Voss opened the first letter on Thursday afternoon at the long table in the church kitchen, with Silas sitting at the other end of it and a pot of tea between them that neither of them had touched.
He had asked for company and then not known how to say what kind. He had come to the door of the store at noon in his clean shirt and said, "Mr. Ketterman, I'd be obliged if you would sit while I read a letter," and Silas had said yes at once, and Voss had looked so relieved and so appalled by his relief that Silas had pretended to tie a boot.
"I'll read it aloud," said Voss. "I find I cannot read a thing to myself. I always begin to skim."
"All right."
"If it becomes difficult, I should like you to say nothing at all. Simply be there."
"That's the whole job," said Silas.
Voss nodded. He drew the cream envelope from his breast pocket and slid the letter out. It was one sheet, folded in thirds, written on both sides in the plain blue hand. He smoothed it on the oak with the flat of his palm, as he had smoothed the survey roll, and cleared his throat.
"'Leland,'" he read. "'You are asking, which means I did something right. Sit down. I'm going to tell you where I am, and I'm not going to be tidy, because I never was.'"
His voice was quite steady. It was the voice of a man reading a quarterly statement.
"'I am in a well at Hargis Notch, thirty-one steps down, on the first stand. I got here on the twenty-second of October, 1991. I was not sick. I told Faye Pettibone I was, and I told Doc Pruitt, and I told you. I am sorry for that. It was the only lie I could think of that would stop you coming.'" He stopped. "She says, 'I had it put about that I was in the city hospital with a blood clot. It was a kind lie, which is the worst kind. I should have known you would hate it more than the truth.'"
He turned the page.
"'Here is what happened. On the evening of the twenty-first I telephoned your office from the store. You were in a meeting. Your secretary, a nice girl with a lisp, asked if it was urgent, and I said no, and she said she'd have you ring back. I said there was no need.'" His voice faltered, very slightly. "'I rang again at nine that night, at the house. You were out. The machine answered. I had never spoken to a machine before. I stood at the store telephone with the receiver in my fist, and your own voice said, *This is Leland Voss, leave a message,* and I thought, he sounds so tired.'"
Silas did not move. He sat with his hands round the cup.
"'I said, *Leland, it's your mother. It's nothing. I only wanted to hear your voice.* And I hung up. And the next morning I walked into the well.'"
For a while Voss said nothing. He laid the letter down on the table. He took off his glasses, folded them, and put them in his pocket. He put both hands flat on the oak, one on either side of the page.
"I remember the message," he said.
"Sir?"
"I remember it. I didn't know I did, until I read it just now. It's been thirty-five years. I came home at eleven. I was drunk, rather, on some deal I'd closed. I saw the red light flashing and I thought, it's the office. I thought I'd listen in the morning." He spoke very slowly. "I listened in the morning. I heard it. 'Leland, it's your mother.' And I thought, how pleasant, she's rung to say hello. And I deleted it, because I had a nine o'clock."
The kitchen was very quiet. A tap dripped. Out in the churchyard a bird, the first Silas had heard in the whole valley, tried out three notes and stopped.
"I meant to ring her back," said Voss. "I meant to on Sunday. And on Sunday I was told she had died."
"Mr. Voss."
"It is not a very large thing, you see." His face had the stiff, patient look of a man standing in an examination room. "A man deleted a message. It is a thing that happens daily to millions of people. I have not thought of it since. I have, I believe, built a very large part of my life on not having thought of it." He looked at Silas. "I should like to know what it is. What it is that one does with that."
Silas thought of the Sunday voicemails. June's flat tired voice. *Silas Lee, it's your mama.* He thought of the phone in his pocket, and of his thumb, which had spent three years learning to slide a little green bar across a screen.
"I let my mother's calls go to voicemail for three years," he said. "I'd listen to them and not call back. I thought, it's only a hello. I thought, it'll keep." He turned the cup. "And it did keep. It kept the whole three years. She was there when I came home. I got lucky."
"You got lucky."
"Yes. It's not a thing I earned." He looked up. "But here's what I think. I think you didn't delete a message. I think you heard your mother say she only wanted to hear your voice, and it scared you worse than anything in your life, and you pushed a button so you wouldn't have to know what it meant."
Voss said nothing.
"That's the true thing," said Silas. "It's not the deleting. It's that you knew."
For a long moment the man did not move. Then, quite slowly, he put his face down on his folded arms on the table, as he had sat on the pile of earth, and he said something into the oak that Silas did not catch. He said it again, louder.
"I knew," said Leland Voss. "I knew she was saying goodbye."
"Yes."
"I think I've known for thirty-five years."
"I think that's right."
"I think," said Voss, raising his head, "that it's a good deal worse to know than not. And I think I should not exchange it." He wiped his face with the back of his hand, a boy's gesture, and drew a very long breath, like a man coming up out of cold water. "Thank you, Mr. Ketterman. It is unspeakably kind of you not to have said anything clever."
"I'm not clever."
"No. That is why it was so useful."
Silas laughed. It startled them both. And outside, in the churchyard, the bird tried its three notes again, and got the fourth.
That night he slept badly. They all did, in the rooms above the store, on the cots and the floor, with the stove ticking and a thin spring wind sneaking round the sashes. Cade had taken the first watch. Silas had agreed to the second. He had gone to sleep in his clothes with his boots by the cot, and he woke in the black before dawn with his heart going like a drum, and did not know why.
The cot beside his was empty. The blanket lay folded at its foot.
"Wyatt?" he said.
Nothing. The window was a gray square. He sat up. Down in the road, beyond the glass, a long way off, a lantern was moving, not fast, a small steady yellow light, and in front of it, in a gray sweatshirt and with his arms hanging, walked his brother.
He was walking toward the church. He was barefoot. And in the stillness, through the glass, Silas heard him humming, five notes climbing, a flat third, and a drop.
The G did not crack.

