On Wednesday I sent Dalton a note that said, Give me until Saturday. He sent one back within the hour: Noon. The chapel. We’ll bring coffee. I did not know where he thought he was going to find coffee, and the thought made me unreasonably nervous.
On Thursday we went to hate the Master Tally.
He lived at the end of the Millrace in a vault of ledgers, shelves going up into the dark with a rolling ladder on every aisle. The Tally himself stood at the far wall, a brass clerk twice my height, with an abacus for a chest and a hundred little arms ending in quills. Every one of them was writing in a ledger the size of a barn door. Every one of them stopped when we came in.
[Master Tally: For sixty seconds, all damage in the room is written on the books. Then the books are balanced. One name pays the sum.]
“Seven thousand three hundred,” Jun-ho read off the wall, where it was chalked in small neat numbers, as if for a bake sale. “That’s the sum on a clean run. About a third of the Verse.”
“A third’s enough to know,” said Imogen.
Sloane and Lark were up on the gallery rail above us, watching. Sloane had slept, and it showed. The color was back in her mouth, her fingers were tapping the rail again, and I’d have said I wasn’t glad about that if somebody had asked.
“Four colors,” she called down. “I’ll sing out. Pick your places.”
I told them the weights again, out loud, in the middle of the floor. Imogen forty. Me twenty. Jun-ho twenty. Pickle twenty. Nobody objected. Pickle cracked her knuckles and said, “I’m basically a tank,” and Imogen said, “You are very much not,” and we all took our spots, and the Tally lifted a hundred quills.
The first ten seconds went the way ten seconds go in a well-run fight. The books started writing. Hands of brass swung down at Imogen’s shield; Jun-ho’s arrows went out in green lines and soothed the clerks’ gears one at a time; Pickle slid between pillars, lifting things she shouldn’t. I held the rope. I felt the sum rise on the wall. Two thousand. Four.
“The line’s thick on you, Theo,” Sloane called. “Thicker than the weights.”
I looked at the Keeper panel, four pale sliders, as slim as piano keys.
Here is what I’d like to say. I’d like to say I had a speech in me, a debate, a moment where I weighed my promise against the fear and chose wrong. I didn’t. What I had was a thumb.
Pickle’s rope had spiked. Just for a second, through the rope, I felt her terror go up like a struck match, the same bird-in-a-closed-hand feeling from the Sorting Floor, only larger. She was twenty. She was standing in front of seven thousand points of damage with a twenty percent share, and her health was a third of Imogen’s. In the space of a breath, I pictured her at the Gallows, with a share more than three times this one, doing what I’d told her she could do.
My thumb moved. Imogen down to twenty. Jun-ho down to ten. Pickle down to ten. Mine up.
I told myself it was a rehearsal. I told myself it was just for this fight. I told myself I’d say something afterwards, once it was done, once it was safe, and I’m still not sure that wasn’t a lie in the exact moment I told it.
[Weights: Marsh 60%. Duarte 20%. Seo 10%. Vega 10%.]
The sixty seconds ended. The clerk rang a gong that I felt in my back teeth, and every quill came down at once.
[Master Tally: balanced. Sum: 7,312. Payer: the Keeper’s rope.]
It hit me like being run over by a church. I didn’t fall. I’m told I didn’t even stagger. Four thousand three hundred and eighty-seven points of damage went through my chest, and my health bar dropped from full to a thin sliver, and the Weariness bar beneath it shot up through the numbers like a thermometer in a kettle. Eighty. Ninety. Ninety-eight.
I healed myself, which is not a thing I’m good at, and got my bar back above half. I watched the Tally go still, one quill at a time, the books closing with a sound like a library at night.
Then the floor came up and put its arm around me.
[Weariness: 100. Spent.]
I woke in the Chapel of Small Hours, on a pew, under a coat that smelled like beans. It was dark, and somebody had lit candles, a lot of them, in the stone bowls along the wall. My mouth tasted like pennies. My Weariness read thirty-one. Six hours.
They were all there. Imogen at the end of the pew with the slate on her knee. Jun-ho on the floor with his back to the wall. Pickle on the altar step, hugging her knees, hood up.
“You’re awake,” Imogen said. She wasn’t smiling. “We carried you. The books balanced, by the way. It worked. The split works. Sloane says to tell you the ledger went across all four ropes like it was designed to.”
“Great,” I said. “That’s great.”
“Theo.” She turned the slate face-down on the pew, which is the thing she does when she’s about to say a hard thing. “What’s my weight?”
I’m very good at medicine. I’m not good at this.
“Forty,” I said.
“I just looked. My panel says twenty.”
The candles guttered. Pickle’s hood moved. “Mine says ten,” she said, so quietly I could barely hear it. “I thought it was a bug.”
“It’s not a bug,” Jun-ho said, to his boots. “I checked mine too. Ten.”
“It was a rehearsal,” I said. “I was fine. I knew what I could carry. It was just for the first ten seconds, and then there wasn’t a place where I could say—”
“You said you wouldn’t,” said Pickle. She’d pushed her hood back. Her eyes were red and she was furious, which on her looked a lot like a sunburn. “On the steps. You said, I will never set anyone’s weights in secret. Imogen told me what you said. I thought, finally. Finally somebody’s going to let me carry something.”
“I didn’t want you hurt.”
“That’s what Sloane did to you.” She almost laughed. “You did the Sloane thing. You looked at me, and you decided what I could take, and you didn’t even tell me.”
“You wrote us out of our own risk,” said Imogen. She was very calm, and it was the worst thing in the room. “I’m not mad that you took it. I did that for eleven years. I took it so nobody had to ask. I know exactly what it is, Theo. It’s not love. It’s a way of making sure nobody can ever do the same for you.”
“I would have paid,” Jun-ho said. “Forty yards. No wind. I’d have paid.”
“I’m sorry.”
“I know you are.” Imogen stood. She picked up her shield, and counted something under her breath, and didn’t finish. “I think I need to go and be somewhere with fewer people in it.”
She went out the pantry door into the dark. Jun-ho followed her, without a joke, which I’d never seen him do. Pickle was the last one. She stood on the step with her hood in her fist, as if she wanted me to stop her.
“I really wanted to be on a team that trusted me with something,” she said. Then she was gone.
The candles burned down a little. It was very quiet.
I opened the Bind panel, because that’s what you do when you want to see the damage. Three lines in a column. Imogen: consent withdrawn. Jun-ho: consent withdrawn. Pickle: consent withdrawn. Each one gone gray as ash.
Only one line still glowed, warm, steady, humming in my ribs like a pilot light. The only rope still holding was the one I hadn’t earned.

