Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 52

Asking Right

They gave Lorna Beck the hour she had been offered, and then they gave her until Thursday, because by the end of the hour she was sitting in Lyda Tolliver's kitchen with a cup of coffee going cold in both hands, and nobody had the heart to take it back.

Dovie had stayed with her. Gene had gone up the chute to sit with Trav. And Wyatt had walked off down the plank road in his brother's flannel with a shadow trailing behind him, toward the creek behind the church, and Silas had followed, because it was what he had done all his life.

The creek at Pinch Gap was no wider than a doorway. It ran low and clear over brown stones between banks of dead fern, and there was a fallen sycamore across it, white as a bone,. Wyatt lowered himself onto the trunk. He put his hands between his knees. Silas sat beside him. The winter sun came down through the bare branches in long pale bars.

On the log between them, flat as a pressed leaf, the second shadow waited.

"You told her I'd do it," said Dennis. It said it very quietly. "Before you asked me."

"I know," said Wyatt. "I'm sorry. I'd like it noted that I had about four seconds."

"It is noted."

"I thought, there's only one person here who can sit for the rest of time and not be missed." He said it quite gently. "And then I thought, no. That's the thing I was wrong about."

The water went on talking.

"You have misstated the rule," said Dennis, after a while. "I have been thinking about it. May I?"

"Please."

"Mrs. Tolliver said the seat must be one who will be missed. It is not a legal condition. It is a physical one." The pale shape raised its blank head. "I think the stair is made of what people leave behind. It holds a person by the hole that person would make. A stranger would make none. There would be nothing for it to hold on to, and so it would let him through, and he would walk on down, and the seat would be empty, and no one would come up." It was silent for a moment. "I have never been missed, Silas Ketterman. I have been avoided. It is not the same."

Silas looked at his brother. Wyatt's face had gone very gray, and very still.

"I could not hold a seat," said Dennis. "I am glad of it. I do not wish to put myself where I am not wanted."

"Dennis," said Wyatt.

"Yes."

"I want to tell you something, and I want you to hear it all the way to the end." He turned on the log. He was looking at the shadow now, directly, in the bar of the sun. His hands, which had been loose, had begun to tremble. "I was angry at you for a year. Down there. You were in me, and you were all the things I'd never said, and I thought if I held still and didn't listen, you'd go quiet. You never did. You sat by me in the dark for three years, and you said every single true thing I was afraid of, one at a time, in that dry little voice, and I hated you for it. I hated you so much I gave you a joke name. And you never once said it back."

"I am not able to hate," said Dennis. "I have tried."

"I know." His brother's face twisted. "That's the worst part. And I'd miss you. I want to say that. If you went down there tomorrow and sat on the fifth stand for good, I would miss you every day of my life. I'd put a saucer on the sill. I'd talk to the wall. I don't think I'd be right, afterward. I'd sit at the supper table and know there was a place where you weren't." He stopped. He wiped his face with the back of his wrist. "That's the truth. I paid for it. It cost something."

The creek ran.

The shadow on the log did not move at all. It lay perfectly flat in its bar of light. Silas could not have said how long. He found that he was holding his breath. And then, very slowly, it began to change. The pale edge, the faceless head, went somehow darker, not in color, but in grain, as if a thing had been poured into it and settled.

"That is a true sentence," said Dennis. "It cost the speaker. I felt it go by." It said it in a very odd voice, a little high, a little lost, the voice of a person who has been handed a thing he doesn't know where to put. "I have said ten thousand sentences, and none of them has ever cost anyone anything. You are the first who has said one to me. And I have been," it paused, searching, "moved. I think that is the word. I did not think I had a place to be moved in."

"Is it all right?" said Wyatt, raggedly.

"It is a great deal more than all right. It is an enormous nuisance."

Wyatt laughed. It came out of him all in a piece, as it had at the Lip, with his head down on his knees, and Silas put an arm round his shoulders and held on.

"Then I will sit," said Dennis.

"You don't have to."

"I know that. It is why it is mine." The shadow settled, like a leaf onto water. "I will sit in the seat of Mrs. Beck's son, in the fifth stand, beside the other one, and I will hold it. I think I am able. I do not sleep and I do not tire and I am not hungry. I have sat three years already. I should like it to be for something." A pause. "But you have not asked me the other half."

"What other half?"

"The stair will not let me down because I am willing. It will not let the boy up because I am there. There is a thing that has to be sung." Dennis said it with great care. "A song for this stair. A stave of its own, with a blank. A stair does not release a man for a hum. It wants the words. And there are none. Mrs. Tolliver has had one line for sixty-three years and the rest have never been made."

Silas felt it come at him from a long way off, as a wind comes over a field.

"I can't," he said. "I don't have it. I've got nine staves and none of them work here, you saw. I don't even know the, I've never walked the trail."

"No one has," said Dennis. "That is what I am telling you."

"Silas." Wyatt had lifted his head. His eyes were red and perfectly clear. "You wrote the fifth. You wrote it in front of the Borrower, with a cracked G, in a night. You didn't walk it. You wrote it from what was true."

"That was different."

"It was exactly the same. It was just yours." His brother held his gaze. "I can't. I'm the one who goes down, and I'm the one who's here, and I haven't got a whole voice. And Dennis can't, it's the whole trouble. You're the one with the G. You're the one who sits."

"I would also like to say," said Dennis, "that I have a condition."

"Go on."

"When it is done, and I am sitting, and the boy has gone home, I should like someone to tell me that it was noticed. Not because they must. Because they did." It was quite steady. "I would like one person to say it who was not made to."

"We'll say it," said Wyatt.

"You are made to. You are my," a pause, "I do not have the word. You will say it because you have to. I should like it from the one who does not." Slowly, delicately, the pale head turned. "From the one who sat with me."

Silas did not answer for a long time. The great plain weight of the thing settled down through his chest, and rested.

Then he took out of his coat pocket a small folded square of paper, and a stub of pencil, and a plastic bread bag, and began to smooth the bag out flat on his knee.

"All right," he said. "I've got until Thursday. I'm going to need the whole town."

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!