We went down at midnight, three of us, with the fifth key in Matthias’s fist.
The Sheriff had given it back to him that evening, wrapped in a handkerchief, with the air of a man handing over a fish he had been told was poisonous. He had brought it himself on the last train, with his hat pulled down, and he stood in the cellar passage with a shuttered lantern and said that he would look at nothing, and hear nothing, and remember only that he had been asked to attend as a witness. It is a great advantage in a deacon.
I had told them both what I thought, in the dining room, with the Kinderhook drawing flat between the candles. Matthias had listened with his jaw like a hinge. At the end he stood up, took the lantern, and said, “That will do,” which is how he ends all discussion, and which in that house means that the discussion has been won by the thing it was about.


