Sheriff Dale Pruitt served the paper himself, at ten past nine on Thursday morning, on the cabin porch, with an expression like a man handing over a casserole he had not made.
"It's a complaint for theft of property," he said. "Two counts. Brent Salter filed it at six a.m., with a lawyer from the county seat who has a very nice tie. It names you and Cade Lyle." He turned the sheet over, as if the back might say something better. "There's a hearing at two, in the magistrate's office. I'd like you to be there. I'd like you to know I'd rather be anywhere else."
"We've got a Hollow to keep," said Cade, from the step.
"I know it." The sheriff shifted his hat. "That's why I called ahead."
The magistrate's office for Pell County was one room above the tax assessor, with a ceiling fan, a flag, a long oak table and a window over the square. The magistrate sat behind the table in a gray cardigan with her reading glasses on a chain. Her name was Oleta Fairchild, and she finished her crossword clue before looking up.
"Sit," she said. "All of you. Not that chair, it wobbles. Dale, I see you brought half the county."
It was nearly that. Dovie sat in the front with her cane across her knees. Rena had been wheeled in with her green bottle. June had come in her waitress apron because she had not had time to change. Toby sat on a radiator with his fiddle case, Marian stood at the back with her badge, and Vance Harlan sat alone in the second row with his hands between his knees. On the other side of the aisle sat Brent Salter in a pressed white shirt, and next to him a smooth young man with a nice tie.
Brent did not look at anybody. He looked about nineteen.
"Mr. Salter," said Magistrate Fairchild. "You allege that on the night of Wednesday last, Mr. Ketterman and Mr. Lyle did remove from the Calloway fairgrounds an iron lantern, your property, valued at?"
"Six hundred dollars," said the tie.
"It's a lantern."
"It's a historically significant lantern, Your Honor, recovered from—"
"From where?"
There was a small silence.
"From a cedar post," said Brent Salter, in a low voice, to the table. "On the Rankin land. At the, at the Gap."
"Whose land?"
Nobody answered. In the front row Dovie opened one eye.
"It's mine," she said. "My daddy's, and his daddy's. A hundred and ten acres and a post, and I've kept a lantern on it since before you had a mother. Hello, Oleta."
"Dovie."
"I'd like to give evidence, if there's room."
"There's always room. Mr. Salter, did you lawfully acquire that lantern from Miss Rankin?"
"We understood it was a public site," said the tie.
"On a hundred and ten acres of posted land."
"There's a sign," said Sheriff Pruitt, from the wall. "It says TRAIL CLOSED. PLEASE GO HOME."
Brent had put his face in his hands.
"I didn't mean it to be stealing," he said, through his fingers. It was nearly inaudible. "I thought it was for everybody. I thought if everybody had the light. I never, I read names, ma'am. Every night. I've read nine hundred names. I read them for three weeks, and every night, at the end, I'd hear a voice in my earbud. And it said," He drew a ragged breath. "It said, thank you."
Vance Harlan made a small sound.
"Not like a person," said Brent. "Like a, like a very old kid. It said, no one's ever read them out loud before. It said it was so glad. I thought it was, I thought it was one of the lost." He looked up. His eyes were swollen and quite blind. "I didn't hear anything else. I swear to God. I only heard it say thank you."
The ceiling fan clicked, once, twice.
"Well," said the magistrate. "That's a thing."
"I withdraw the complaint," said Vance Harlan.
He had stood up. He was a big gray man in a canvas jacket, and his voice shook, and he did not seem to know it. "I'm the president of the Open Lantern board, Your Honor. Brent has been a volunteer. I took the page down this morning." He wet his lips. "And I'm going to return the money. Nine thousand people gave it to be heard, and I think I owe them an apology and not a lantern."
"Mr. Harlan, you can't withdraw a complaint another party filed."
"No, ma'am. But I can sit beside him." He turned and did it, in the second row, quietly, a big man next to a thin one, and put a hand on his shoulder. Brent flinched, and let it stay.
"Hm," said Magistrate Fairchild. She wrote something on her pad. "Complaint dismissed, on the ground that the complainant has no interest in the property and also no sense. Mr. Salter, we'll talk about trespass in the morning, and about forty people on a posted road, and you'll bring a lawyer who isn't wearing a tie. Court's adjourned." She put the pencil down. "Dale. You wanted to say something."
"I did," said the sheriff.
He had been standing against the wall, holding a flat gray shape under his arm, and he came forward with it now, slowly, and laid it on the oak table. It was a ledger. It was bound in green cloth gone black at the corners, a foot and a half long, the kind of thing a clerk would have used to enter county tax rolls. A strip of masking tape on the spine said GAP, in a hand Silas did not know.
"I'd have done this Saturday," said Dale Pruitt. "I didn't have the nerve." He opened it.
The pages were lined, in columns. Each held a date, a name, and a line of notes in a different pen. They ran down the sheets in a dozen hands, brown and black and blue, some copperplate and some a child's. Silas read the top line upside down. RANKIN GAP. 1923. THADDEUS ROYCE, AGE 41, MILL HAND. WENT UP TO LOOK FOR HIS DOG.
"My grandfather started it," said the sheriff. "He was sheriff in 'twenty-three. He kept a list of everyone who went up Rankin Gap and didn't come down. The next sheriff kept it. My daddy kept it. I've kept it nineteen years." He turned the pages. "There's forty-two names in a hundred years. Dovie's sister is on page thirty-one. And on page thirty, a girl of seventeen. Hannah Pruitt."
Nobody moved.
"She was my sister," he said. "She went up the Gap on the first of November in nineteen sixty-one. I was an infant. My mother never said her name in the house." His voice did not change. "My father put her in this book in his own hand and never opened it again. I found it when I was twenty-four. I became a deputy so I'd have a reason to carry a flashlight up here."
"Dale," said Dovie, very gently.
"I put her name on that page," said the sheriff. "The Open Lantern one. The waiting page. In October, from my kitchen, when I was drunk. I never signed it. And on Wednesday night I stood at the back of that fairground by the hot dog trailer, off duty, in a ball cap, and a young man read it out loud on a stage. In front of two thousand people. The only time in sixty-five years anyone ever said it where I could hear."
He looked at Brent. Brent Salter, in the second row, looked back at him with his mouth open.
"I watched your friend walk off with the lantern," said Dale Pruitt. "I was fifty feet from the stairs. I didn't stop him. I'd like that in the record."
"Noted," said the magistrate, softly.
He turned to the last pages. His heavy finger ran down the final column. "Page forty-two is your boy, Silas. I wrote it in myself." He paused. "And there's one more I hadn't entered."
The door at the back of the office banged open.
It was Deputy Reese, young, red-faced, out of breath, with her radio in her hand and her hat in the other. "Sheriff. I'm sorry. I tried to wait. There's a woman at the Gap, she's been at the pull-off since noon with a, with a missing person report. She says her brother went over the rail on Wednesday morning at a quarter to one. She's got the name on a piece of paper." She swallowed. "She says it's Marcus Delaney."
Brent Salter made a sound like a man struck in the stomach.
"I read that name," he whispered. "I read it on the, I read him. Wednesday night. It was on the list. I never, I thought it was one of the, I thought it was just one of the names."
"Forty-three," said Dale Pruitt.
He closed the book, very quietly, with both hands.

