Mercy Chapel stood where the county road quit pretending to be a highway, a white frame church on a stone foundation with a tin roof the color of old teeth and a bell in a cupola the size of a birdhouse. Everett parked the truck in the gravel lot among the headstones, and for a moment nobody got out.
"Seventy years," said Dovie, "and I could draw you the floor."
It was Monday, a little after nine. The rain had gone and left a washed, yellow, dripping sky. The graveyard rose behind the church in tilted rows of fieldstone and marble, with plastic geraniums on the newer ones, and Silas saw, near the back fence, a stone he knew, flat and gray, carved RUTH ANN RANKIN, 1946. There was no second date. Somebody had put fresh cedar on it.
"Every spring," said Dovie, following his eyes. "I've never missed a spring. There's nothing under it."
She went up the steps with her cane. Silas went after her, hat in his hand, and Everett came behind, big and quiet, ducking under the lintel as a man does who has spent his life in trucks.
The door was open.
Inside it smelled of lemon oil and old hymnals and the damp wool of a hundred winter coats. There were twelve plain pews on each side of a plain aisle, with a pulpit made out of a single board, and the light came through clear glass windows in long slow bars. In the front, a very small old woman stood on a stool wiping the top of a piano with a dust rag.
"Dovie Rankin," she said, without turning around. "I wondered when it would be you."
"Pearline."
"I'd have bet on the first of October. Then it came and went." She climbed down off the stool, bit by bit, in a navy cardigan and sensible shoes, and turned. She was seventy-nine, with a face like a dried apple and bright black eyes. She held out her hand to Silas, and it was dry and warm and astonishingly strong. "Pearline Ayers. You're the Ketterman boy. The other one."
"Yes, ma'am."
"He sat right there." She pointed with the dust rag at the back pew on the left. "Four Wednesdays in a row. I took him for a graduate student. He sat with his notebook on his knee and never said a word until the break, and then he came up and asked me if the church had a hymn that nobody could remember the tune to."
"Did it?" said Silas.
"Honey, it had a hundred." Her black eyes were amused. "I run the singing school. Wednesday nights, since I was twenty-one. We sing the old way, out of the shape-note books, four shapes to the scale so a person who can't read a note can read a triangle. Fifty-eight years. We've got twenty-three, thirty on a good night. And he comes up and says, is there one that was lined out, and then dropped, and never written down."
"There is," said Dovie.
"There is." Pearline folded the dust rag over her arm. "Your mother's, Dovie. I'd have sent for you forty years ago, but she asked me not to."
Dovie went very still.
"Your mother put it in my hands the week after Ruth. She said, there's something in here the mountain wants and I'm too frightened to find out what. She said, keep it in the church, Pearline, where it can't do any harm. And you don't ever give it to Dovie unless Dovie asks." She looked at the old woman gently. "You never asked."
"I didn't know to."
"No. Nobody did." She went to the piano bench, lifted the lid, and took out a bundle in a flour sack.
It was a book. It was small and square and thick, bound in black cloth gone gray, with a spine that had been mended with twine, and a title on the cover in faded gold that had mostly rubbed away. The corners had been handled to softness. Dovie took it in both hands, as Silas had seen her take nothing else, and sat down on the front pew, and opened it on her knee.
"Page one hundred and nine," said Silas.
"How did you know that?" said Pearline.
"A friend told us."
Pearline's eyebrow lifted. She did not ask.
Dovie turned pages. They were soft as flannel, brown at the edges. Each held a hymn in fine small print, with the notes drawn as triangles and circles and squares along the staves, and in a few places the margins were crowded with a woman's handwriting: dates, names, the weather. Funeral. Rain. The Ketterman baby. Silas knew the writing. It was a hand a lot like Dovie's, in a smaller child's loop.
"Mama," Dovie whispered.
Page one hundred and nine was nearly bare. There was a hymn at the top, four short lines, in the old square notes, and a title that had been erased by a thumb a long time ago, and beneath the lines there was a wide white space, very clean, the width of a man's palm. Somebody had drawn a box in the space in pencil. It was empty.
"It's a blank," said Silas.
"It's a lined-out," said Pearline. "The leader gives the line and the people sing it back. Look at the margin."
In the margin beside the hymn, in a tall, quick, careful hand he would have known in the dark, somebody had written in pencil:
Leader, then the people. Not one voice. A house.
And under it:
Every one of them fills the blank. At once. Out loud. A hymn wants a house, and a house wants everybody.
Silas read it three times. He found that his hand was on the pew in front of him, holding it hard.
"Four Wednesdays," said Pearline. "He copied out the tune. I let him. He said it was for a friend, who'd need it in the end, and I said I'd teach it to anybody who asked. He said, 'Miss Ayers, I don't think anybody's going to ask for four years.'" She put her dust rag down. "He was right. It's been three. I'm sorry I'm late."
"You're not late," said Dovie. Her voice was unsteady. "You kept it."
"I kept it in a piano bench."
"That's keeping."
Everett had taken off his cap, a thing Silas had not seen him do in a church. He turned it in his hands and said, "Miss Ayers, how many people does it take? To sing it, I mean. If a man wanted to do it right."
"Wyatt asked me the same." Pearline smiled. "I told him a house. It's a hymn that wants a congregation, Mr. Lyle. You can't carry it by yourself. It's got to be said by all of them at once, each one filling the gap with their own true thing, out loud, in front of everybody. And not one of them can be the leader." She put a hand flat on her chest. "I've heard it once. Fifty-nine years ago. My mother's church did it for a woman who was dying badly. I was twenty. I never forgot what it sounded like when a hundred people said what they meant at once."
"What did it sound like?"
"Like the sea," said Pearline Ayers, "if the sea had hands."
Something had folded itself inside the book.
Silas saw it as Dovie turned the page. It was a thin sheet of lined notebook paper, creased in four, tucked into the fold of the gutter at page one hundred and ten. It had been there a long time. The paper had gone soft as cloth. On the outside, in the same tall hand, in ink this time, someone had printed:
SI. IF YOU ARE READING THIS, READ IT ALOUD TO NOBODY.

