Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 14

The Bill

By noon, Merrow was the happiest town I had ever seen.

Priya and I walked Main Street with a recorder and a lamp in a thermos, and every door we passed stood open. Through the windows I saw families around kitchen tables with too many chairs. A man in a 1940s work coat taught a boy to tie a tie. Two women sat on a porch swing, one in a nurse's cap from another century, both laughing so hard they had to hold on to each other.

At the bakery, the teenager who had pocketed my flyer was selling rolls to a drowned grandmother. They were arguing about the price of butter.

"This is the best thing I have ever recorded," Priya said, wiping her eyes with her wrist. "And I am scared out of my mind."

"Why?"

"Because nobody has asked what it costs." She nodded at the recorder. "Everybody who comes to a door has a rule. Every rule I've ever heard has a bill."

That was when Carol Haugen came out of the clinic and flagged us down.

She had her reading glasses pushed up into her hair and a clipboard clamped against her chest. Her face was the color of putty.

"Sadie," she said. "Priya. I need you to look at something. I don't have anyone else to show."

Merrow Family Clinic has four exam rooms and a waiting room with a fish tank. Today every chair was full. Not with the drowned. With the living. Eleven people, sitting very quietly in their coats, hands folded like they were waiting for a bus.

"Since dawn," Carol said in a low voice, taking us into the hallway. "They all came in the same way. Nothing wrong. Blood pressure fine. They just say they lost something."

She flipped the clipboard.

Walter Jaeckel, 61: cannot remember his daughter's first word. Miriam Rask, 34: cannot remember the name of the street she grew up on. A boy of nine named Eli Soderberg: cannot remember his own dog, and his dog, a very patient beagle, was sitting in the exam room beside him, thumping its tail.

"Eli's grandmother came up out of the lake last night," Carol said. "He asked her in. She stayed. This morning he woke up and he's missing his beagle." She laughed, high and shaky. "He knows he has a dog. He just doesn't know him."

Priya's pen was moving fast. "Every one of them has a guest?"

"Every one. And it's always one thing." Carol pressed her fingers against her eyes. "Always one thing. And always something that mattered. A good memory, a favorite one. Whatever they were holding hardest."

I thought of Theo in his kitchen, trying to hum.

"What do they say?" I asked.

"They say it's worth it." Carol's voice cracked. "Sadie, I held my husband's hand for the first time in nineteen years last night. I haven't invited him in yet. I'm scared that I will."

Arne Solberg was in the last exam room, perched on the paper-covered table in his good suit, rubbing his thumbs together. Behind him, on a plastic chair, sat a tiny white-haired woman in a flowered dress, patting his knee with enormous tenderness.

"Ingrid," Arne said, smiling at me with his whole face. "She stayed. Isn't that something?"

"It's wonderful, Arne," I said.

"I can't remember our wedding," he said, still smiling. "Not the church. Not the day. Fifty-one years I've carried that, and this morning it's like a bag with a hole in it. Ingrid told me about the weather. It rained, apparently. I don't remember anything but the rain." He patted the hand on his knee. "She says I wore a terrible tie."

"You wore a terrible tie," said Ingrid, in her faint, delighted Norwegian accent.

"I'd give it again," said Arne. "I'd give a hundred weddings."

I walked out into the parking lot and stood in the cold with my hands in my pockets.

On the far side of the lot, Sheriff Dale Nygaard was leaning against his cruiser with a small boy of about twelve in a striped sweater beside him, eating a candy bar from the vending machine as if he'd never tasted one. The sheriff's face looked like a man who had won a war, and lost his keys.

"Dale?"

"Hey, Sadie." He cleared his throat. "Thomas, say hello. This is the girl from the film."

"Hi," said the boy politely, and went back to his candy.

"I can't remember my wedding day," Dale said quietly, so the boy couldn't hear. "Marit's furious. Says I'm the only man in Minnesota who could lose a thing like that." He swallowed. "It's a fair trade. I think it's a fair trade."

I went and stood by the lake. The shore was white now to forty feet out.

When I came back, Priya had made a card.

She'd written it on an index card from my mother's kitchen drawer in tidy block capitals, and she handed it to me without comment.

1. A GUEST MUST BE INVITED BY NAME. 2. TEST FIRST. 3. THREE NOS SEND IT AWAY. 4. EVERY NIGHT A GUEST STAYS, THE HOST LOSES ONE MEMORY. THE ONE THEY HOLD HARDEST.

"Rule four's a guess," she said. "A good guess. But the numbers fit. Eleven hosts. Eleven holes."

"We have to tell people."

"We have to tell them tonight," Priya said. "Before eleven fifty-two."

The Lutheran church basement held three hundred by five o'clock.

I hadn't wanted a meeting. I wanted a bullhorn. But Pastor Ruth Engstrom, who was sixty-three and wore men's work boots and had buried half the people in that room, had walked up to me in the parking lot and said, "Girl, a town this size does not take instructions from a bullhorn. Come downstairs and say it out loud."

So I stood by the coffee urn the size of a fire hydrant and I told Merrow what the lake charged.

Nobody shouted. That was the horrible part. I'd prepared for anger. I'd prepared for fear. What I got instead was a long, steady silence, like the quiet when somebody important has already left the room.

Then Walter Jaeckel stood up, a tall man with a sunburned neck.

"Miss Kerrigan," he said. "I held my father's hand today. I didn't know I'd missed it for thirty years. If the lake wants my daughter's first word, it can have it. She'll say another."

Somebody clapped. Then someone else. Then the whole basement rose, not in anger but in a kind of terrible joy, applauding the price, and I stood there with an index card in my hand and understood what I was up against.

It wasn't the lake. It was love.

Pastor Ruth walked up beside me and said into the quiet, in her smoker's voice, "Everybody keep your own counsel. I'll say this once. It is not a thing we decide for each other. But I want every one of you to test, and to say three nos, and to write down in the morning what you've lost, so that you know. Is that fair?"

It was, apparently, fair.

Outside, in the church lot, the dark came down early. A cold wind off the lake smelled of ice and iron. In every window on Spruce Street a lamp was already lit.

Theo's truck was parked at the curb with its engine running.

He was sitting behind the wheel with both hands on top of the dashboard, and when I opened the passenger door, I saw his fingers were white at the tips.

"I can't get warm," he said. "I've been in front of the heater for three hours."

I took his hands in both of mine.

They were like handling stone out of a river. I held them between my palms and breathed on them, and his breath caught.

"It's the song," he said. "It's bigger than the song. When I try to remember what I lost, there's a cold place where it used to be. It goes all the way down." He gave me a crooked, apologetic smile. "I'm not complaining. I'd do it again."

"I'm complaining for you."

"Danny's worth it."

"That isn't the point."

"It's exactly the point." He looked at our hands. "Sadie. You know what it was like standing on that beach every nineteenth for twelve years, and not knowing why I wanted to die?"

I didn't answer. His hands were warming, a little, in mine.

When I got home, the kitchen light was on.

My mother sat at the table in her good blue cardigan with her hair brushed and a lamp burning in the window beside her, holding the index card Priya had written.

She had read it, I could tell. She had read it more than once.

"I'm inviting Pat tonight," she said.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!