"I have been wanting to say this to you," said Ottilie Harl Voss, "for thirty-five years, young man, and I have only got till supper."
It was Sunday afternoon. She sat on the tailgate of Cade's hatchback in the church lot, in her tan raincoat, with a plate of Faye Pettibone's biscuits on her knee and a cup of tea in her fist. She had not been parted from her trowel. She ate as Silas had seen very few people eat, with a quiet, ferocious, unembarrassed appetite, like a woman who had been told that food was a rumor.
The others stood round. Wyatt leaned on the bumper with his arms folded. Dovie sat on a camp stool with her cane across her knees, and Voss stood at his mother's shoulder as though he might otherwise be lost. Marian had her clipboard. Toby had his recorder. Nell sat on the gravel at Ottilie's feet, cross-legged, like a girl at a story hour.
"In the first place," said Ottilie, "the Pettibone business is sorted. I'm told Faye will keep the roll and Nell will count, and Walt Everett is to sit with them on Thursdays, and the whole village is to answer every dusk until the frost. That's a good plan. It wants a name." She sipped her tea. "I'd suggest the Notch Roll. It's what Mercy called it."
"I like it," said Nell.
"I knew you would. In the second place, Leland has given the Harl quarter acre to the congregation, which is the first sensible thing he has done since he was fourteen." Voss opened his mouth. "Don't, dear. In the third place." She set down the cup. "Wyatt Ketterman."
Wyatt straightened. "Ma'am?"
"You've been worrying about the tilt." She looked at him with her head cocked. "I heard it from below. You feel the stair lean toward you. It's nothing to be afraid of, and I'd like you to hear me say so. It's the Lip's manners. A nine-door man walking past a well, any well, will feel it. It's saying, 'You're welcome here.' It isn't saying, 'Come down now.'" She smiled, suddenly. "But you'll want to be at the Gap in October, in any event. That is your road. It isn't mine, and it isn't Hargis's."
"Thank you," said Wyatt. He sounded dazed.
"Don't thank me. Thank Walt. He sat." She turned. "Now. Mr. Ketterman. The little one. Silas."
"Yes, ma'am."
"You are carrying nine staves. I could feel them all the way down, like a hand on a banister. It's remarkable. You have no business being able to do that at nineteen." She tapped a biscuit on the plate. "I am going to tell you a thing, and I want you to hear it with your whole attention, because I did not manage to say it on the tape. Mercy told me not to. She said it would only frighten whoever came after."
Nobody moved. The wind in the lot was cold, with a smell of thawed ground.
"There are nine Lips on my son's map," said Ottilie. "That's what he gave you. A quarter acre each, on Harl land, from the survey of 1912. The Harls drew those nine circles because those nine were the ones the old Harls knew." She looked at Voss. "They were not the only ones, Leland. They were only the ones that happened to be on our land."
"Mother," said Voss, faintly.
"In October of 1987 I counted ten."
The silence was complete.
"It was Mercy who said it. In her kitchen. She was ninety, and she'd done her sums for eighty years. The Pettibones always held the ninth, and the Rankins held the first, and between them they knew the ring. But she said, 'There's a tenth.' She said it was not on any survey, because the family that kept it had never owned an acre. They were the sort who rent." She turned the cup in her hands. "She said it was in a town. She said it was a gap. She said it was nine miles from the first, east of the Rankin ridge, and there was a sourwood tree on the road into it, and a little restaurant on the corner with a red sign."
Silas felt the world go very quiet.
"Mercy never walked there. It was beyond her. She had it from her own mother, who had it from the Rankins." Ottilie looked at Dovie. "Dovie, my dear. Did your people never tell you?"
"No," said Dovie. Her voice was hoarse. "My mother never told me anything. She stopped setting a plate."
"I'd say your mother knew. I'd say she knew a good deal, and was ashamed." Ottilie put down her cup. "Mercy said the tenth was the oldest. She said the other nine were built after it, as people build a house round a well. She said it was the first one anyone opened. And she said, which is the part that kept me awake for four years, that it has never in the history of the county been counted."
"Not once?" said Marian.
"Not once. Nobody has ever kept its roll." She said it very gently. "It is the only Lip in the range that has no counter at all. It has been going down, quietly, for as long as there were people in that gap to go, and no one has ever written a single name."
Nobody spoke. Toby had taken off his headphones. In the lot behind them a screen door banged, and Faye Pettibone laughed, a long way off.
"Sourwood Gap," said Silas.
He heard his own voice from outside. It was flat and dry. It was the voice he used when he was frightened, the one he had worn for three years, and he heard Wyatt draw in a breath beside him.
"Is that your town?" said Ottilie.
"It's where we're from. It's nine miles from Dovie's spring." He could not stop. "There's a diner on the corner. It's got a red sign. It's the Gap Diner, ma'am, my mother's worked there since I was nine. I've sat in the back booth after school with my homework. I've eaten pie." He stopped. "There's a sourwood tree in front of it. It's the only tree on the block. My mother hangs stars in it. Paper ones. At Christmas. She leaves them up all year."
"Silas," said Wyatt, softly.
"Nine miles." He looked at his brother. His mouth would not seem to stay straight. "It was right there. All of it. For nineteen years. I walked eleven hundred miles to get away from a hole in the ground, and the whole time it was under the diner."
"We don't know that," said Marian. "It's a legend."
"It's on the map." Voss had stopped breathing. He was looking, with a strange gray face, toward his long dark car, where the vellum roll lay in its cardboard tube. "My mother's hand. 'This one is already open.' I took it for the ninth. I never thought to count the circles." His voice cracked. "Mother. How many did the roll have, in 1912?"
"Nine," said Ottilie. "That's why I wrote my note beside the ninth. It was the one in front of me, and it was open, and I had a pen." She spread her small brown hands on her knees. "I'm sorry, Leland. I've had thirty-five years to think of a better way to say it. There isn't one. I never marked the tenth. I had no way to mark a place that isn't on any sheet."
She looked at Silas, and her dark bright eyes were very kind.
"But I'll tell you what it means that a child in a notch could ring a telephone that had been dead since 1996, young man. It means somebody in a much older place has been ringing first."

