By dawn I had been awake for thirty hours and had a theory of law.
It was not a good theory. It was the kind a person builds at five in the morning on a lobby sofa, with a cat on her chest, a cup of Marnie's coffee in her fist and the smell of wet char still in her hair. But it had the virtue of being mine, and by the time the sun came over the ridge and laid a long rose-colored bar across the lobby floor, I had it down to a sentence.
"He said nobody sleeps here," I told Odalys. "He didn't say nobody stays awake."
"That's a very lawyerly distinction for a person in a bathrobe."
"I'm told it's the best kind."
The guests had gone at midnight. Odalys had walked every one of them down to the Hollis Motor Court, six cars in a slow line with their hazard lights on, apologizing in three languages, and she had come back at one with a face like a rinsed plate. The couple from Maine had left a twenty-dollar bill on the desk and a note: Don't let them win. The family from Ohio had left a box of Cheez-Its and a drawing, by the youngest, of a very large cat in a cape. Tom Hale had left without a word, at one-fifteen a.m., in his gray sedan, with the leather bag, and the clink of glass in it.
I had let him go. I'd seen no reason not to. A man who burns down a carriage house in order to close an inn does not leave the building in socks.
Philippa Stroud arrived at nine-fifteen, in her good gray suit and a wool coat the color of a pigeon, with a briefcase in one hand and a paper bag of apple turnovers in the other.
"I brought food," she said. "People in a crisis always forget to eat. It's the leading cause of bad legal decisions."
"You drove forty minutes."
"Thirty-two, with the shortcut. I'm a determined woman." She set the bag on the card table, took a turnover and sat down across from me with her knees together like a lady at a tea. "Now. Tell me what he said. Exactly."
I told her. She listened with her eyes half shut, which I had learned meant she was listening very hard, and at the word vacate she lifted one finger.
"Vacate."
"He said 'ask you to vacate.'"
"Not 'I'm ordering you to vacate.'"
"He said both. First the ask, and then the order. The closure was verbal."
"Verbal." She opened her eyes. They were gray, shrewd and very pleased. "My dear, I've been practicing law in this county for forty-six years. In that time I've been handed more verbal orders than a short-order cook. You know what they're worth?"
"Nothing?"
"Less. A safety closure under the state fire prevention code requires a written order. It must be signed by the marshal. It must cite the specific hazard and the section violated. It must be delivered in hand to the owner, or posted conspicuously on the property, with a statement of the owner's right to appeal to the select board within seven days." She took a bite of turnover and dabbed her mouth. "He's given you none of that. He's given you a speech."
"He said the sixth."
"He's hoping you won't wait for the sixth. He wants you out tonight, so that by tomorrow the building is empty and the will's condition has been breached, and the Historical Society can file for a declaratory judgment on the strength of a closed door." She set the napkin down. "Do you see?"
"The door's not closed."
"Then it's very good that you're sitting in it."
I laughed. It came out slightly hysterical.
"And the will," said Philippa. "I read it for you on the first day, but I want you to hear it once more, with this in mind. 'Open, lit, and staffed, with Room Nine's key on the board and Room Nine made up.' Not 'full.' Not 'solvent.' Not 'licensed by a fire marshal who is first cousin to the bank.' Open. Lit. Staffed. Nell, if you are in this lobby, with the doors unlocked and the lamps on and one person awake at the desk, then the Larkspur Inn is open. I will say so in front of Judge Amato in a clean shirt."
"And if Dennis comes with a deputy?"
"Then he'll find a woman in a bathrobe, sitting in a public lobby, offering him coffee. He may cite you for trespassing in your own house. I'd pay a great deal to see that." She smiled, and for an instant she looked about twenty. "Your aunt hired me in 1991 because she wanted a lawyer who enjoyed being right. I'm told it's a rare talent."
"What about the guests? We can't take them."
"You don't need guests. You need a lit lobby and a pot of coffee and someone at the desk. And you have, I believe, a mayor."
It turned out we had considerably more than a mayor.
I will tell you how the town of Ferris Gap responded to the closure of its beloved inn by a cousin of the bank. It didn't hold a meeting. It didn't write a letter to the editor. It simply showed up.
By ten that morning the lobby had been swept and the fireplace lit. By noon, Iggy Sobel had posted a handwritten rota on the front desk, written out in four-four time, a watch schedule in two-hour shifts with names assigned: LIARS, FIRST WATCH. LIARS, SECOND WATCH. THE PELLETIER FAMILY (WITH WALKER). Marnie brought a fifty-cup percolator from the church hall. The widow Pelletier appeared at one with a quilt and a Bible and the declaration that she had never in her life seen a fire marshal she couldn't outlast. A team of teenagers from the high school turned up at two with a speaker and a deck of cards and a plan to play poker for nickels all night.
At three-ten, Dennis Prentiss arrived with the young deputy and a roll of yellow tape.
He stopped inside the front door. I watched his gaze travel over the room: the roaring fire, the percolator, the quilt, the card game, the teenagers, the widow Pelletier in her armchair with the Bible open on her knees, the entire pile of humanity, and one woman in a bathrobe at the desk, smiling at him over a mug.
"Good afternoon, Marshal," I said. "Coffee?"
"Miss Hartigan." His jaw worked. "I told you the building was closed."
"You did. I'd like to see the order."
"I'll have it by the sixth."
"Then until the sixth, we're a lobby. Anyone can sit in a lobby." I held up the mug. "It's dark roast. Marnie made it."
"There are people sleeping on the sofa."
"There's one," Iggy said, from a recliner. "And it's very comfortable."
Dennis opened his mouth. The widow Pelletier, in a voice like a closing door, began to read aloud from the book of Proverbs, about a man who diggeth a pit. He tried to speak over her. She read louder. The teenagers began, very softly, to hum. After forty seconds of this, with the whole room watching him with expressions of such cheerful, bovine innocence that I nearly lost my composure, Dennis Prentiss rolled up the yellow tape, tucked it under his arm and said, to no one, "I'll be back on the sixth," and left.
The room waited until the cruiser's engine had faded. Then it cheered.
By four, there were seventeen people in the lobby, and two more outside on the veranda, sitting on the porch swing with a thermos and a flashlight, in case.
"This is insane," I said to Tam, who had installed herself in the wing chair by the fire with a blanket and her feet up on a hassock. She had a plate of cheese, a plate of crackers and a look of enormous peace.
"This is Ferris Gap."
"Dennis is going to be furious."
"Dennis has been furious since 1986. He'll adjust." She picked up a cracker. "Nell, you don't know what you've done."
"What have I done?"
"You've done a thing this town hasn't done in forty years. You've asked them to hold something." She chewed thoughtfully. "They've been waiting for a reason."
I thought about that. I thought about it while I walked the lobby at six, carrying a tray of mugs, listening to Wick Tolliver's empty chair at the card table being sat in, with great ceremony, by Ray Novak, who was dealing a hand for two and talking to the empty seat as though Wick were in it. I thought about it at eight, when Gabe came in out of the dark with a toolbox and a stack of plywood and said, without a word of preamble, "I'm going to patch the kitchen wall."
I thought about it at ten p.m., climbing the main stair alone with a flashlight, past the landing, down the long hall of tiny birds, to the door at the end.
The lamp was on. The bed was made. The room smelled of lilac, and the little brass bell on the nightstand had been moved a quarter inch to the left.
Nobody was there.
I sat for a while in the wing chair, with my hand on the worn pale place on its arm, and I did not say anything. I was too tired to say anything. I sat in the lamplight with the whole town of Ferris Gap holding the lobby beneath me, forty feet below, a low murmur of voices and clinking mugs coming up through the floor like the sound of a river, and for the first time since I'd arrived, I felt something I could only describe as housed.
"You're not alone," I said, to the room. "Whoever you are. We're all down there. You could come down."
The radiator ticked. And the bell, a foot from my hand, was perfectly silent.
At eleven, my phone rang. Philippa Stroud.
"I'm sorry to call so late," she said. "I've been thinking about it all day, and I owe you an honesty. I told you the will had a sealed provision I couldn't open before the nineteenth. I didn't tell you the rest."
"What's the rest?"
"Your aunt called me in March of 2023. She added a sentence to the will's conditions. A single sentence. She had me read it back to her three times. I wasn't to share it until the day, but given the circumstances, I think she'd have wanted you to know." A rustle of paper. "'If a woman arrives and signs the registry as R. Ames, Nell is not to call the police, the sheriff or any officer of the law for twenty-four hours. She is to give her tea. She is to give her a night.'"
I stood up.
"Twenty-four hours," I said.
"That's what it says."
"Philippa. Why would Dot think she'd need to say that?"
"Because," said Philippa, very gently, "when a woman who has been missing for forty-two years walks into a town where she's the only person ever named in an arrest warrant, someone is going to want to make a phone call."

