There were more than a hundred and four on Friday. There were a hundred and ninety, by Rosalind’s count, and she counted twice, because the second time two men were standing on the stove.
It was the same Grange hall, with the same smell of damp coats and cold tea, and Squire Hobart Pell sat at the same trestle with his white beard and his ear trumpet and the expression of a man called from his turnips for a trifle. This time the benches were full to the walls. The whole of Tarrow Landing had come to see whether the third Mrs. Caldwell would be hanged, and it sat with its hat in its lap and its mouth a little open, and I think it was disappointed in advance.
Lavinia sat at the front, in her grey dress with the pins, between Matthias and Agnes. Rosalind was at her other hand with the ledger on her knee. Fitch was on the floor under the bench, sorting buttons. Dr. Hollis sat at the end of the row, taking snuff and looking at the ceiling. In the corner beside the stove, on a chair that had been carried in by four men, sat Mr. Crane, shrunken inside his coat, grey as putty, with a rug over his knees and a bottle of milk beside him, and when the benches saw him a murmur went round them like wind through a field.
Mr. Pruett rose when the Squire nodded. He was in perfect order, the white cravat, the narrow black coat, the voice like a ledger shutting. If he had not slept, nothing showed it. He read his petition in a level hum, with the air of a man reading a will aloud to cousins, and he put it plainly: a woman who had lain hidden ten months, a forger by her own admission, a husband poisoned within a month of her return from the dead, and a wrapper in her hand.
“A wrapper in Miss Whitlock’s hand,” said the Squire, from behind his trumpet.
“I beg the Court’s pardon. In a hand copied by Miss Whitlock, from a hand copied by the lady.” He had it. He turned it neatly. “It is a fact on which I do not wish to lean too heavily.”
“Then do not,” said Squire Pell.
“I shall call my first witness.”
It was not a witness he had expected to call. It was, on the contrary, a man in an overcoat, standing in the doorway beside Sheriff Colby, with his portfolio held before him like a hymn-book, who said in a clear unsteady voice, “Squire, I am Mr. Pruett’s clerk, and I wish to be sworn.”
I have not often seen a man’s face change. Mr. Pruett’s changed as a pond does when the wind drops. It did not fall. It merely stopped being a face and became a surface.
Mr. Wren was sworn. He said what he had said to me in the train, slowly, with his eyes shut for the worst of it, and he held out the portfolio at the end like a boy handing up his lesson. In it were the practice sheets, hundreds of them, in his own upright hand and in the hands of other people, going back four years. A hundred M. Caldwells, every one a little smoother than the last. A dozen of Dr. Rainsford’s lines. A page of the swan-necked slope. There was a silence while the Squire looked at them through his spectacles, and one of the men on the stove said, quite distinctly, “Well, I’ll be hanged.”
“He is a thief and a runaway,” said Mr. Pruett, who had not sat down. His voice was perfectly steady. “He has a motive to save his neck.”
“Then the Terminal Company will call itself a thief and a runaway too, Squire,” said a voice from the door. Mr. Ansel Marrable, whiskered and stooped and out of breath, had come in from the early train with a leather case under his arm, and he walked down the hall between the benches and put it on the trestle without ceremony. “Ansel Marrable, Hudson Valley Terminal Company. I have here the originals of the file. A deposit of five thousand dollars in the Vance Trust, of which Mr. Pruett is sole trustee. Eleven letters in his hand, with enclosures in another. And a letter of the seventeenth, which I shall read to the Court if it is not objected to.”
He read it. “The matter of the lady will be disposed of by then.” He lowered it, and the murmur in the hall had gone dead.
“By whom was it written?” said the Squire.
“By the principal,” said Mr. Pruett. “Whom I have never seen.” He had gone very white at the lips. “I am a solicitor, Squire. I took the instructions of a client by post, on blue paper, in a lady’s hand, through a trust of which I was trustee. I do not know her. I swear it. I have asked myself who she is for two years.”
“Then you are a very credulous kind of lawyer,” said the Squire.
“There is a further matter,” I said, and rose. I had not planned to. “If the Court will allow. A question of dates.”
It was Rosalind who stood. I had my hand on the bench, and I saw her go up from beside her stepmother like a small stiff flag, with the ledger open in her two hands.
“Squire,” said Rosalind. “May I read?”
“I do not see why not,” said the Squire, who had been waiting twenty minutes for something he could follow.
“On Thursday the thirteenth of November, at ten minutes past eight in the morning, Mr. Pruett took Miss Whitlock’s draft out of her glove. I wrote it in my book at the time because it was a day of events.” She turned a page. “That evening Mr. Boyce told Teel that Mr. Pruett had been at the post office at six, and Teel told me. At three o’clock on Friday the tin came. Miss Whitlock was in the lockup from Thursday morning until Saturday at eleven. It is therefore a matter of record that she could not have written or posted a wrapper, and that the only persons who held her draft were Mr. Pruett and Mr. Wren, and Mr. Wren says it was Mr. Pruett who went to the post.”
She stopped and drew breath. “That is not an observation. It is a date.”
“Child,” said Mr. Pruett, “you are very young.”
“It is inaccurate,” said Rosalind, “to say so. I am nine and a quarter.”
I think it was the nine and a quarter that did it. A woman on the third bench began to laugh, with the helpless laughter of someone who has been afraid for a week, and in a moment the whole hall was in it, a great rolling shout of relief, and the Squire hit his trestle with his trumpet and could not be heard.
When it fell quiet at last, Mr. Crane spoke from his chair. He did not rise. He had not the strength. He said, in a voice that went to the very back of the hall, “Pruett, you sent me the loaves. For eleven years. And I carried them, God help me, because it was the only way I knew to be kind,” and he began to weep, with enormous gasps, into his rug.
Squire Pell dismissed the petition without leaving his seat. He said the Court did not hold on a wrapper, nor on a woman’s having been dead, and that he considered the lady entitled to a cup of tea. He declared the deed void for want of an owner’s hand. He ordered Mr. Wren to remain in the Sheriff’s keeping as a witness. And then he looked at Fitch, who had come out from under the bench with something in his fist, and held out a very large, very hairy hand.
“It is a button,” said Fitch. “You may have it if you are fair.”
“I intend to be,” said the Squire gravely, and put it in his waistcoat.
The Sheriff took Mr. Pruett out by the side door, quite quietly, with the Deputy at his elbow, for forgery and for conspiracy, and the matter of the cocoa to be gone into. He did not struggle. At the door he stopped and looked back over the heads of the crowd, not at Lavinia, nor at Matthias, but at me.
“Miss Whitlock,” said Mr. Pruett. He spoke so low that I was perhaps the only one who heard. “You have caught the pen. It is a good pen, and a poor one. Ask who owns the hand.” The ghost of his dry smile came and went. “And ask who in that house has the key to the east wing.”

