IF YOU TASTE SOMETHING UNEXPECTED, SAY SO OUT LOUD.
Nobody in that hall drank, for about nine seconds, and I will remember them for the rest of my life.
They stood at the long tables in their good clothes with a paper cup in one hand and a gallon jug in the other, eleven hundred people holding two kinds of water, and they looked at me. They looked at Voorhees. They looked at the cups, steaming gently in the lantern light. It was a very old hall and a very old custom, and it had a force behind it that I could feel from the stage, the pressure of sixty years of being part of a thing.
A boy of about seven, at the front table, said clearly, “Mama, is it the bad kind?”
“Hush,” said his mother, and did not drink.
“Friends,” said Alder Voorhees, and raised his cup, and the hall lifted with him. “To those who gave.”
The whole room drank.
Not all of it. I counted, because I count. About two hundred, the jug-holders, put their cups down on the cloth and picked up the water. A hundred more stood with their cups at their lips and did not let it in. But the rest, seven hundred or eight, took the toast with a long slow swallow and a murmur of pleasure, as they had every December since they were children, and the band played a soft chord.
I came down the steps of the stage with my knees shaking. I went to the nearest table, to a stout woman in a green dress who had just set her cup down, and I said, “May I?” and took it from her hand. I put my tongue to the rim.
Salt. A thin, honest, bright salt. A cold clean taste, like the edge of a wave.
Three point oh.
I stood there with the cup in my bandaged hand and did not understand. I put it down and took another, from the man beside her. Three point one. I took a third. Two point nine. I went down the length of the table, tasting rims, like a woman gone mad in a bakery, and every cup I touched was a three, and every one was plain, and none of them was sweet.
“It’s water,” I said aloud, to nobody.
“It’s been watered,” said a clear dry voice behind me, “by about a third.”
Voorhees had come down from the stage. He had a cup in his hand. He stood in the aisle in his gray cardigan with the lanterns swinging behind him, and he was looking, not at me, but at the line of women at the back of the hall who were standing by the kitchen door with their empty trolleys, in their church aprons, with their arms folded.
The women of the Saint Orrin Methodist Altar Guild have catered every Founders’ Night for forty-one years. They do the pork and the potatoes. They do the urns. It had never crossed anyone’s mind to wonder what they put in them. At the head of the line, in a clean apron over her best dress, with a ladle stuck in her pocket like a sword, stood Winifred Plunkett.
“Mrs. Plunkett,” said Voorhees. He said it kindly. “I wondered.”
“Pet,” said Winnie.
She walked down the aisle. She is not a tall woman, but the hall parted for her as it had for him, and she came and stood a yard from him, with her hands on her hips, and looked him in the eye.
“I did it,” said Winnie. “I took six hundred gallons of Dolores’s water into the church kitchen at four o’clock this afternoon and poured it into your urns, and I cut your toast by two-thirds. Four seasons on the Hazel Dawn I did it, with a white jug, behind Hank’s back, and no one on my boat ever stood at the rail.” Her voice was steady and carried to the back wall. “I thought it was a secret. It wasn’t. It was a recipe.”
A sound went through the hall. It was not quite a laugh.
“You’ve thinned a gift,” said Voorhees, mildly.
“I’ve thinned a poison.”
“That’s a strong word, Winifred.”
“It’s the one I’ve got.” She took the ladle from her pocket and held it in front of her in both hands, like a candle. “Rin.”
I understood. I went back up the steps to the stage and took the envelope out of my coat, Renata’s eleven pages, and I put them on the lectern under the lantern light, and I read.
I did not read it all. I read the first page and the table of four names. I read the line about the three hundred profiles, and the line that said that the material was salt from the skin of human beings, ground fine and dissolved and kept a long time. I read that every tamper strip was intact. I read the name of the laboratory director, and the seal, and the date.
When I read the name Augustus Plunkett, the hall made a sound I will not try to describe.
“My husband,” said Winnie, quite clearly. “He’s in your tank, Alder.”
Nobody spoke. Somewhere near the middle of the hall a man stood up from a bench, very slowly, as if he were afraid that the floor might not hold him. He was about fifty, with a gray beard and a Co-op jacket, and his hands were shaking.
“Deke Halloran,” he said. “That’s my father. March. Fourteen years.”
“Hollis Crane,” said a woman in the third row, and put her hands over her face. “He was my son.”
“The Pardee boys,” said somebody. “The Verity.”
They did not shout. It was not that kind of room. They said the names one by one, in low voices, as if they were reading a roll at a funeral, and the hall rose slowly to its feet around them. I stood at the lectern, holding eleven pages of paper in both hands, and could not stop shaking.
And then a small clear voice, from the front table, said: “Is my dad in there?”
It was the boy of seven. He was standing on his chair. His mother had her arm around him. He looked at me with a perfectly serious face.
I could not answer. I could not tell a child a lie, and I could not tell him the truth, and I thought, quite clearly, of every time I had decided what a person could bear. I looked at the boy. I took a breath.
“I don’t know,” I said. “But I’m going to find out. And I will tell you the number.”
He nodded, as one nods to a doctor, and sat down.
“Noted,” said Hank Skaug.
She had stood up out of her wheelchair. She did it slowly, with her stick and her good right arm, and Nurse Dunne said, “Captain, please,” and Hank did not look at her. She stood in the aisle in her wool coat, a small, stiff, perfectly upright woman of sixty-three, with her stick and her white hair, and the whole hall turned to look.
“Henrietta Skaug,” she said. “Master of the Hazel Dawn. My number is twenty-two point oh, on a ceiling of twenty-eight. It was thirty-one on paper for four winters, and I lied.” Her voice was rough. “I’ve got a band down my spine, and I’ve been in a Home for sixteen days, and it’s not a rest home. It’s a dispensary. They scrape us on Thursdays. They take the salt off our backs with a little brass spoon. They call it VOICE.” She paused. “I would like it known that I am not the one who is ill.”
Nobody breathed.
A man at the back of the hall, a thickset man in a bandage and sea boots, who had come in late and stood by the door with his cap in his hand, turned and went out. It was Roy Dacey. He did not slam the door. I think that was what frightened me.
“I’ll swear to it,” said a voice from the wheelchairs. It was Sunny. She had stepped forward from behind Marlon’s chair. She took the badge off her gray tunic and put it on the white tablecloth, very gently, as if it were a very small, very delicate animal. “I’ve worked Tank Seven for six years. It hums. It adds a voice when there’s a fill. I’ll say it on any oath you give me.”
“Sunny Abara,” said Voorhees, gently. “My dear.”
“Don’t,” said Sunny. “Please don’t.”
He did not. He stood in the center of the aisle with his cup in his hand. He did not look like a man who had been caught. He looked like a man who had been waiting a very long time for a train, and had seen it arrive.
“You’ve made the island very afraid, Ms. Marek,” he said at last, to me, across the length of the hall. His voice was soft and level and carried perfectly. “I don’t say it unkindly. I would have made the same speech. But I would like you to consider one question.” He turned to the crowded tables. “If the Co-op falls, who holds the paper on your boats? Who holds the fuel? Who sends the doctor? Who pays the ninety-three families?” His eyes came back to mine. “It’s very easy to take a thing apart. Who builds the next one?”
I opened my mouth. I had nothing. I had a lab report and six hundred jugs of water and a vial of two. I stood at the lectern with my brother’s handwriting in my pocket and found, to my horror, that Alder Voorhees was right about the question and wrong about everything else.
There was a loud clear knock at the back of the hall.
It was a sharp, flat, official sound, like a gavel. The big double doors were thrown open. A cold wet wind came in and blew the lanterns sideways, and all the heads turned.
Inspector Ines Quarles stood in the doorway in her rain jacket, soaked to the thighs, with her hair plastered to her forehead and her clipboard in a plastic bag. She had come by boat. She had come, I learned later, in the Alice B., with an old man in yellow oilskins at the wheel, across five miles of black water, in the dark. She stood there dripping on the Co-op hall’s varnished floor, in front of eleven hundred people, and she held a long brown envelope in her right hand.
“Alder Voorhees,” said Quarles, in a voice that rang to the rafters. “I have an order from the district magistrate. I am required to serve it on you in the presence of witnesses.” She drew a breath. “I find that there are quite a few.”

