for a line and finding that it belonged to somebody else.
"Say what you've got," said Gene Tolliver.
She was standing in the doorway with her arms folded. She had been awake all night at the head of the chute with her back to the stump and a thermos of coffee, keeping Trav company through the planks. There was a gray, burned look about her, but she was steady. "Not the song. Just say what's there."
"There's a light," said Silas. "There's a chair."
"Good."
"There's a, somebody goes up. Somebody stays." He stopped. "Mrs. Gaskill said it was always a chair. And Mrs. Tolliver said Jesse said, 'Go on up, son. I'll sit a spell.'"
Lyda lifted her head.
She had gone still in her chair, with the stove light on her walnut face. She looked at him a long time, through the enormous glasses, and then, very slowly, she began to speak in a voice that was only a breath.
"He said it like that. 'Go on up. I'll sit a spell.' He had a stammer, you know. He never stammered on that. He never did when he said it, not once, not in all the years. I didn't know why." Her mouth trembled. "I think it was the only thing he ever said that he didn't have to think about."
Nobody breathed.
"That's the third line," said Toby, in a whisper. "That's the third line, Silas. That's it."
"It's not mine."
"It's not anybody's. That's the whole point. It's just true."
Silas picked up the pencil. His hand was not steady. He wrote, on the back of a receipt, in square block capitals, the line the old woman had given him, and under it, above it, the one the schoolteacher had given. He had a light. He had a chair. He had a man's own last words, and a hill full of oil cans. It came up in him as it had come in the dark of the eighth stand, not as an idea but as a pressure, a thing that had been there all along and only needed a place to set down.
He wrote four lines, slowly. Then he crossed one out and wrote it again. Toby hummed the old note, the single held hum, low and level, while he worked, and bent his fiddle string to it, a hair sharp, so that the tone wavered like a flame in a draft. Lyda, in her chair, was crying without a sound. Nobody mentioned it.
At a quarter past eleven he laid the pencil down.
"Read it," said Wyatt.
He had come in some time ago, with Cade, and sat on the bench by the stove with his boots stretched out. He had a mug in his hand and a blanket round his shoulders and a look of grave attention that Silas remembered, from a long time ago, on the faces of people listening to a song in church.
Silas read it aloud. His voice cracked on the second line, at the G, as it always did, and he let it.
I leave a light at the head of the chute, I keep a chair by the fire; Go on up home, I'll sit a spell, And here is why I'd stay: ________
The room was perfectly quiet.
"That's it," said Gene.
"It's not done. The blank." He pushed the heel of his hand against his eye. "The blank has to be something somebody can fill. The ones at Rankin were all, I mean the blank asks a question. It's got to be a real one. I don't think 'here is why I'd stay' is, I don't know. It's the best I've got."
"It's the one," said Dennis.
Everyone looked at the sill.
"It is the right question," said the pale shape, "because it can only be answered by someone who is already deciding to." It spoke very quietly. "I think that is what the seat is. It is not a punishment. It is a reason, said aloud. I have been thinking about what I would say, and I do not know yet. I would like that noted." A pause. "It is a very good stave."
"You can't hear it," said Wyatt. "Nobody's sung it."
"I can hear it. It has been humming for a day and a half."
Lyda was the one who laughed. It was a small, cracked, delighted sound, like a gate swinging in a high wind. She wiped her glasses on her cardigan and put them on again and looked at the shadow.
"I'd like to sing it," she said. "Tonight. The first line. If I'm let."
Gene took a breath. "Granny, you can't climb that chute."
"I know I can't, baby."
"You haven't been up it in five years. Your heart."
"I know my own heart." But she was smiling. "I'll find a way."
Nobody argued with her. It was a few minutes after noon. The rain had thinned to a drizzle, and at the window a clear pale light was coming through the bare lilac, falling on the oilcloth and the sugar bowl and the envelope against it: HE WAS MY BROTHER AND I WAS GLAD. Silas looked at it. He had four lines on a feed-store receipt, and a hill, and a seat, and thirty hours.
And then, from the road outside, through the wet window, there came the sound of a great many boots on gravel.
Silas stood up. He crossed the kitchen and put his face to the glass.
They were coming up the plank road in twos and threes, in rain jackets and feed caps and church coats, thirty or forty of them, a little crowd of Pinch Gap, with Buddy and Ray at the front. Behind them, four men in muddy boots carried between them, on two long poles tied with baling twine, a kitchen chair with a quilt thrown across the seat. It was, he saw, Corinne Gaskill's, from the schoolhouse porch. A small, straight old woman in a shawl walked alongside, holding her Bible against her chest.
They stopped in front of the house. Edna stepped forward. She had a thermos in one hand and a string of Christmas lights in the other, and she said, politely, to the window, "We heard there'd be a singing. We thought you might need a way up."

