DO NOT TAKE ON AN EMPTY STOMACH. DO NOT TAKE ON A FULL ONE EITHER. TAKE ON A PONTOON.
We sat on the edge of the outermost pontoon with our feet over the water, my brother and I, at four on Sunday morning, in the one hour of the week when Greer Point was quiet.
Or I sat. Danny, as always, was mostly a matter of arrangement: a damp print on the boards beside me, a cold along my left side, and the pencil, which I held, because it was my hand. I had a slate on my knee and a mug of tea at my elbow that I could not taste and had stopped pretending I wanted. Below us, the black water of the harbor lapped the float. Beyond the ring, the east had begun to gray.
"Tav told you what he saw," said Danny, writing, in his loops. It came a little slow, now. We had both noticed that. "In the shed."
"He told me. He said you were the blank card."
I'M THE BLANK CARD.
"I'm not going to say you can't."
GOOD, wrote my brother. BECAUSE I'D HAVE TO LEAVE.
I laughed, and then I stopped, because it was not a joke. We sat for a while without saying anything. A gull stood on a piling and considered us.
"When did it ask you?"
THE FIRST NIGHT. THE NIGHT YOU LET ME OUT OF THE CHAIR. I WAS AT THE SHELL. IT WAS VERY QUIET AND THE WATER WAS DOING THAT THING, THE STANDING THING. AND IT SAID, VERY POLITELY, WOULD I SIT WITH IT FOR A WHILE.
"Not as its friend."
NOT YET AS ANYTHING. IT SAID, I DO NOT WANT YOU TO DO A THING. I WOULD LIKE YOU TO SIT. SO I SAT. WE DIDN'T TALK. IT WAS LIKE WAITING ROOMS. I SAT FOR AN HOUR.
"And you didn't tell me."
I DIDN'T TELL YOU, wrote Danny, and the pencil pressed down a little, because you could always tell when it was something he did not want to write, BECAUSE YOU WOULD HAVE FIXED IT.
I opened my mouth. I shut it.
"That is a very accurate thing to say," I said.
I KNOW. I'M SORRY. I'M NOT SORRY. BOTH.
"Danny."
I LIKE IT.
I looked at the water.
"I'm not saying that I like what it did. I don't know what it did. I know it's the most frightening thing I have ever been near. But Rinny." The slate went on, the loops tilting. IT ASKED ME WHAT I THOUGHT OF THE WEATHER. IT WANTED TO KNOW IF I WAS WARM. I HAVE NOT BEEN ASKED IF I WAS WARM IN TWO YEARS AND SIX MONTHS. THE CO-OP DID NOT ASK. THE HOME DID NOT ASK. THE COURT ASKS WHAT I WANT. IT'S DIFFERENT. NOBODY ASKS A PERSON WHAT HE THINKS OF THE WEATHER UNLESS THEY WANT TO KNOW HIM.
"It might want to keep you."
IT DOES.
"Danny."
IT SAID SO. WE'VE TALKED ABOUT IT. WE TALK ABOUT IT EVERY NIGHT. I SAID, YOU WANT TO KEEP ME. IT SAID, YES. I SAID, I'M ALREADY KEPT. IT SAID, I KNOW. I SAID, THEN WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BEING KEPT AND BEING YOUR FRIEND. AND IT DIDN'T ANSWER FOR A LONG TIME. AND THEN IT SAID, A FRIEND CAN SAY NO.
My hand stopped on the pencil. The wood was warm. I held it still until my brother pushed it on.
I TOLD IT I DIDN'T KNOW IF I COULD. I SAID I HAD NEVER BEEN ABLE TO SAY NO TO IT. I SAID I WAS TOO CLOSE. I SAID IF IT ASKED ME TO STAY, I DON'T THINK I'D HEAR MYSELF. AND IT SAID, THEN YOU MUST NOT BE THE ONE.
"It said that?"
IT SAID, A FRIEND MUST BE ABLE TO WALK AWAY. THAT IS WHY THE LIVING ARE BETTER. THE KEPT CAN NOT. I HAVE NEVER KNOWN. I HAVE ONLY LEARNED IT FROM PASK AND FROM YOU. YOU ARE THE ONLY ONE I KEEP WHO SAYS THINGS THAT MIGHT BE NO.
I put down the pencil, and the slate, and put my face in my hands.
I stayed there some time. A cold hand lay against my left shoulder, very lightly, as a man lays a hand on a sister he has not touched in two years, and held there, and neither of us said a word.
"I told you I was going to be honest," I said at last, into my palms. "I'm going to be. I'm terrified that I'll say the wrong thing and you will go in and do it anyway, because it is your life, and I don't get a vote."
YOU DON'T.
"I know."
BUT I'D LIKE YOU TO HAVE A VOICE. YOU COULD HAVE A VOICE, RINNY, IF YOU CAN STAND IT.
"What does that mean?"
I'M NOT GOING TO SAY YES. I WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT. I TOLD IT NOT YET. IT SAID ALL RIGHT. I SAID, ASK ME AFTER THE SITTING. IT SAID IT WAS GOOD AT WAITING. I THINK IT MEANT IT.
I wiped my face on my sleeve and picked up the slate, and held it where the dawn could reach it.
"I have a pharmacist's question."
GO.
"Why does it have to be one?"
My brother did not write for a moment. The pencil lifted, and hung.
"One friend," I said. "It asks, who will be my friend. Everyone hears friend, and a person. But what it's missing is the arithmetic. It is a very large thing, and it is lonely, and it has been given one dose, ever, one child at a time, and each time the child grew up and went away, and it was alone again." I could feel the idea coming, the cold clean click of a thing falling into its measure. "You never give a patient a single large dose of a thing you can't take back. You split it. You spread it over the day. A little at a time, in a schedule, so no one's system is overwhelmed and none of the doses is the whole of the cure."
IT'S NOT A DRUG.
"Isn't it? It's lonely. That's a condition. It wants company, and it does not know how to ask for less than a person. So give it a rota. A different person, a different day, short visits, no one asked to stay. A Wednesday for Edda. Mondays for Mrs. Pym, if she'll do it. A cup of soup at noon." I was speaking quickly. "No one has to be the whole of it. A friend who can walk away because there are twelve of them. And you, you are never the one, because you are already on the inside. You're the hearer. You're the one who stands at the door and says, this one has had enough."
There was a long, long silence. The gull took off from the piling.
Then, very slowly, the pencil began to move in my hand.
THAT IS A VERY GOOD IDEA, wrote my brother.
"It might not work."
NO. BUT IT'S YOURS. IT'S NOT A THING YOU DID FOR ME. IT'S A THING YOU THOUGHT.
I put my head on the place where his shoulder would have been. It was cold, and then it was not.
"Danny," I said. "What did it say about the girl?"
The pencil stopped.
I'D FORGOTTEN, he wrote, after a while. I TOLD IT NOT YET, AND IT SAID, ALL RIGHT, AND THEN IT SAID A THING I WASN'T SURE I SHOULD TELL.
"Tell me."
THERE'S SOMEONE DOWN THERE IT DOESN'T KEEP. SHE'S NOT KEPT. SHE DOESN'T SAY NO. SHE JUST STAYS. IT SAID, SHE HUMS. IT SAID, SHE'S BEEN KEEPING ME FOR A VERY LONG TIME, AND I HAVE NEVER KNOWN HOW TO TELL HER THANK YOU.

