The trouble with a Halloween party is that nobody can tell whose costume is a costume.
I could. By Friday I had a trained eye. The chimney sweep by the keg had real soot on his cuffs and a puddle of nothing under his boots. The flapper on the arm of the couch had a gray bruise above her left eye that no makeup artist would have chosen. A man in a hospital gown stood by the window and looked out at the street with an expression no costume contest has ever rewarded.
“Okay, hear me out,” Dee said at my elbow. “You came as a pharmacist.”
“I came as a person with a normal life.”
“You came in your work coat with a plastic stethoscope from the bin at Pellman’s.”
“It’s a normal life with a stethoscope.”
Dee had come as a software bug: green tights, felt antennae, and a sign pinned to her chest that read IT WORKS ON MY MACHINE. Her coworker Marcus was throwing the party two weeks early, in a loft above a bike shop on Quarry Street, because he would be in Tucson for his sister’s wedding on the thirty-first. Dee had insisted. She said I needed to spend one evening around people with pulses.
The candle on my phone read thirty-eight. I’d kept it dark in my pocket since Thursday. Julian stood by the bookshelf with his hands in his sleeves, tall and transparent and entirely out of place, like a lighthouse at a pool party.
“The dead love Halloween,” he’d told me on the stairs. “It’s the one night the Bench empties out. Nobody can tell us from the guests. Nobody even asks us to leave.”
So the party was full of them, and not one of the living knew. A man dressed as a pirate went through the drywall like an apology. A very old woman in a prairie dress reached for a deviled egg on a tray. Her fingers passed through it. She drew them back with a look of enormous longing. I stopped trying to count.
Then a speaker somewhere started a slow song, and Julian looked at the floor, and cleared his throat.
“Would you like to dance?” he said. “I can’t, technically. But I can stand very close and move in sympathy.”
I put the phone on the bookshelf, screen up, so he’d stay. I stood in front of him, in my coat, with a stethoscope around my neck. He lifted one hand and set it an inch from my waist, and the other an inch from my hand, and we turned in a very small circle between two people dressed as taco shells.
It’s hard to explain being an inch from someone who cannot touch you. His cold didn’t pull, the way Gary’s had. It sat above my skin like the outline of a hand drawn in cold pencil, and the rest of me felt warm by comparison, which is the most romantic thing anyone has ever done for my body temperature.
“I’d like to put on record,” Julian said into my hair, “that this is the best night I’ve had since March.”
“It’s a low bar.”
“It’s a very low bar. I’m still thrilled.”
Across the room, Dee had her phone up and was filming us, in the camera view, like a nature documentary. She mouthed, You two are the cutest haunting I’ve ever seen. I would have been furious if I hadn’t been so happy.
That was when I noticed the Hosts.
You could pick them out once you knew. They stood alone in corners wearing scarves and gloves in a room that had to be eighty degrees. They all glanced at their phones too often, and they all beamed, in the particular way people beam when a delivery has finally arrived. Each had a ghost standing at the elbow like a coat they weren’t wearing. There were seven of them, I counted, and that was just the room.
One of them came over, a heavyset man in a flannel with a nametag that said RAY and, under it, in the thick marker strokes of a man who doesn’t want to be forgotten, BEAL.
“You’re on it too,” he said, warmly, and held up his phone. The icon was a black heart with a keyhole. “I can tell. The hands. You can’t hide the hands. I’m Ray. Electrician. I’ve been on six months.”
“Lena. Pharmacist. Four days.”
“Oh, honey.” He laughed, and his teeth chattered. “You’re gonna love it. I’ve never been so popular. Mary Ellen here, she’s been with me since May.” He nodded at a woman in a nineteen-fifties dress who smiled at me politely, as if from the other end of a long hallway.
I looked at his phone. The candle in the corner read 9%.
“Ray,” I said. “How are you feeling?”
“Never better. Little cold.” He shrugged. “That’s the thing about the upgrade. They sent me a message today, they said I’m being promoted. ‘Premium.’ Founder’s going to see me himself.” He lit up. “Imagine that. A man like me.”
“I don’t think that’s a promotion.”
“He told me I’d never be lonely again.”
Julian had stopped dancing. He had stopped being even faintly polite. He stood beside me, rigid, looking at Ray as one looks at the edge of a cliff.
“Lena,” he said. “Get him a chair. Now.”
I found a folding chair near the stairwell and got Ray into it. He sat, still smiling, and his gloved hands fell open on his knees. Mary Ellen, at his shoulder, put her fingers over her mouth.
“Ray?” I said.
He looked at me. His smile wasn’t quite Ray’s smile anymore. It was the smile of a man trying a coat on in a store.
My phone buzzed against the bookshelf. The elevator chime, but low and slow. I took the phone down. I didn’t want to. I read it anyway.
Edmund Orrin has swiped right on you. It’s a match!
The profile photo was a black-and-white shot of a thin man in a brown suit and a narrow tie, with large glasses and ears that stuck out a little, standing in front of a wall of small switches and cords. He did not look like a founder. He looked like a man who had spent his whole life being kind to strangers who never learned his name.
Edmund, 36. Passed: 1974. Cause: pending. Last active: now. Distance: 0 ft.
The man in the folding chair put his hands on his knees and sat up straight. Ray’s face went through a rearrangement, one muscle at a time. When it finished, a different man was looking out of it, with a mild, careful expression and the posture of someone who was used to being the only one in the room allowed to ask.
“Miss Park,” said a voice that was not Ray’s. It was old and quiet and unhurried, a dry, polite telephone voice that had put a hundred strangers through to each other and never asked who they were. “May I?”
My legs said no. My mouth said, “May you what?”
“Speak with you. I have borrowed this gentleman only for a moment, and he will be quite well afterward, I assure you. It is a rather poor fit. The sleeves are short.” He smiled, the way Ray’s face did not know how to smile. “I do apologize. I wanted to introduce myself properly. It is so much better than a text.”
“Who,” I said, “are you?”
“Edmund Orrin. I run the Switchboard.” He folded Ray’s hands. “I’d like to take you to dinner, Miss Park. Thursday, if you are free. The Silver Dollar Supper Club, on Quarry Street, ground floor of the old Exchange. I’ve kept a table for you for a long time.”
The room went quiet in my ears. I heard a phone ringing, far away, down a long hallway, and nobody picking up, and then, at the end of it, someone finally did.
I had remembered the phone for twenty-one years. I had never remembered the voice. A man who said, kindly, to an eight-year-old on the other end of the line, Not yet, Miss. I’ll call.
“I did say I’d call,” said Edmund Orrin, in a stranger’s mouth. “And you have been so very warm.”

