I didn't make a scene. My mother raised me better than that.
I walked back up the service stairs in silence. I smiled at a waiter carrying a tray of champagne. I walked straight through my own beautiful kitchen, past the lemon cake, out the back door, and into the alley, where it had started to rain.
It was a cold November rain, the kind that goes straight through silk. I didn't care. I pulled out my phone to call a car with fingers that wouldn't stop shaking.
The door banged open behind me.
"Margo."
I didn't turn around. "Go back inside. Your trap's still running. Wouldn't want to waste it."
"You heard."
"Every word." Now I turned. He stood in the doorway in his white shirt, rain already darkening his shoulders. Behind him, Teddy hovered like a heartbroken wardrobe. "Did you have a good laugh, planning it? While I was picking out the peonies?"
"No." His voice cracked on it. "No, Margo. Never that."
"Then what? Explain it to me. You promised me no more lies."
"I didn't lie."
"You didn't tell me I was bait!"
"You were already bait!" It came out of him like something tearing. He took a step into the rain. "From the second Bianca sent you that text, you were a target. Somebody tore your home apart. Somebody sent you a photo to turn you against me. They are coming for you whether I like it or not, and I had two choices. Hide you and pray they found you on a night I wasn't looking. Or make sure that when they came, I was standing right next to you."
"You could have told me."
"Would you have said yes?"
"No."
"Then you understand why I didn't ask."
I laughed. It was an ugly sound. "That's the problem, Santo. That's always been the problem. You decide. Six years ago you decided I was better off hating you. Tonight you decided I could be a lure. You decide what I can handle and what I'm allowed to know, and you never once let me decide anything."
The rain fell between us. He didn't have an answer. I watched him not have one.
I pulled the ring off my finger. It came off easily. Too easily. I took off his jacket, folded it over my arm, tucked the ring into the breast pocket, and held it out.
"Rule five," I said. "I'm walking away."
"The thirty days aren't over."
"They are for me."
He took the jacket. His hand closed over the pocket where the ring was, hard, like it might try to escape.
"Teddy goes with you," he said hoarsely. "You don't have to talk to him. You don't have to look at him. But he goes."
I wanted to say no. I wasn't stupid enough to say no.
"Fine."
"Margo..."
I got into the car before he could finish. I didn't look back. I'm still not sure if that was strength or cowardice.
Priya lived in a third-floor walk-up in Pilsen with a radiator that clanked like a ghost and a couch that had seen me through every breakup since college. She opened the door, took one look at me dripping in emerald silk, and went straight to the freezer for ice cream.
Teddy parked across the street and stayed in the car. Every so often I looked out the window and saw him sitting there, enormous and patient, eating a sandwich in the dark.
"So he used you as a lure," Priya said, handing me a spoon. "And you're furious."
"Yes."
"Because he lied."
"Because he decided."
"And because," Priya said carefully, "you were about to tell him you love him."
I put my face in a cushion and didn't answer.
By one in the morning, Priya was asleep on the other end of the couch and I was staring at the ceiling. Santo had called four times. I hadn't picked up. Then my phone lit up with a different name.
Nico.
Heard what happened. For what it's worth, I told him he's an idiot. You okay?
I stared at the screen. Then I typed: Not really.
The reply came fast.
Real talk. My father will know you two split by breakfast. If he's coming for you, your best friend's place is the first place he'll look. Let me get you somewhere nobody in this family knows about. My mom's old cottage across the lake in Michigan. Nobody's been there in years.
And a moment later: Don't tell Teddy. Teddy tells Santo everything. His ears do a thing.
I almost smiled at that.
I thought about Nico in the wine cellar, saying, He's my father, Santo. I thought about how much that must have cost him. To stand beside his cousin against his own blood. I thought about Aldo's eyes on my face across the dinner table, and his hand holding mine a second too long.
Rule six. You don't go anywhere without telling me first.
Santo had broken his rule tonight. I could break mine.
Okay, I typed. Back alley. Ten minutes.
Priya woke up while I was pulling on her old sneakers and a borrowed hoodie over my gown. "Where are you going?"
"Somewhere safe. Nico's taking me."
"Margo. It's one in the morning. You can't just..."
"It's Nico," I said. "He's the good one."
I went down the back stairs, past the dumpsters, into the narrow alley. The rain had softened into a cold drizzle. A car was idling at the end of the alley with its headlights off.
A silver sedan.
I hesitated. Just for a second. Something cold brushed the back of my mind. Then I told myself half the cars in Chicago are silver, and I got in.
"Hey, you," Nico said warmly, and handed me a paper cup of hot chocolate. "With extra marshmallows. I'm told it's medically necessary after a breakup."
"We weren't actually together," I said. "So it's not technically a breakup."
"Sure," Nico said, pulling out. "And I'm technically not a great dancer."
I laughed despite myself. He drove south, chatting easily, past the dark warehouses and the glowing gas stations, toward the highway and Indiana and the long road around the lake. He told me a story about Santo at fourteen trying to impress a girl by jumping off a boathouse roof and landing in four feet of water. He told me Santo had been impossible to live with for six years. He told me he'd always wondered who the girl at the lake was.
"And now I know," he said, smiling at me sideways. "Makes sense, actually."
The heat was on. The hot chocolate was sweet. For the first time all night, my shoulders started to come down from around my ears.
I reached for the lip balm in my hoodie pocket and fumbled it. It bounced off my knee and rolled into the pocket of the passenger door.
I reached down to fish it out.
My fingers closed on something smooth and hard and the wrong shape.
I pulled it out.
It was a phone. Switched off. In a pale blue case, with two tiny letters picked out in seed pearls across the back.
B.C.
I knew that case. I'd ordered it myself, from a little shop in Lincoln Square, and I'd given it to Bianca at her final fitting as her something blue. Her future initials. Bianca Corvino. She'd laughed until she cried and said she'd never take it off.
She'd had it in her hand on Thursday morning.
I looked up slowly.
Nico wasn't smiling anymore. His eyes moved from the phone in my hand to my face, and something in them went quiet and flat and patient, like a door closing.
Beside me, all four door locks clicked down at once.
"Ah, Margo," Nico said softly. "Nonna was right about you. You notice too much."

