The fifth ring did not come. I have since learned to be more afraid of a bell that stops than of one that goes on.
Matthias moved before the echo had gone. He took the lantern in his numb left hand and the poker from the bench in his right, and said her name again, once, in a voice that was not meant for me.
“Go up,” said Lavinia. She had already put a foot behind the hinged rack. “Lock the oak door behind you and take her with you. Whoever it is will count the stairs.”
“Who is it?”
“I will tell you when I am sure.”
“Lavvy.”
“When I am sure, Matthias.” She drew the rack to. The last of her I saw was a grey sleeve and two fingers, and then the whitewashed wall was a wall again, with jars on it.
We went up through the passage with the lantern turned low. I counted fourteen paces to the oak door, and Matthias stopped with his hand on the padlock. He looked at the key as if it belonged to another man.
“You will say you came to give me back this,” he said, and took the cellar key from my fingers, “and your notice. I declined both.”
“That is a very poor lie.”
“It is the first I have told in a year. I am out of practice.”
He turned the lock behind us with his own key, and we went out into the kitchen passage.
Dr. Rainsford stood at the foot of the back stairs with a lamp on the flags beside him and his bag in his hand. His other hand was still on the bell rope. He wore his greatcoat buttoned to the chin and he looked, in the poor light, exactly as kind as he always looked, which I had begun to find the most alarming thing about him.
“Matthias, my dear fellow.” He let go of the rope. “I did beg your pardon. Four was always ‘come at once,’ you remember, when we were boys and old Keeper Dunning had the vault. I thought you would hear it.”
“I heard it.”
“Agnes sent for me at dusk. She was afraid for you.” He glanced at me and away, and patted his breast pocket. “Miss Whitlock. I did understand you were to take the morning train.”
Mrs. Dunning came along the passage then, in her wrapper, with her grey plait over one shoulder and her keys in both hands to keep them from ringing. She stopped when she saw the oak door. She looked at Matthias’s face, and at mine, and at the padlock, and I watched the whole sum of it go into her like coins into a box. Then she wiped her hands on her wrapper.
“Well now,” she said, and no more.
“Miss Whitlock came down to resign to my face,” said Matthias. “I find I would rather she did not. I was hasty on Sunday, Edmund. She is not leaving by the morning train.”
Dr. Rainsford took a moment. “After what you told me she had done?”
“After what I learned she had not.”
“Now, now.” The doctor smiled at me, and it was a very good smile. “I only wish you had told me, Matthias, that you were walking about the cellar at midnight. It is exactly the sort of habit we ought to speak about.” He took a small brown bottle from his bag and a measuring glass from the other pocket, and I knew the bottle before the label turned to the lamp. “Your draught. You have missed two nights, I think. Agnes, milk.”
Mrs. Dunning went and came back with a glass of milk, and she did not look at the bottle, and she did not look at me.
The doctor counted drops. I counted with him, because I cannot stop myself: ten, into the milk, which clouded and cleared. He held it out. Matthias took it, and his hand shook, and the milk shivered at the rim.
I had perhaps two seconds, and not an idea in my head. What I had was my hands, which have always been better liars than my mouth.
“You will spill it,” I said. “Let me.”
“Quite right,” said Dr. Rainsford, softly approving, in the voice of a man who likes to be proved correct. “The governess has nursing hands. Do see that he drinks it all.”
I took the glass from Matthias and put my free hand behind his head, like a mother with a feverish child, and tipped the rim to his lips. He did not swallow. He made the motion of it very beautifully. The milk ran down the inside of my wrist, into my cuff and the wool of my shawl, warm for a moment and then cold, and I tilted the glass higher and higher until the doctor could see the bottom of it, white and empty, in the lamp.
“Thank you, Miss Whitlock,” said Matthias, gravely, in a voice that had not shaken in three seconds. “That will do.”
Neither of us looked at the other. It was the nearest I have ever come to dancing.
Dr. Rainsford took the glass from my hand and shook the last drop out of it onto the flags, which no one else would have done. He rinsed it in the scullery pump. He was a man who tidied his own tracks, I noted, with the ease of long practice, and then I stopped noting it, because it was not evidence of anything, and I was cold, and my sleeve smelled of warm milk and something faintly like a pharmacy.
I wrote that down as a Wrong Thing, since the rule is three. The first: a doctor summoned at dusk who arrives at midnight. The second: four rings, which a man might remember from boyhood, or might remember because he had been told the bell still worked. The third was the cuff.
“I will say good night,” said the doctor. He put on his hat in the passage, and Mrs. Dunning held the kitchen door for him, and the cold came in off the river like a hand through the keyhole. “Oh, and Matthias. I ought to have said. Barnabas and I will come at nine, with Mr. Pruett. Your father’s solicitor, you remember, from Troy.”
“At nine on a Monday?”
“It concerns the children, I am afraid. It concerns your father’s will.” He touched the brim of his hat to me, as gently as a man touching a sleeping face. “There is a clause. You never did read the whole of it, my dear boy. I thought you should hear it from a friend.”
The door shut. Matthias stood in the passage with his hands hanging, and for the first time since I had met him he did not put them behind his back.
“Agnes,” he said, without turning. “You sent for him.”
“I did.”
“Why?”
She had her fists in her wrapper, and her face was the colour of old tallow. “Because you went down every night, Matthias, and you came up every morning looking more like your father at the end. I am sixty years old and I have buried one of you. I thought, he is a doctor, he knows. God forgive me. I thought he would know.”
Matthias said nothing for a long time. Then: “Go to bed. All of you.” He held out his hand to me, the right, the one that could not feel, and then he thought better of it and let it fall. “That will do.”
I went up the thirty-one stairs. The sixth tread complained, as it always did, and I walked on its outer edge from habit.
Rosalind was sitting up in the nursery in her nightgown, with a candle and her ledger. She looked at my wet sleeve and at my face, and she turned a page and made a mark, and said without looking up, “Four bells. I counted.”
“You are meant to be asleep.”
“I was keeping the tally.” She blew out the candle. In the dark, very small: “Is it still eleven?”
“I am told,” I said, “that it is not.”
The little door stood open the width of my hand. Beyond it the stair was empty. I did not sleep, and I counted the seven windows until each of them went grey, and I thought of one clause in a dead man’s will that I had never read, and of a doctor who tidied his own glass.

