Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 14

Common Pleas

The courtroom on the third floor of the Alder County Courthouse smelled of wet coats and radiator paint. It held a flag, a seal, two tables, and about two hundred people who had never before been interested in a motion.

Judge Dolores Kimmel sat under the seal with her reading glasses pushed up into gray hair. She had a face like a good fence: not unfriendly, and not going to move. She had been on the bench twenty-two years.

“The State’s motion,” she said. “Ms. Prentiss.”

The assistant attorney general, a small woman in a very good suit, rose with a folder. “Your Honor, the State seeks a temporary restraining order for two purposes. First, to secure the records of the Alder Mutual Harvest Association, and an unaccessioned volume now held in this building, pending examination. Second, to close to public access, from sunset to sunrise, a parcel in Weller Township known locally as the Reserve, as an unregistered burial ground and an unsafe agricultural site.”

“Unregistered burial ground,” said the judge. “That’s a phrase.”

“We’re not certain what else to call it, Your Honor.”

Dale Whitcomb, the county prosecutor, appeared for my office. He had the look of a man who had read the motion twice and been unable to remember a single reason to oppose it. He told the court the county had no position.

Ostrander testified first. He sat in the box with his glasses on the cord and set out, in order, what he had seen. Sixty-one individuals interviewed, giving dates of birth between 1889 and 1984, none of whom could produce a document dated after the day they said they went away. A county whose population had not changed in a century. He did not say “impossible.” He said “inconsistent with the public record,” and the judge wrote the phrase down.

“Mr. Ostrander, do you have an opinion as to the cause?”

“I have a form.” There was a ripple of laughter, and he waited it out. “I’m an examiner, Your Honor. When I can’t explain a figure I ask who is in a position to. The person in the best position is the Auditor, and she has given me an answer I can’t define.”

“Auditor Pell,” said the judge. “You may take the stand, since you’ve been so patient.”

I took the stand with my right hand in Hobb’s glove and my left on the Bible, which seemed unfair to both.

“What is the harm, Auditor?” She leaned on her elbow. “I’ll accept your own unit.”

“Persons, Your Honor. Twelve thousand four hundred and six.”

I heard the room change. It was not a gasp. It was the sound of two hundred people doing a small piece of arithmetic they already knew the answer to.

“That’s the county,” said Judge Kimmel.

“That’s the county.”

“What happens on the twenty-first of December?”

“A sum falls due.” I kept my voice in the weather-report register I had picked up from Mrs. Pilcher. “I can produce the document. I can’t say yet to whom, or what happens if it isn’t paid. I’d be guessing, and I don’t guess in a courtroom.”

“You understand how this sounds.”

“Yes, Your Honor. It sounds like a figure that doesn’t foot. That’s what I’m here to say it is.”

She looked at me for a while. Then she asked whether I wanted to add anything, and I said that I wanted to enter the Compact as an exhibit, and Whitcomb, who had said nothing in an hour, said “Objection” very quietly and sat down again.

It was then that a small old woman rose from the third row of the gallery. She wore a gray coat and a hat with a pin in it, and she had no gloves.

“Your Honor,” said Mrs. Pilcher. “I wonder if I might say something. I am the clerk of that Association. I am also, in a sense, the subject of an order of this court.”

“Ma’am, this isn’t the time—”

“I was declared dead in 1991, Your Honor. Case 91-PR-0114. The petition was granted in nine minutes. I find that it has been a considerable inconvenience.”

The bailiff, who was twenty-four, turned the color of a candle. Judge Kimmel took her glasses off her head and set them on her nose and read the file Whitcomb handed up, front and back, with the concentration of a person who has found a hole in her own roof.

“Who petitioned for this?”

There was a long silence. Then Abel Truitt stood up at the back of the courtroom in a clean canvas jacket and without his gloves.

“I signed it, Judge.”

“Mr. Truitt, you understand you’re admitting to—”

“Yes, ma’am. I understood it then. I signed it with Walter Hess and Dale’s father, God rest him. We told the court she’d walked into a field.” His big hands hung at his sides, wrong for the shape of the room. “She walked out of the courthouse and kept an office for thirty-five years. We never asked how she did it. We paid her in bread.”

Nobody in the room moved. The bailiff remembered to breathe.

“I am not going to open a perjury matter on a thirty-five-year-old petition,” said Judge Kimmel at last, “when the petitioner is standing in front of me trying to un-sign it.” She looked at the old woman in the pinned hat. “Mrs. Pilcher. Do you wish to be alive?”

“I should like very much to be alive, Your Honor. I should like to have the table back.”

“The order of March 1991 is set aside. For all purposes under the laws of the State of Ohio, Edna R. Pilcher is living.” “Someone give that woman a chair.”

“Your Honor,” I said, from the stand, because I could not help it, “as Auditor, I’m obliged to note that Mrs. Pilcher has been off the tax duplicate since 1991. The bungalow behind the elevator has been assessed for thirty-five years to an owner who did not exist. With penalty and interest I’d estimate two thousand one hundred and four dollars.”

I had meant it in complete seriousness. The room laughed, and kept laughing, and Mrs. Pilcher, seated at last with the pin of her hat gone crooked, said in her clear dry voice, “I will pay it gladly, Auditor. It is the first bill I have been sent in thirty-five years.”

Judge Kimmel did not laugh, but her mouth took a position on it.

Then she ruled. The State’s motion was granted in part. The records would stay in the county for thirty days, under the joint custody of the Auditor and the Examiner. As for the Reserve, she said she did not know what lay out there, but she knew it was not a cemetery and it was not on any plat she had ever signed for safety, and she would not have two hundred people in an unlit field at night while the State and the Auditor argued about units.

“The parcel is closed, from sunset to sunrise, to all persons,” she said, “except the owner of record, and persons acting under the statutory authority of the Auditor. Effective tonight. Deputy Rinehart will post it.”

I stood up. “Your Honor, with respect, the work—”

“Auditor.” She looked at me over the glasses. “I have granted you thirty days and an exception with your name on it. If I were you I would not ask for the whole county.”

At 5:15 the horn rolled out across Long Bottom. Deputy Tate Rinehart, a big young man with a sunburned neck, unrolled a length of yellow tape across the plank bridge and tied it at both ends, apologizing to the planks.

The lane behind him was full. The Returned had walked out from the church hall in a column, Hester Lind in front, and stood in the road under the sodium light in rows. Most of them held a sheet of printer paper. It was their own name, the line where it stood on the roll.

“Auditor,” said Hester Lind. “We are on the list. We weren’t asked, last time. We would like to be asked.”

“Tomorrow,” I said.

“That’s what they said in 1917.”

I had no answer. Across the creek the corn rattled, patiently, in a wind that reached none of us. By the time the horn gave out, the lane had emptied, a few at a time, with their papers folded against their coats. It was the first night since Friday that nobody paid.

The sum was exactly what it had been that morning. I stood alone at the tape and understood that the judge had not limited the debt. She had limited who could pay it, and left a gap for me. The order had one exception, and it was me. A court does not carve out a single person for no reason. A compact, I was beginning to suspect, did not either.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!