On the day I should have been watching Santo Corvino marry someone else, I met his grandmother instead.
"She asked for you specifically," Santo said in the car. "Those were her exact words. If my grandson is going to insult New Jersey for a woman, I will feed the woman."
"Is that a threat?"
"With my grandmother, it's hard to tell."
I'd been living in his apartment for three nights. It sat on the forty-first floor of a glass tower on the lake, and it was so clean and gray and quiet that I kept whispering in it like a library. He'd given me the guest suite. He'd stocked the fridge with the oat milk I didn't remember telling him I liked. And at two in the morning, when I got up for water, I'd found him asleep on the living room couch in his clothes, facing the front door.
He hadn't said anything about it in the morning. Neither had I.
The Corvino house in River Forest was red brick and old money, with potted lemon trees on the steps and a stone saint in the garden holding a lily. I'd planned weddings at houses like this. I knew how to walk into them. Shoulders back, smile ready, never look impressed by the chandelier.
"Rule one," I said quietly as he opened my car door. "Someone's going to be watching."
"Everyone," he agreed, and laced his fingers through mine.
It felt more natural than it should have. That was a problem for later.
Lucia Corvino was eighty-four years old and roughly the size of a fire hydrant. She wore black silk, three strands of pearls, and Santo's exact eyes, dark and patient and unimpressed. She looked at me for a long moment in her front hall.
Then she said, "You're too thin. Sit."
Dinner was served at a table that could have seated twenty. Tonight it seated six. Nonna at the head. Santo at her right hand, me beside him. Across from us, Santo's younger sister Gia, a third-year law student with a sharp bob and an even sharper mouth, who took one look at me and mouthed, Run.
Beside Gia sat Uncle Aldo.
He was handsome the way old movie villains are handsome. Silver hair, gold cufflinks, a tan that didn't come from Chicago in November. He kissed my hand when we were introduced and held it a beat too long, studying my face with an odd, private interest, like I reminded him of a song he couldn't name.
His son Nico sat at the end. Santo's cousin and, he informed me, Santo's best friend since diapers. Nico had dimples and a wide, easy grin, the kind of smile that belonged on a game show host. He leaned over the bread basket and whispered, "Welcome to the family. Blink twice if you need rescuing."
I liked him immediately. Everyone, I suspected, liked Nico immediately.
The questions started with the antipasto.
"Where did you meet my grandson?" Nonna asked.
"At a wedding," I said. True.
"Whose?"
"I was working it." Also true.
"And what is his middle name?"
My mind went perfectly, catastrophically blank. I'd memorized four hundred guest names and their dietary restrictions. I did not know Santo Corvino's middle name.
Under the table, his knee pressed against mine.
"She doesn't use it, Nonna," he said easily. "She calls me Sam."
My fork stopped halfway to my mouth.
Nonna went very still. Her gaze moved from Santo to me and back, and something shifted in her face. Something almost tender.
"Sam," she repeated. "From the summer at the lake."
Santo said nothing. He didn't have to. His ears had gone faintly red.
"He came home from that lake house a different boy," Nonna told me, as if Santo weren't there at all. "That night his father was killed, and he came home a man. I always wondered which girl took the boy." She picked up her wine. "Now I know."
I didn't know what to do with that. I looked down at my plate and, because I'm my mother's daughter, I noticed the tablecloth instead.
"This is Burano lace," I said. "Hand-worked. Someone mended this corner, beautifully. You can barely see it."
"I mended it," Nonna said. "In 1962. My husband spilled wine on our wedding night and I nearly killed him."
"It's the most beautiful repair I've ever seen."
She looked at me for a long time. Then she said, to Santo, "This one notices."
"She always did," Santo said.
Across the table, Uncle Aldo laughed softly. "A party planner. How modern of you, Santo. Your father would have been fascinated."
The temperature in the room dropped ten degrees.
Santo set down his fork. He didn't raise his voice. He didn't need to. "Her name is Margo, Zio. Say it with respect at this table, or don't say it."
Aldo's smile didn't move. "Of course. Margo." He lifted his glass to me. "Welcome."
"Nobody move," Gia muttered into her wine. "I want to remember this forever."
After the tiramisu, Nonna called me into the front parlor alone. She opened a small velvet box from her pocket and held it out.
Inside was a ring. Not new. An old European-cut diamond in a band of rose gold, worn thin and soft with decades of someone's hands.
"This was my mother's," she said. "Then mine. I did not give it to the Rinaldi girl. Santo never asked me for it." She took my left hand and slid the ring onto my finger. It fit. Of course it fit. "I was waiting to see who he'd bring me."
"Mrs. Corvino, I can't..."
"Nonna."
"Nonna. It's not... we're not..."
"I am eighty-four years old," she said. "I know exactly what you are." And she patted my cheek and left me standing there with a family heirloom on my hand and absolutely no idea what she'd meant.
I found Santo on the back terrace under the bare branches of a fig tree, looking out over the dark garden. The cold made his breath smoke. He turned when he heard me and his eyes went straight to the ring.
Neither of us spoke for a moment.
"She gave you that," he said finally.
"She did. I'll give it back. After."
"Keep it on for now." His voice was rough. "She'd notice."
"Santo." I came to stand beside him at the railing. "What she said in there. About the summer. About you coming home different."
"My grandmother exaggerates."
"No, she doesn't."
He was quiet. Then, so softly I almost didn't hear it, he said, "I'm not good at pretending, Margo. Not with you. I never was."
He reached up and tucked a loose strand of hair behind my ear. His knuckles grazed my cheek. I stopped breathing.
"Why didn't you call?" I whispered. "Six years. Just tell me why."
He opened his mouth.
His phone rang.
He looked at the screen and his face shut like a door. "I have to take this. Stay here. Two minutes." He squeezed my hand once and went inside.
I stood alone in the cold with my heart going like a hummingbird.
Then my own phone buzzed.
Unknown number. A photo.
It took a second to load. When it did, the whole world tilted under my feet.
It was the loading dock behind the Larkspur Hotel. I knew it instantly. I'd signed for every crate of roses back there. The timestamp in the corner read Thursday, 9:42 a.m.
Five hours before Santo walked into my ballroom and pretended he had no idea where his bride was.
In the photo, Santo was dragging Bianca toward a car. His hand was clamped around her upper arm. Her mascara had run down her face and her mouth was open, like she was screaming. And on the white cuff of Santo's shirt, bright and unmistakable, was blood.
A second message came through beneath it.
He told you she never showed up. Ask him whose blood that is.
"Margo?"
I spun around. Santo stood in the terrace doorway, backlit by the warm gold of his grandmother's kitchen. His eyes went to my face, then to the phone in my hand.
"Who's texting you?" he asked.
I looked down at the ring on my finger. At the photo glowing on my screen.
"Nobody," I said.
Rule four was no lies. I'd written it myself. I just hadn't stopped to wonder which one of us would break it first.


