On Monday morning Silas went down the stair in daylight, which was a thing he had been told twice not to do.
He had permission, strictly speaking. It was a lawyer's kind of permission, the kind that holds up only if nobody looks hard. Dovie had said Don't descend, and Wyatt had said Don't descend, and Opie had said, in her mild voice, over the kitchen coffee, that the ten steps to the landing weren't descending, they were simply the booth's own cellar stair, and anyone with a flashlight and a measuring tape might reasonably go and look at it.
"I will hold the light," she said. "You will hold the tape. We will not sing and we will not count. We will measure a stair."
"Is that allowed?" said Silas.
"I do not recall that it is forbidden."
So they went at nine in the morning, the two of them, with the long flashlight from the shelf and a steel tape from Lon's toolbox. Wyatt was at the lip with Marian, working on door seven, a map and a phone and a list of names. Dovie had not come out of her house. Toby had gone to Marshall for the third time in three days, searching for a cable he swore he could not live without, and Hollis had driven to a hardware store for something he declined to specify.
The booth was bright and plain with the sun in the long window. Opie lifted the trapdoor at the back, behind the counter, the one Silas had stood on a hundred times without once thinking about, and set it back against the wall.
Cold came up. Not a frost cold. A still cold, like the air in a root cellar, with the smell of stone and old water in it. The stair went down in the beam of the flashlight, plain wooden treads between two walls of fieldstone, narrow enough that his shoulders brushed on both sides.
"Ten," said Silas. He heard himself say it, and stopped. "I mean. I'm not counting."
"No. You are noting a fact." Opie came down behind him, one hand on the rail, the light in the other. She had put on her good coat, as if for church. "A man can know a number without owing it to anybody. Go on, child."
The treads were worn in the middle, hollowed out by a hundred years of feet. At the fourth, Silas laid down the tape and read it off. Seven and a quarter inches of rise. At the seventh he checked again. Seven and a quarter. At the tenth, where the stair stopped at a flat stone landing no bigger than a kitchen table, the rise was the same.
"Landing," he said. "Ten feet by ten. They said it was ten by ten. This isn't ten by ten."
"No," said Opie. "That's the parcel. This is only the end of it, where the stair comes out. The rest runs back under the hill." She passed the light over the walls. They were stone, damp, and unmarked. "The deed said ten feet square. Thaddeus gave away more than this, you see. He gave away the dark."
He stepped down onto the landing. It was cold under his boots and it was not warm, and that was almost a relief. The warmth was a thing that came in the evening, when the count came. In the morning the landing was only stone, and the flashlight on it showed bare slate, a line of old mortar, and a place at the back wall where something large had once stood and left a rectangle of cleaner stone.
"The stool," said Opie. "Dovie's kindling stool, that stood here from 1970 until Wednesday last. We took it up to the booth. Well, it left a mark."
"Where does the rest go?"
"Down. Under." She did not say more.
Silas held up the tape. "Opie, I want to measure the stair again. Top to bottom. Not the treads. The whole height."
"Why?"
"Because I'm in a hurry to be sure of something."
She did not argue. He ran the tape from the landing stone up the rise of the wall to the lip of the trapdoor, and it read a little over six feet seven. He wrote it on the back of his hand with a pencil. Then, since it nagged him, he took the tape back down and measured it the long way, from the top tread to the bottom, counting the rise of each step.
He did it twice. He was meticulous. He was a man who had spent three years walking away from every number that frightened him, and he found, to his surprise, that he did not mind being frightened by this one.
"Six feet seven inches," he said. "Ten risers at seven and a quarter. That makes six feet and half an inch. Opie, that's seven inches short."
"Short of what?"
"Of the height of the hole." He swept the flashlight up. "A ten-step stair for a six-foot-seven drop would have eleven risers. Or the risers would be bigger. They're not. They're all the same. It's built for ten steps and it is eleven steps deep."
"Then where is the other?"
"Under me."
They looked at each other in the beam of the flashlight. The landing was a flat slab of slate, about four feet by five, set in mortar. It looked solid. It looked as though it had been there forever.
Silas crouched down. He ran his hand along the edge where the slate met the lowest tread, and found what he had half expected to find, a gap, hair-thin, running straight along the front of the slab. He took his pocketknife and slid the blade in. It went in a quarter of an inch.
"It's not a landing," he said slowly. "It's a step. It's the eleventh. Somebody laid a slab across it, flat, so it would look like the floor."
"Who would do that?"
"Someone who wanted a landing." He sat back on his heels. "Thaddeus. He gave a deed of a landing, ten feet by ten. If the eleventh step is the real bottom, then the landing isn't a landing at all. It's the place a man stood so he wouldn't have to look at what's below."
Opie said nothing. She held the light steady. The beam shook very slightly, and the slab sat in it, plain and gray, a slab with nothing on its face.
"Hold the light lower," said Silas. "Right along the front. There."
At the edge of the slab, on the vertical face of what he now thought was a riser, someone had scratched letters into the stone. They were old, and shallow, and had been partly rubbed away by a hundred years of boot toes. It took him a moment to read them in the slant of the flashlight.
ELEVEN.
It had been cut with a knife. A single deep line had been drawn through it afterward, from left to right, as a man crosses out a mistake.
"Struck through," said Opie, in a small, flat voice.
"By whom? By the one who wrote it, or by somebody who didn't want it there?" Silas laid his finger beside the word, careful not to touch it. "Look at the cuts. The word is deep and square. The line through it is shallower. It's a different hand."
"Silas."
"Someone wrote eleven. Someone else struck it out. Maybe Thaddeus. Maybe the thing itself." He felt, suddenly, very tired, and very much awake. "Opie, somebody has been telling this stair it doesn't have an eleventh step for ninety-five years. And it has been very politely insisting."
The flashlight beam moved. Silas looked up and saw that Opie had turned it, without being asked, back toward the trapdoor and the faraway square of morning.
"Come up now," she said. "That's enough for one day. I would like to go and sit down."
"We haven't—"
"We have measured a stair. I said we'd measure a stair. And I'd like to go up, because I believe, my dear, that I have just been listened to."
He had not heard anything. He listened. The cold stone kept its silence. But on the way up, on the sixth step, he thought he felt the board tick under his heel, one small dry tick, like a knife leaving wood. And then, on the seventh, as if it had been waiting for him to notice, another.

