It was a quarter past one on Wednesday morning when they came up to the Lip and found the post empty.
The hook on the cedar post was bare. The cairn was dark. In the grass, where a week of frost had lain white in a ring no wider than a lantern's light, there was a pale smear a few feet across, going gray at the edges, and as Silas watched, the gray crept in a finger's width.
"Forty of them," said Marian, behind him. She had a handkerchief wound around her hand. She said it without stammering, flatly, like a woman reading an incident report. "They came up the cart road at eleven with flashlights and a hand truck and a cooler. Brent had a clipboard. He said the sheriff had sanctioned it. Deputy Reese got a call and went down the mountain. Ferrell stood in the path. They went round him."
"I DIDN'T HIT ANYONE," wrote Ferrell, on the slate. He looked as though he wished he had.
"Where did they take it?"
"Calloway. The fairgrounds. Brent said they'd put it on a stage." She swallowed. "He said, everybody should have the light."
"It's going," said Cade.
He was on his knees at the edge of the gray. His hand was out, flat over the grass, and it shook. The frost had a dull, drowned look, as if the first warm breath of the thaw had finally caught it. "It's going now. It's an hour. Maybe two. We had nine nights, we had a hand a night, and it's a hand an hour without it. Silas, I can't hold it." His voice went up. "I can't hold it, I haven't got it."
"Easy," said Everett.
He had come up behind his son with something in his two big hands, and he held it out. It was a glass jar, the kind June put up beans in, with a plain white candle burning in the bottom of it in a puddle of its own wax. He had carried it up the mountain in the crook of his arm with his coat held over it against the wind.
"Rena's kitchen," he said. "From the window over the sink. She's lit it every night for nineteen years."
Silas looked at it.
It was a small thing. A kitchen candle in a jar. It was not the lantern that had stood on that stone for eleven nights, and he did not know if it would work. It did not seem to matter. Cade took it in both hands, as he had taken the lantern, and set it on the first stone, and cupped his palms around the glass.
The gray stopped.
It did not go back. It held at a plate's width, a pale gray-white ring not much bigger than a saucer, and the cold coming up out of the stair breathed on the candle and the flame bent. It did not go out.
"That's an hour," said Rena, very low.
"Then we'd better use it."
They gathered round the stone. Silas knelt, with Dovie's cane at his shoulder and Cade's hands beside the jar. Rena had been wheeled up to the very edge of the white. Everett stood behind her chair, and June had come up the cart road in her coat over her nightgown, and Toby crouched with his laptop in its plastic bag, its small red eye blinking. Nobody said anything.
Silas drew a breath. He was a boy with nine staves in his chest and a cracked G, and he did not know what he was about to do. He only knew that it was the right hour, and that the thing in the dark had waited for it.
"I'm going to sing the ninth," he said. "Just the ninth. And I'm going to give it a blank, and I want both of you to fill it. Out loud. At the same time. Do you hear me?"
Silence.
"Si," said the first voice, hoarse, a long way down.
"Si," said the second, from the same place.
"Not a word more than the blank. Just the true thing. That's all." He wet his lips. "That's all I'm asking."
He sang it.
It was nothing like the church. It was one voice on a cold hill, plain, a little unsteady, and it went down into the stair like a stone dropped in a well. One voice calls and the many sing. And none of us sings alone. He heard Rena's breath catch behind him, and June's, and a thin dry sound that was Dovie's cane tapping the stone three times. I lend my breath to the one below. To carry him back to his own.
The blank opened.
For a moment he thought nothing would come. The stair was entirely quiet, as it had been for two nights. The candle stood very straight in its jar.
Then two voices spoke.
The first one was low and hoarse, and it said, "I'm so tired, Si. I can't let go of it. I'm not holding the door because I'm brave. I'm holding it because I don't know how to stop."
And the Hollow rang.
It was the bell, clean and low, rising through the stone. He felt it in his boots. A thin gold thread ran down the stair into the dark and then, quite suddenly, faded.
The second voice had spoken at the same moment. It was clear and strong and warm. It was an entirely sweet voice, and it said, in a perfectly level tone, every word distinct:
"I wanted you to refuse. I was angry at you for a year. I wanted you to say no so I'd have a reason to go."
It did not ring.
There was no echo. There was not even the small dull sound of a stone on mud. It fell into the Hollow like a coin into a well with no water in it, and the silence closed over it.
Silas stood very still.
He knew that voice. That was the horrible thing. He knew every word of it. He had gone back over the porch step a thousand times in three years, and he had never once thought of it, and when he heard it he knew it for the truth in the same instant that he knew that he had not been told. Wyatt had been angry. Wyatt, who walked toward things and named every dog he met, had been so angry at his little brother for a year that he had gone looking for a reason to leave. And he had never said it. Not in the first letter, not in the second. He had put it in his pocket with the stone.
"That's true," said the first voice, in the dark.
It was very small. It was Wyatt's, and it was tired, and the breath at the end of it caught.
"That's true, Si. It's mine. I never said it. I held it back, I had it in my pocket the whole last year, and it got loose somewhere on the stair. It's been wearing my voice ever since." A pause, an uneven breath. "Don't you dare hate it. It's not a copy. It's the part of me I kept back."
"Wyatt," said Silas.
"I'm here. I'm the one who rang."
"It's got the other half of you."
"It's got what I wouldn't say." A tired, awful, almost fond laugh. "And it says it so well, Si. It's so honest. It tells the truth with no cost at all, and nobody's ever been so tempted."
The candle flame bent. The cold came up out of the stair in a long slow breath, and Silas understood, with a sensation like missing a step, that he was not frightened. It was not what he had expected to feel. He turned his head, and he said, to the second voice, quite gently, because Wyatt had written it in a letter he had read in a church:
"Thank you."
The Hollow went entirely still.
It was the first time anything had stopped it. For a long time nothing happened at all. The second voice did not say Si. It did not say anything.
Then it spoke, and for the first time it was not Wyatt's voice. It was nobody's. It was a plain soft voice, dry, sexless, curious, a voice Silas had never heard, the voice of a very old child.
"No one has ever said that," it said.
The candle went out.
It did not gutter. It went out as if a hand had closed over it, and the whole Lip was black, and Silas heard Cade cry out, and Rena's breath catch, and under it all the voice came up from the dark, gentle as a hand on a sleeping face.
"Now you know what I am," it said. "Come get your light."

