It began to talk at what might have been midnight, and it did not stop for a very long time.
Silas did not sing. He had thought about that on the way down, and he had thought about Rena at her porch rail with her machine purring. You don't sing at somebody in the dark. You sing beside them. So he sat on the cold slab with his back against the wall and his brother's shoulder against his own, and he put his hands in his lap, and he listened.
"I never liked the hymn," said the shadow.
It did not use Wyatt's voice. It used the other one, the dry soft curious voice of a very old child, and it spoke into the dark in front of it, not to either of them. "The one with the lamp and the laurel. I sang it for forty years at that church and I never liked it. I only sang the alto because the tenors were too good-looking."
It paused, as if to see what would happen.
Nothing happened. The fog lay on the slab. Wyatt's breathing had gone slow and deep.
"I took forty dollars from the register in nineteen eighty-eight," said the shadow. "I told them it was the new boy. They let him go."
"I'm here," said Silas, quietly.
"I wanted the divorce. I never said so. I said I wanted to work it out. I wanted the divorce for eleven years." A pause. "I am not sorry my father is dead."
"I'm here."
"I never liked the baby."
He had thought it would be terrible. It was, a little. But mostly it was ordinary. It was the plainest, drabbest, most unbearable list in the world: the small, mean, silly things people had never said, one after another in a little level voice with no heat in it at all. I stole the pie plate. I was glad when she moved away. I hate the way he chews. I told her I'd be right back and I wasn't. I don't love you the way you love me. I prayed for him to die and then he did. He heard it come out of the dark like water out of a tap, and each one was true. He knew it was true by the way it landed. It did not ring. It did not echo. It dropped into the Hollow without a sound and was gone, and the shadow drew a long breath, and said the next.
Whose were they?
He understood that after the first hour. They were not Wyatt's. Wyatt had never stolen a pie plate in his life. They were the unsaid of other people, of the ones in the sheriff's book, held at their stands and not yet called. The thing had been sitting here three years beside the nearest living ear, and the nearest living ear belonged to a young man who had stopped counting at some number, and it had been telling him, in order, everything that had been left on the stair.
"Wyatt," whispered Silas.
His brother's head had sunk onto his shoulder. He was asleep.
It was not an ordinary sleep. It was the sleep of a man who had not closed his eyes in three years because something was always about to speak. His mouth was open a little. The frost under his palm had thinned to a lace. The shadow, beside him, went on talking in a lower voice so as not to wake him.
Silas sat with his arm around his brother's shoulders for what felt like six hours.
He thought about Rena. He thought: she did this. She did this for eleven hundred people, thirty-one years of nights, and she never once told anyone what it cost. They talk, the dying. At three in the morning they say anything. They say I never loved him, I hated my mother, I'd go back if I could. And a night nurse sits there and says, I'm here, and writes none of it down, and in the morning she goes home and makes eggs. It is not a thing anyone is trained to do. It is only a thing one person can do for another, and almost nobody does it.
"I stole my sister's wedding ring," said the shadow. "I said she lost it. She cried for a week."
"I'm here."
"She's been dead since March. I never said."
"I'm here," said Silas, and found that his voice had gone ragged. "I heard you."
The shadow stopped.
It had never stopped before. It had gone on all through the night, without pause, in its level soft voice, and now it was quiet, and Silas felt the whole dark listening. A long way up the stair a stone dripped. Behind the black wall Ruth sang four notes, very low, in her sleep.
"That one is paid," said the shadow.
"What?"
"The last one. The sister." It said it slowly, as if tasting a word it had never had occasion to use. "When you said you heard me. It went somewhere. It didn't go in the well. It went someplace. I don't know where."
He looked at it. It had turned its blank face to him. It was very close, in the fog, a young man's outline with no features in it, and the pale hand beside Wyatt's was flat on the stone, and a thin line of frost had started, very faintly, to grow out from under it.
"It's the first time," said the shadow, "that anyone has been in the room."
"I'm not going anywhere."
"They all go. They hear one, two. They hear the first sentence. They say, it's lying, it's a monster. They sing at me. They put their hands over their ears." Its soft voice shook, very slightly. "Nobody has ever stayed to the sister."
"Dennis," said Silas, and was ashamed at once.
"No," said the shadow.
It said it quite mildly. "That one is not a name. That one is a kindness he did me, because he was frightened and could think of nothing else. It is a very good joke. I have kept it." A pause. "A name has to be given by someone who means it. I would know."
He was silent. He could not think of a thing to say.
"Go on, then," said the shadow. "Go up. You are tired and your hands are cold. You have a long climb, and no one lends you anything to go up with. There's a great deal more. I don't think there's an end. I have been saving them up for a very long time." It turned its face away. "I don't mind. I did not expect to be heard at all."
"I'll come back."
"They say that."
"I will." He eased Wyatt's head off his shoulder and laid it on the folded jacket he had brought for the purpose, and Wyatt did not stir. "I'll come back. With everyone. I want to ask you something."
"Ask."
"The names. Everyone in the sheriff's book. Do you know where they are? Do you have all of them?"
The shadow turned back. For a very long moment it did not speak.
"I have what they didn't say," it answered. "I don't have them. They're at their stands. Where they hold." It lifted its head. "Silas Ketterman. May I ask you something now?"
It was the first time it had said his name. It was the first time it had said anyone's.
"Yes."
"I have so many," said the shadow. "I have all of them, all these mouths, and I've never had a mouth that was mine. Nobody gave me one. I've been wearing his, because he was nearest, because he listened." Its voice was plain and soft and quite without complaint. "I should like to know. Whose mouth is it supposed to be?"
He climbed.
It was the longest climb of his life. He went up on his hands and knees at the last, on stone that fought him every step, with no lend in his legs and the clothesline round his chest and the cold slowly seeping up through his boots. The Hollow gave him nothing. The Hollow had only ever lent him the way down. At the fifth stand he lay on his face on the slab and said the one thing he had left, which was his mother's name, and at the third he said Cade's, and when he came to the first, a rope tightened on his chest and a hundred hands took hold of him and pulled him up out of the dark into the gray October morning.
"He's here," said June, on her knees in the wet grass. "Hold him. Hold him. He's breathing."
"One," said Rena, from her chair. "Two."
It was Saturday. It was afternoon. He had been down for eighteen hours.

