Thursday night, Thanksgiving, the county paid a hundred and thirty-three hands.
Felix wrote it on the window at six on Friday morning in a very small hand, as though it might spoil. Beneath it he wrote, without comment, 8,154 Owing, and under that a third number I did not ask him to explain. 24.
“That is the nights,” he said. “Not the hands. I thought it would be cleaner.”
“It isn’t.”
“No,” he agreed. “Quick question. Do we eat or do we panic?”
“We eat.”
So we ate. It had become the order of things: Mrs. Pilcher’s zucchini bread at the Dutch door, the percolator, the three of us standing up at the sill like cattle at a trough. At seven I read Dale Rhoades the line from Volume One that Mrs. Pilcher had found for me in the night. It was a single sentence in Gosnell’s cramped copperplate, and it said that the retained stand until the book balances. The book would not balance until the principal was paid. Retention, in other words, was not a way out of the debt. It was a way of becoming part of it.
Dale folded his seed cap into his pocket. “Then I’ll pay,” he said, and went to find a shovel.
At nine, Constance Haig came to the scale house with a thermos of her own.
I want to be fair to her, because I was not at the time. She sat across the desk from me in the camel coat, with her case on her knees and her glasses pushed up into her hair, and she did not look around the room for ghosts. She looked at the Dutch door, the percolator, the framed Orders and the feed-store calendar nobody had taken down. Then she looked at me with the exact, unhurried attention I have used on other people for fourteen years, and I understood that I was being examined.
“I declined the coffee,” she said, “because I assumed you would. I find the policy sound.”
“It’s a good policy.”
“I have the church newsletter.” She laid it on the blotter. It was a single folded sheet, mimeograph purple, with a hand-drawn turkey on the front. Inside it said, under Community Notes, that the Auditor of Alder County had joined the congregation for Thanksgiving dinner and had been very gracious about the green bean casserole. “You accepted it. A plate of food worth, I should think, four dollars, from a person on the Association’s roll.”
“The church committee isn’t an auditee.”
“The roll is the county, Ms. Pell. The county is the debtor. You are the county’s auditor.” She said it without relish. “I would be very happy to be wrong.”
I will say this for my profession: it does not need ghosts to hang a person. Independence is a three-legged stool. You must be independent in fact, which means you do not take the client’s money. You must be independent in appearance, which means no reasonable person looking in thinks you do. And you must be independent in structure, which means you are not a party to the thing you are examining, and cannot be made one. I had taught this to Felix at a whiteboard.
I had broken the third leg myself, in a field, with the word Seven.
“Ms. Haig,” I said. “Under Article Nine, I am not an interested party to this debt. I am the Surety. I am the person who pays if the debtor doesn’t.”
“That is rather worse.”
“It’s rather worse,” I agreed.
“I have read the Compact.” She took a photocopy from the case. It was the exhibit from Common Pleas, and Article Nine had a yellow flag on it, and a pencil line down the margin. “I read it three times, and then I read it aloud to my husband, who is a patent attorney and whom nothing has astonished since 1998. I do not know what it is. I do not know whether a person can be bound in the way it says. I don’t, and I am under no obligation to.” She put one finger on the sentence. “The Auditor, having set his mark, stands Surety for the County. That is a guarantee. A guarantor is an interested party. The standard says what it says.”
“Warren Ostrander has watched the book write a birth.”
“Warren has been under strain.”
From the doorway, Ostrander said quietly, “Constance.”
“Warren.” She did not turn round. “I like you very much. I liked you a great deal better before you began speaking to corn.”
He didn’t answer. He took off his glasses and put them on again.
I said, “What do you want?”
I think she had been waiting for that. Haig is a woman who likes a clean sentence.
“I want you to step back from the Office until an independent examiner can review your work,” she said. “Voluntarily, if you will. Under the statute, if you won’t. In either case the deputy auditor acts as Acting Auditor in the interim, so the county does not go without its books. I am not removing you. I am recusing you. It is entirely procedural.”
“And the Reserve?”
“Is a parcel of land in the custody of a court,” she said. “It will remain so. I’m not here to hurt anyone.”
I should have said yes. I want that understood. It is the sort of offer I would have taken from an examiner ten years ago at the first knock, with a handshake. I did not say yes because of something I could not explain, a thing with Article Nine in it, and the sentence I had read in an old man’s green ink. And for those who hold the Office after him.
“No,” I said.
“You are refusing?”
“I am declining to recuse. I’m not declining to be examined. Examine me. I’ll give you every workpaper I own.”
“That is a very good answer,” said Haig. She said it with real regret. “It isn’t the right one.” She closed the case. “I have filed the petition. Judge Kimmel has the Monday docket. Eight a.m., Common Pleas. I am sorry that I have disturbed your holiday.” She stood and held out her hand, and I took it in my left. It was warm, and square, and dry. “For what it is worth,” she said, “I have a policy about coffee, too. Mine is that I decline it, and my husband drinks it for me.”
I laughed. It surprised us both.
She went out past Ostrander in the doorway and stopped. “You should eat, Warren,” she said, not unkindly, and walked down the lane to her car, a woman in a good coat who had done what she had come for and was sorry about it.
Ostrander sat on the bench. For a while neither of us spoke.
“She’s right,” he said. “Under the standards. It’s a clean motion. Kimmel will have to grant it.”
“I know.”
“I could appear for the Receiver. I could say—”
“Say what? That the debtor’s guarantor is an ordinary party and the office has a century of undefended obligation attached to it, which the State of Ohio should please not look into?”
“Well,” said Ostrander. “Put that way.”
It was Felix who came in at four. He stood in the door of the scale house with his county van keys in one hand and in the other a photocopy of the back leaf of the Compact, folded small. He had not slept. He had a way of not sleeping that left him looking nineteen.
He was holding Article Nine as one holds a thing one has been carrying for some time.
“I read it again last night,” he said.
“Felix—”
“You said it in the church basement. For the Auditor, and for those who hold the Office after her. I wrote it on the back of my hand during the meeting, because I thought I should.” He turned his left hand over, and the faded blue ink was still there, in his tidy handwriting. “Quick question. Mrs. Haig said Acting Auditor. In the interim.” He swallowed. “That’s the deputy. Isn’t it? That’s me.”

