Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 23

Frank's Boxes

My father's life had been shipped to Vermont in eleven cardboard boxes, and my aunt had put them in the attic and never once, to my knowledge, opened them.

I found them on the morning of the seventh, under a sheet of plastic in the south gable, behind a dressmaker's dummy and a stack of broken chairs. They were stacked in two neat columns. Each one was labeled in block capitals: F. H. - CLOTHES. F. H. - PAPERS. F. H. - DO NOT OPEN UNTIL NELL ASKS.

I read that last one a few times.

"She's got a flair," said Odalys, from the top of the attic stairs. She had followed me up with two mugs and her phone's flashlight and the air of a person who had volunteered for a fire. "Do you want me to stay? Or is this one of those 'I'm going to cry and I'd rather do it alone' things?"

"It's one of those."

"Okay." She set a mug on the floor. "I'll be down in the kitchen. Marnie's making doughnuts. I have a feeling you'll need one."

I sat on an old steamer trunk with a box on my knees and the gray October light slanting through the gable window. The attic smelled of cedar and mothballs and a hundred and thirty years of other people's winters. Dust floated in the beam. Ledger, patched with a small gray bald spot on his flank where the fire had singed him, climbed into the box on my lap, turned around twice and lay down on a pile of tissue paper.

"That's not helping," I told him.

He closed his eyes.

I opened the box.

My father had never been an orderly man. In life he'd carried a wallet with eleven receipts in it, and a toolbox that rattled, and the ability to lose a pair of glasses on top of his own head. But the box marked PAPERS was a revelation. Everything in it was labeled. Folders, tabbed, in a clean, angular hand, in blue ink. A cardboard accordion file marked HERITAGE FUND, 2012-2015.

I opened the accordion file.

For twenty minutes I forgot to breathe.

It was all there. Every invoice, every check stub, every bank statement. The roofer's bill for the Larkspur's north slope, eighty-four thousand dollars. The depot's foundation work, forty-one thousand. A mason's invoice, a carpenter's invoice, a lumber bill. A running tally, in my father's blue ink, in a neat column down the side of a yellow legal pad: a hundred and nine, a hundred and sixty, a hundred and ninety-eight. The last line: 212,000.00. SPENT. PAID. DONE.

Not one dollar missing. Not a cent unaccounted for.

Clipped to the back, in a fat manila envelope, was a stack of photocopied bank statements from the Ferris Gap Savings Bank, each one marked in red pen. Beside every one, a note, in the same blue ink.

"ADMIN FEE 1,200 - not authorized." "ADMIN FEE 1,350 - ask L.P." "ADMIN FEE 4,000 - I did not approve this." The fees ran for three years, small at first, then bigger, a slow draw on the Heritage Fund's balance by the bank that held it.

And at the bottom of the stack, a typed letter on bank letterhead. Dated June, 2015. Signed, in an extravagant, confident hand, by Lowell Prentiss II.

Dear Mr. Hartigan: In light of discrepancies we have identified in the Heritage Fund's records, the Bank must regretfully request your resignation as Treasurer, to protect the integrity of the Fund. We will not pursue further action at this time. We trust you will understand that this is for the good of the community.

Under it, in my father's hand, in a different color, a different pen, as though written much later and with great deliberation, was a single line.

I did not take a dime. I could not prove who did. They knew it.

I put the file down. Ledger pushed his head under my hand. I sat quite still, as the dust turned in the light, and let it come: the whole slow rolling realization of ten years, of a man who had been shamed in the town where he was born and had packed his car and driven away, rather than let his daughter watch him fight.

He had known. He'd had the receipts the entire time. He could have stood up at that town meeting and said, I have every cent, here it is, and he hadn't. Why hadn't he? Why take the blame?

I knew, and I hated that I knew. Because the other half of that story was a woman with a stove, a bell, a lamp in a window and a room to keep. Because Dot had been standing beside him. Because anyone in a position to ask Lowell Prentiss a question about the bank's books, in public, in front of three hundred people, would find that Lowell had an answer ready about 1983.

"Oh, Dad," I said. "You were protecting them."

The next box was clothes. Flannel shirts, a Navy peacoat, a set of cuff links I'd never seen him wear. It smelled so much like him that I put my face into the wool and stayed there for a full minute, and Ledger, in his patient, ironic way, waited.

The box after that held photographs.

He'd kept them in a shoebox, loose, in no order. Me at three, in a pumpkin costume, with a missing tooth. Me at ten, on the Larkspur veranda, holding a trout. My mother, Joanna, laughing at something off-camera, with the kind of full, open-mouthed delight that I have never once been able to fake. A snapshot of my father's hands, working a lathe. A picture of Dot at the stove. Pictures of friends I had forgotten and houses I had left, the long, ordinary accumulation of a life.

And at the very bottom, under a rubber band, a small square print.

Color, a little faded. A man and a woman, seated on the steps of the Larkspur's veranda, on a bright cold day, with a brown paper bag of apples between them. She was small, with a braid over one shoulder and wire glasses. She wore a gray cardigan. She was laughing. The man beside her had his hair in his eyes and a canvas jacket and a look of such pure, idiotic, astonished happiness that I had to put the photograph down, so I could look at it again.

I turned it over.

In my father's blue handwriting, in ink gone brown: R. + F. October 1983. The day I asked. She said yes.

I read it three times.

The sun moved. A pigeon walked across the roof, claws clicking. Below me, in the kitchen, Marnie was banging pots, and somebody was laughing, and the building smelled, even here, in the highest corner, of fried dough and cinnamon. The most ordinary day in the history of Vermont.

He'd been going to marry her. My father. He'd been twenty-three and in love with a bookkeeper in a gray sweater, with a ring in a stamp drawer, and on the nineteenth of October she had disappeared, and he had stayed.

He had stayed for thirty-two years. He'd run a hardware store. He'd met my mother at a church supper and married her, and been, as far as I knew, entirely happy. I'd never once, in all my life, seen him look at a woman the way he looked at that one.

And I thought: she isn't a thief. I know it now the way I know my own name. A man like that does not love a thief.

At the bottom of the box, folded in a sheet of wax paper, was a postcard.

I almost didn't see it. It had slid under the lining. A cheap drugstore card, the front a photograph of a lake at sunrise, blue and gold, with a stripe of pine along the far shore. On the back, a stamp, a postmark I could barely make out: DULUTH MN. AUG 2019.

Addressed to Frank Hartigan, c/o Dot Hartigan, The Larkspur Inn, Ferris Gap, Vermont. Dot had forwarded it to him. Dot had kept the card after.

My father had died on the fourth of September. Twelve days after it was postmarked.

The writing was the small, upright, exquisite hand I'd come to know like a person's voice. There were only a few lines. I read them slowly, with my finger under each one, as if I were a child.

Frank,

They tell me you are very ill. I think I've known for a year. I should have come. I didn't, and I'm sorry. I couldn't make it safe.

I'm sorry about the room. I should have taken it. I should have taken a lot of things.

I've never stopped counting. Not one day.

Ruth

I sat in the attic of the Larkspur Inn, with a dead man's photographs on my knees and a cat's chin on my wrist, and I felt something I'd have called grief if it hadn't been so much larger.

Sorry about the room.

What room? Which room? What had she done, or not done, with a room?

Eleven boxes. I had opened four. Seven remained, and the last of them, the one at the bottom of the left-hand stack, the one that said DO NOT OPEN UNTIL NELL ASKS in my aunt's block capitals, sat exactly where it had sat for six years, a plain square carton tied with kitchen twine.

I put my hand on it. The cardboard was cool and slightly damp.

"I'm asking," I said, aloud, to a box. "Dad. Dot. Whoever's listening. I'm asking."

Nothing happened. It's the thing about asking. You do it, and the universe goes on being an ordinary day. I lifted the box, and it was lighter than I expected, a few pounds, something that shifted softly and did not rattle. I couldn't make myself cut the twine. I set it down on the trunk beside me, and put my palm on its lid again, gently, the way you'd touch the arm of someone who was sleeping.

Not yet, I thought. And I heard the echo of those two words in a pencil line on a registry page, and understood that I was my aunt's niece after all.

I looked up. Through the dusty gable window, I could see the whole of Ferris Gap laid out like a Christmas village: the green roofs, the white steeple, the long gray river. Beyond the roofs, across the water, the dark bulk of the mill. And in front of the mill, a tiny thread of smoke, the first I had seen in weeks, rising straight into the sky from a third-floor window.

Someone had lit a fire.

A signal, I thought. Or an answer.

Footsteps on the attic stairs. Slow, heavy, deliberate.

"Nell?" said Gabe.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!