PAYMENT DUE AT TIME OF SERVICE. NO CREDIT. NO EXCEPTIONS. WE KNOW. WE KNOW.
By Sunday morning the harbor of Tallow Cove held eleven boats, nine hundred gallons of diesel behind a padlock, and, by Dolores’s count, one hundred and forty dollars in actual cash.
The fuel dock had reopened on Friday, as Brandt had promised, and the line had started at four in the morning. By noon the first problem had arrived, which was that the island did not use cash. It used the Co-op. A person bought a pound of butter and the clerk wrote it in a book, and on the first of the month the book was settled against the catch, the lease, the Program and the debt, and money as a physical object was something you saw on the mainland, like escalators. The line outside the pump was forty skippers long, and not one of them could pay.
Dolores solved it in about ninety minutes. She would have said it was nothing. She nailed a plank across two sawhorses at the end of the wharf and hung a sign from it that said THE EXCHANGE. By two o’clock the first customer had arrived with a bucket of smoked crab, and by Sunday morning, in a thin cold sunshine with the gulls gone quiet, there were sixty stalls.
I am a pharmacist, and I know the look of a market that has been built by people who are frightened. It is very cheerful. A man sold a chainsaw for forty gallons of diesel. A woman sold eleven jars of plum jam for a week’s groceries and the use of a truck. The Altar Guild, in matching aprons, ran a table where you could trade an hour of work for a hot meal, and I watched Mrs. Pardee, who must have been eighty, ladle chowder with the grim fury of a general. Tav’s mother Losa ran a stall of fried bread, which was already gone.
“A sensible people,” said Winnie, at my elbow, with a pot. “It’s a very sensible thing, to be poor on purpose.”
“It isn’t on purpose.”
“It is after the first week, pet.”
Hank was bargaining. She sat on an overturned crate at the head of the dock, in her wool coat with her stick across her knees, and across from her stood a skipper named Ostrander, who was fifty and enormous and visibly regretting his entire morning. Hank had four hundred pounds of frozen bait in the Dawn’s hold, and Ostrander had a leaking fuel tank that he needed to move before Wednesday.
“Sixty gallons for the bait,” said Hank.
“It’s worth eighty.”
“It’s old,” said Hank. “Noted. Sixty.”
He gave her sixty. I did not see the moment he decided to; it was the sort of thing that happened to people around Hank, quietly, like weather.
By the end of the morning I had taken sixty-one numbers on the dock, at the end of a table, for free, with a sign Dolores had made for me that said THUMBS: BASIC ASSAY, NO CHARGE, NO QUESTIONS. I did not ask any. A woman of seventy had a ceiling of one point one and wanted to know if she should be worried; I told her no, and she looked disappointed.
It was Tav who nudged me. He had stood by the table with a rope over his shoulder, being quiet, being large, and he tipped his head toward the end of the wharf, where a green truck was parked with its engine running.
“Don’t,” said Tav, very low.
“I haven’t done anything.”
“You’re going to. I can tell. You’re getting the face.”
“What face?”
“The one you made at Voorhees.”
The truck was Roy Dacey’s.
I had not seen him since the hall. He had been a large friendly man with a loud laugh, the kind of man who slaps you on the shoulder, and had been Voorhees’s favorite skipper for twelve years. He had walked out of the Co-op on Founders’ Night in sea boots, with a bandage on his arm, and not said a word. He now sat in the cab of the truck, with the window down, and a flask on the dashboard that, I knew from fifty feet, was not coffee.
He looked at me. He lifted two fingers from the wheel.
I went. Tav came with me; I did not try to stop him. When we reached the truck, Dacey said, “Not him. Just you, Thumbs,” and Tav said, “I’m going to stand here,” in a tone that closed the subject.
“Fine,” said Dacey, tiredly.
He was a different man. The big shoulders were still there, but he had gone loose in them, like a sack that had been emptied. His beard needed a trim. His eyes were bloodshot and flat, and he did not smile, which is the thing I noticed first, because I had never seen his face without it.
“I can’t lose,” said Roy Dacey. “You know that about me.”
“I do.”
“It’s not pride. I’ve thought about it. I’ve had three days. It’s just a thing in me, like a limp.” He took a drink. “I’m going to lose the Gull. The bar’s got her. The bank’s got the mortgage. Voorhees is in a cardigan crying. And I can’t lose. So I’ve come to sell you something.”
“What?”
He leaned over. He reached under the seat and brought out a black ledger, an ordinary school accounts book, the kind you buy at a stationer’s for four dollars. It was soft at the corners. He put it on the dash.
“Seventeen years of Stacks,” he said. “That’s mine. Every one I ever delivered to the Co-op launch. I wrote it all down. Don’t ask me why. A man who sells people ought to keep books.”
I said nothing. I could not have.
“Date. Name. Where they dropped. What I got, which was a bonus, which was a thousand dollars a head.” He did not look at me. “And the pink slip. The launch man gave a pink copy for every one, signed by the man who took the delivery on the other end. I stapled them in. Every one.” He tapped the cover. “I didn’t read them. Not for years. And then Thursday night I did.”
“What do they say?”
“They say who the buyer was.” He picked up the flask, looked at it, and set it down again, without drinking. “It isn’t the Co-op. Never was. They’re all received on behalf of the Calder Street Memorial Fund. And every one has the same two initials.” He opened the ledger to a page at random. I saw a long run of pink paper, stapled in rows, each slip small and flimsy and perfectly legible, with a signature in a small neat slanting hand at the bottom. “P.H.”
I knew the hand. I had seen it three days before, in pen, on the bottom of a telegram. And the pharmacist.
“How much?” I said.
“Two thousand,” said Dacey. “Cash. I know it’s a lot. I know you’ll say I’ve got no right to ask.” His voice cracked on the last word, and he looked out of the windshield. “I haven’t got any right. I sold people. I didn’t know what for. I said I didn’t, and it’s true, and it doesn’t matter. But I’ve got a little girl on the mainland I haven’t paid for in a year, and I’d rather she got the money from the thing I did right than the thing I did wrong. Is that a stupid thing to say?”
“No,” I said.
“I can’t lose,” said Roy Dacey. “So I thought I’d sell it to the people who could.”
I stood on the wharf in the thin sun, with the gulls wheeling and the chowder-steam rising and the whole island selling jam, and I thought of Brandt’s cash box, which held two thousand and sixty-one dollars, and was the only money on Saint Orrin that belonged to nobody.
“I’ll get it,” I said.
“Thumbs.” He held the ledger out of the window. His hand was shaking. “Look at the last page. Before you go. Please. Just look.”
I took it. I turned to the back, to a pink slip that was not stapled but pinned, and I read it where I stood. It was dated Founders’ Night. It was not a delivery slip. It was a single typed line on a Trust letterhead, and it had been slid under the door of the Lone Gull’s wheelhouse the morning after the toast.
It said: NEXT TIME IT WILL BE THE PHARMACIST. IT WOULD SAVE US ALL A GREAT DEAL OF TROUBLE IF YOU WERE THE ONE TO DELIVER HER.
The initials at the bottom were P.H.

