Pellam Bridge toll book, margin, in Lorne Fitch’s hand: “Sunday. Casseroles received: nine. Opinions received: more.”
Five nights to the crest.
By nine on Sunday morning, all of Pellam Bridge knew, and had come to look.
They did not come in a crowd. They came the way a small town comes to a house with a death in it, one at a time, in good coats, carrying dishes with foil on them and a determined cheerfulness that did not reach their eyes. They parked in a line along the county road. They stood on the porch of the green house and rang the bell, though the door was already open. Dennis the dog, who had never in his life met a person he did not approve of, greeted each one with the same affectionate wuff.
Nell, who had slept on a fold-out couch in the front room with Priya’s feet in her kidneys, sat at the kitchen table with a cup of coffee and watched the town come through.
Jo made the coffee. That was the first strange thing. She stood at the stove in her too-short jeans, spooning grounds into a battered percolator, and when Nell said, “I take mine with salt,” she turned and gave her a look of such total, quizzical recognition that Nell nearly dropped the mug.
“I know,” said Jo. “It’s on the card. Teo’s hands do it for you, don’t they. I know that too. I know a lot about you, Nell. It’s a little embarrassing. I got it from the town.”
“From the town.”
“Everyone who ever pledged anything, Lorne says, pledged it at this counter, to my face. And what they felt about the pledge, they felt about me. The fear. The gratitude. The ones who were angry that I took their sorrow. The ones who were angry that I would not take more.” She set a mug down in front of Nell. “It all went somewhere, apparently. It went into the Vault with my name on it. I think I’m what was left over.”
“You think you are a sum,” said Nell.
“I think I am a casserole,” said Jo, with her crooked smile. “Years of everybody’s opinions of me, baked until set.”
Nell laughed, helplessly, and put her hand over her mouth, and Jo looked pleased and a little stunned, as though she had not expected to be funny.
It was the visitors who were the problem.
The first was a stout woman in a quilted jacket who stopped in the doorway with her hand pressed to her chest and said, “Jo,” in a voice like a dropped plate.
“Hello, Adaeze,” said Jo.
“You look so thin. You always did. You haven’t been eating.” The stout woman, who was Adaeze Pruitt of the Pruitt Hardware family, strode across the kitchen and took Jo’s face in both hands and examined it. “I told them. I said, ‘She will come home and she will be skin and bone.’ I brought the pot roast.”
“It smells wonderful.”
“It’s the recipe you gave me. The one with the stout.”
“I would never have used stout,” said Jo. “I’m allergic to it. I think I gave you the one with the cider.”
Adaeze’s eyes filled. She had nodded vigorously. “That’s right! That’s right, it was the cider. Oh, Jo, it really is you.”
Nell, behind the percolator, set down her mug. She had seen it. So had Priya, in the doorway to the hall, her eyebrows halfway up her forehead.
Jo had said the wrong thing on purpose. She had a recipe in her head with stout, and she had said the cider, and the cider had been right, but the stout had been what Adaeze remembered, and Jo had known it. She had held both and chosen.
Then the second visitor came in, a thin man in a tweed cap who did not hug anyone, and said, “Jo, I want my watch back.”
“I don’t have your watch, Mr. Haskins.”
“You took it. Five years ago. You said it was for the heartache. I never got it back.”
“It’s in the loft, with your pledge,” said Jo gently. “If you come to the counter, you can tell the Keeper about it, and take the sorrow back, one true memory at a time. I’ll walk you over myself.”
“You always said that.”
“I always did.”
He stared at her for a long moment, his mouth working, and then said, in a smaller voice, “You were always very patient with me. I never said thank you.”
“You’re welcome, Mr. Haskins.”
By eleven, Nell had counted nineteen visitors and had begun to see the pattern.
A heavyset man who thought of Jo as stern got a Jo who stood straight and answered in short sentences. A nervous teenage girl who thought of her as sweet got a Jo who touched her arm. The woman who ran the diner, who had never trusted her, got a polite Jo who kept the table between them. Each time, the change was tiny. A tilt of the head. A choice of word. No one noticed but Nell, and Priya, and Teo, who had come in from the porch and was leaning on the doorframe with his arms crossed and his jaw tight.
“She’s doing it again,” he muttered.
“I know.”
“She is a mirror. Every person who comes through sees the Jo they carry.”
“Yes.”
“It’s the oldest trick of a counterfeit. It gives you what you expect.”
“I don’t think it’s a trick,” Nell said. She kept her voice low. “I think she can’t help it. She’s built from what they felt. She’s turning toward the part that’s theirs.”
“And Tilly?”
“Watch.”
Tilly had spent the morning on the stairs with the notebook in her lap. She had not said much. She had watched each visitor, her eyes following every word, and had made a mark in the notebook after each one, small, neat, in pencil.
At noon the last neighbor left. The kitchen was full of foil-covered dishes. Jo, drained, sat down at the table, and rubbed her face with both hands.
“I’m sorry,” she said. “I don’t know how to stop.”
“Stop what?”
“Becoming what they want.” She looked up, and for a second her face, which had been warm and varied all morning, went completely still and plain. “I don’t think I’m being dishonest. I think I’m doing it the way water takes the shape of a glass. But I’ve been very careful not to do it with Tilly. I’ve been plain with her. And she knows.”
“What does she know?”
“That I’m not hers,” said Jo, and Nell, who had been holding her breath, let it go.
From the stairs, a small voice said, “Mom.”
They both turned. Tilly had come down two steps. She was holding the notebook against her chest.
“What’s my cat’s name?” she said.
“You don’t have a cat. You have a dog. Dennis.”
“Dennis isn’t mine. He’s Mr. Pruitt’s. He just lives here.” The notebook was shaking now. “We have a cat. It’s on the list. Everyone I asked got it wrong. Mrs. Pruitt said Biscuit. Mr. Haskins said Mittens. They all had a different one.”
“Tilly.”
“What’s the cat’s name?”
Jo opened her mouth, and Nell, watching, saw something cross her face, something quick and desperate, the face of a person looking through a drawer for something she knows is not there.
“I don’t know,” she said.
It was the plainest voice Nell had ever heard. It had nobody in it, nobody’s hope, nobody’s fear, nothing but the truth.
“There isn’t one, is there,” said Jo. “I’m so sorry, Tilly. There is no cat. No one ever gave me one. I’m not able to get it from anyone, because it’s a thing only you know.”
Tilly came down the last two steps. She stood in front of the woman at the table, very small, very straight, with her braids neat and her chin up.
“It’s Pickle,” she said. “He died when I was seven. I’ve never told anyone. I was saving it.”
And she turned and walked out of the kitchen, and the screen door slapped, and from the porch, Dennis the dog, uninvited, followed her.

